Cascarelli's Pizza

Pizza is great. The atmosphere is awesome. We went to the "other" one, and they were rude. So got back on the road, and stumbled across this place. Glad it happened. Definitely recommended over the other of the same name.

Very nice place. Roomier than it looks from the outside. It runs deep and is accommodating for large groups of people. The staff were friendly and very attentive. The food was delicious. My first cut into my lasagna was all cheese! Yummy!

What a cool place! People had recommended we try this place for a while, so on our drive back home from South Haven, MI we decided to detour a bit and stop. They did not disappoint! I got the Frankie's Pie which has their famous meatballs, red onion, mushroom & basil...it was incredible! Thin, cracker style crust and the sauce was great, slightly sweet but not too much. My wife had the lasagna and she really liked that too. We took leftovers home of course! 😋

We had the Supreme Pizza 🍕. Very good generous toppings prepared very well. We stopped in on a Thursday night, and the place was very busy. Our waitress was very nice and accommodating.
We be back!

The Gluten-free pizza was the best I've had at a restaurant. Was a thinner crust but not super thin and crunchy like most places. Definitely recommend

The food was excellent! I had a supreme deep dish pizza (add bacon) It was easily one of the best pizzas I have had. My daughter had the Chicken Alfredo and couldn’t stop talking about how good it was. My wife had the Baby Chicken pizza and my son had a cheese pizza. The only problem we had was deciding what to get because there were so many things that sounded so good! Also it is fair to note that the menu changes during the day so burgers and sandwiches are not offered after 2pm.

First time I ate there was when I was 11 years old. It was the best pizza I ever had. 44 years
later I returned this time with my wife who is from Minnesota who has never had a pizza from Cascarelli's. Neither one of us were disappointed. It is Still the BEST pizza as far as I'm concerned in the state of Michigan!!!!
Thanks Cascarelli's for bringing back good memories and for making new ones. WE WILL BE BACK!!!!! 😀

Party of six. Seated quickly. Very nice atmosphere. Friendly service. Food was amazing. Highly recommend turkey club and chicken Alfredo!

Thank you! It was delicious! this is a worthy place for a good dinner with good friends.

I've eaten here many times over the years. Fridays and Saturdays are usually pretty busy. Their food is good and it's a good place to have dinner or lunch...it can be a bit on the pricey side depending on what you get.

The food was amazing, but we waited over an hour for our pizza order. The pianist was great and so special to have him come in to perform. ❤

Appetizer were great, the pizza was delicious. The pies we're about $20+ drinks were about $3 each. It can add up quickly. We will go again

I've been sleeping on this place that has been no more than 30 minutes away from me my whole life. We were quite happy to find they had Founders Rubaeus on nitro tap. When the meatball appetizer came, they were delicious, and my wife mentioned how they were the "real homemade deal." Shortly thereafter, we received the pizza, Fifi's Favorite. Didn't realize the kick it was going to deliver, but we were ok with it as it was hard to stop eating! Plain and simple, I should have listened to others years ago when they said come here.

We enjoyed our Veggie Lovers and Ham/Sausage Pizzas from Cascarelli's this weekend!
Called ahead and they text me as to when they were ready for me to come in and get them.
We admire their precautions during this time. We drove from Marshall to pick these up.
They were well worth the drive! Cheesy, great sauce! Yum!

The food is always amazing. The waitress was great.

The only issue we had was the seat we were in the ceiling was leaking water. The waitress offered to move us, but we were almost finished.

Great pizza, service is always good. Have eaten here for years! Highly recommended.

Have been coming here for 20+ yrs. and I can't believe I haven't reviewed here. Great atmosphere, great staff, and great food! We've watched many of the staff grow up and move on and love them all. Addicted to Annie's Bread, the Spinach Artichoke Dip, and the pizza. Cannot find Spanish Peanuts anywhere like theirs!

First time there today. Spaghetti was good, meatballs are phenomenal. Pizza was very tasty and the sauce was some of the freshest I've had. Toppings all the way to the edge. We tried the pepperoni and sausage. Also, the Grandson.

What a great little Italian place with delicious pizza and fresh roasted nuts. Purchased a nice selection of flavored nuts to take home. Notable favorites were the red skin peanuts, Maple pecans and Sriracha honey cashews. The service was great and I have to say the pizza was delicious ! I have the chicken and portobello mushroom pizza with olive oil instead of sauce. Just like I like! A great suggestion when I mentioned that I liked white pizzas. Was really enamored with their mug club artisan mugs! So cool that they are all hand made and no two are alike! Makes me wish I lived closer! IG @withlovefrommiche Follow me for Michigan eats!

1st time there. We had the vegetarian pizza. Very good when we get back this way we will be back.