Pizza Pantry

Pizza Pantry is famous locally for a reason. They have my favorite subs ever. There is something EXTRA special about them. Their turkey club cannot be beat. The bread, meat, cheese... AMAZING. Their pizza and wings are always perfect as well. They have a really delicious crust. The owners are kind and friendly and you can't beat their prices. Order and you won't be disappointed

We live close by and this has become our go to. Hands down best pizza and fish fry in the area! Have never had a bad meal from here and they have excellent customer service. My boys also LOVE the chicken nuggets!

We got take-out tonight and it was delicious. The service was fantastic. It was super easy to call, order and pickup my food. My son is picky and he loved the chicken fingers and fries. My husband is always on the lookout for a good sub and he was happy with his sub.

Update;
I attended a private event here today and the service was amazing! The employees went above and beyond to help entertain the two little kids who were there. They also made sure everything was cleaned as we went and topped off. If you're looking for a nice place to have a gathering, this is it.

Very impressed with their food. friendly staff and the food was all very well made. We will definitely order from them again!

The pizza is great and so is the service! I'm glad we stopped here.

Thats said, here are some FYIs for future travelers: it's kind of off the beaten path in a small town. We came expecting a sit-down place, but they only have three tables (one inside and two picnic tables outside); this place is mostly take-out. It took about 30 min for our pizza (we weren't in a hurry so this was fine with us). I overheard that they don't serve by the slice.

Great! I got the personal pan pizza and garlic Parmesan wings. Both were absolutely delicious! Highly recommend!

First time visit yesterday. Looking forward to going back, n the food was good, but the owner was great. My son won his music trivia ? and won bag of peanuts. The rest of the time waiting for our food and while eating was great. Owner so friendly and was fun to talk to about music. Nice the owner is happy and appreciates customers n proud to be in business 35 yrs

I highly recommend this place! We visited on Friday night while camping at Darien Lake. It's a short drive from the park. We loved the food and service. I also loved the small waiting area when we picked up the pizza. Very warm place nicely decorated. They deliver or you can eat in. There is a slight up charge if you use a credit card to cover the fees. If near this place and looking for some great chow check them out!

Surprisingly good pizza in a rural venue. The owner is a gem. I had tree sap from elsewhere on my windshield. I asked if he had a rag I could use to try to get it off and he produced glass cleaner and then helped me to scrub my windshield. The Pizza Pantry is a good place for smaller groups to use for receptions. The menu for ours was excellent.

Excellent pizza and excellent service

Recommend 100%

Pizza is amazing here one of the best I've ever had. Only downfall is no dining in but there is a picnic table outside which is nice. Definitely recommend!

Just outside Darien lake in a small town there is this hidden. Gem the pizza was awesome nice big fluffy crust we couldn't put it down. Prices were on par and our order was up quick and fast. Two of us shared a large and that was more than enough with 4 extra slices.

Food was delicious, servers were very nice. 15/10 would recommend visiting at least once. Great after a trip to darien lake! The man who served us (didnt catch his name) was extremely kind and respectful. Absolutely loved everything about it. I cant say enough good things 💜💜

We stopped by on a Thursday at 3pm - 4 kids and us parents. We'd spent the last 4 days eating from a microwave while staying at Kingdom Bound at Darien Lake Theme Park, but don't let that taint this review at all. The pizza was fabulous! It was real cheese, not the oily kind and there was plenty of it. The dough was think - thicker than pizza hut - but it was real, not processed. We ordered ahead and it was waiting for us. There were only two other people in attendance. The service was great, the bathrooms were clean, and we couldn't have been happier - except they serve Pepsi instead of Coke :-)

A great place for a private party or reception!!! Our group of about 30 enjoyed the private dining experience after a day visiting Darien Lake Amusement Park this summer. Service was great. Food was Good. Facilities were clean. Price as Right. I would recommend this place to any group visiting Darien Lake. I could not have asked for anything more!!!

I went there with a group for an event and we were in the reception hall section. Patrick was an amazingly attentive host with wonderful hospitality! It was a pleasant atmosphere and the food was excellent! I would definitely recommend anyone to go to Pizza Pantry!

Got the sheet pizza and was cooked perfectly. Also have really good prices and so worth it!!! Thanks!

Pizza and wings are great! We ended up ordering twice over two days. Convenient for ordering from Darien Lake. We will be back next visit!

Always enjoy the atmosphere , like an amusement park next door. The owners are friendly , great people. Like to see them and view the improvements they make to the area every year. Better and better

Tried pizza on the way to Darien lake for the first time and loved it. I really liked that it was not greasy. Dough and sauce were delicious. Will definitely get another pizza from there.