Carlucci's Pizzeria

We found this place after an activity in Powell and selected it because it was the only place open till 11. Pizza was amazing, nice crisp crust with lots of pepperonis that were nice and crisp. Nothing was soggy at all!

Only negative is drinks are 2 Liters or cans, but they had Coke and cups for sharing!

Check it out if you are up North!

The young high school kid working the phone and front of house was great. Super personable and friendly. The kitchen was extremely clean and well maintained. The kids working were efficient and diligent. Our pizza was absolutely incredible. The chicken, bacon and ranch is a must. Loaded with toppings! Size was perfect. Crust was crispy.

Carlucci's Pizzeria is the perfect example of why you should support local!

They have great pub style thin crust pizzas which are leaps/bounds better than the chain pizzas! They have great standard pizzas like Deluxe, Lotta Meat and Veggies, but where they REALLY shine is the Buffalo Chicken pizza and Mexican Pizza, if you want something lighter than you can't go wrong with their Deluxe White.

Don't forget to order a few apps! Mac & Cheese bites with their homemade ranch, or the potato skins, or the mozzarella sticks... Mmm too much good stuff to mention!!

I am pretty sure I could eat their chicken/bacon/ranch pizza every day for the rest of my life! Yum! The Carlucci's crust is B perfection. I get the small which is perfect for dinner and then lunch the next day. And when it's gone, I'm sad and wish I'd gotten a large. I have NEVER had a bad - or even mediocre - experience at Carlucci's. The staff is always exceptionally nice. I wish they delivered but the drive is worth it! 🍕

It was my first time ordering from this place, and it was amazing! The pepperoni, ham, and green olive pizza was delicious! Ingredients are top-notch.

Has a old school flavor to it something that most pizzas places have just lost over the years, part of it is the old school brick ovens but the other part of it is the ingredients they use. The pepperoni has a lot of flavor but they also do another thing most companies don't do any more they season it, and put parmesan cheese on it. Absolutely have to go back again loved it.

Excellent pizza, wing and stromboli. Great service too. Charred pepperoni appetizer... Perfect. Cracker crisp crust. All things we have had are good.

We have been searching for a new favorite pizza place. We decided to drive a little further and give this place a try. My family loved it! We ordered pizza and stromboli. This is hands down the best stromboli I’ve ever had. Even the marinara was outstanding. The pizza was extremely good for a thinner crust and the toppings are definitely premium. Price was a little higher but it was well worth it for the quality. So glad we found this gem. We will be back and definitely recommending it to others to try as well.

I have wanted to try this place ever since I did some work for them awhile back & I finally got the opportunity to try it, and I was very thankful I did. Of you want a true to style Columbus style pizza then definitely don't sleep on Carluccis! The crust is a perfect cracker crust, the sauce is a very tasty savory sauce, the cheese blend is great, and uses my favorite Ezzo old world cup and char pepperoni; all that makes up a solid pie, it also holds up well for leftovers too. We also got the white pizza, and garlic bread with cheese, both of which were fantastic as well. Service was very friendly, fast, and accommodating. Carluccis will definitely be put into the rotation from now on.

DONT SLEEP ON THIS PLACE!

Absolutely outstanding pizza from topping distribution to taste. This place is a winner! One of my new favorites!!!

Carlucci's is it. Super consistent and my favorite local pizza place. All the specialties are good, made fresh and made with care. Prices are pretty reasonable too. I highly suggest you check out Carlucci's as it will NOT disappoint.

Happiest crew I’ve ever seen. Consistently busy. Easily the best pizza and stromboli. Get the hot boss pizza, and tell Steve that Chris from across the street sent you.

I am soooooo happy Dominoes was having issues with their app because it led me to this place. We got a large specialty pizza and the crust is almost exactly like the pizza I had in Rome. Light, fluffy, and crisp, but not too light. You have to try it. The whole pizza itself was just amazing. Looks and tastes are high quality. We also got the fried mushrooms. I was expecting the typical little button mushrooms but nope! They were slices of full on mushrooms and the horse radish dipping sauce complimented them very well. Highly recommend this place.
***Just had the Deluxe Pizza from here and wanted to share. Sooooo good! Can’t wait to try every specialty pizza on the menu.

We have lived in the area for 10yrs now and Carlucci's always delivers a solid pizza that is reasonably priced. The crust is light, thin, slightly crispy with the just right amount of chew. The sauce is excellent and is savory with just a hint of spice and sweetness that works well. The cheese is the perfect blend that melts well and is delicious and fresh. The other toppings are all of excellent quality and freshness. We usually get a pepperoni and sausage, the ezzo pepperoni is perfect and the crumbled sausage is an excellent Italian style that pairs well with the spice of the pepperoni.

This is truly a favorite of our family. They are one of very few places that offer the crumbled sausage. Which is a favorite of mine. My go to is a pepperoni sausage and mushroom pizza. Never had bad pie from here. Truly one of the gems in the Columbus pizza community.

New to the area and looking for a good pizza spot. Got the Supreme a few days ago and was not disappointed. Great toppings and good, thin, and crispy crust. Look forward to trying Stromboli.

The best pizza in Columbus. Every single time. Always consistent. Always high quality and delicious. If you’re in the Dublin area this should be your go to.

I like this pizza. Nice and crispy! And the seen to be Blue Jacket fans! I recommend!

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!!! The staff is amazing and always fresh!! Hands down one of the best places I’ve eaten!!!

Never given 5 stars for any reviews. I really enjoyed the pizza. It had a very thin crust which I can't find anymore. Had a good old school pizza used to taste like. Garlic Parmesan wings were cooked just right and good flavor. The big pun sub I didn't order or try because it had to much meat. Overall if I didn't live to far this would be my go to pizza