Panzera's Pizza of Upper Arlington

This is the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Generous with the toppings, all the ingredients were top quality, and the owner is a great guy. Five stars!

Some of the best pizza around. The owner makes it and he spreads twice the amount of cheese as other pizza shops (literally) Good crust, great sauce. Don't sleep on this place. Give it a shot

Love it!!! Very nice and remembered my name and how I liked my pizza after the first order. Homemade dough and sauce. Bon appetite!

Called to place a pick up order and the owner was extremely friendly.

Pizza was phenomenal - perfectly chewy dough, thick sauce with a little spice, those thick pepperonis everyone likes. We had ours with banana peppers and highly recommend. The chef salad was also wonderful with all the goods: cheese, fresh tomatoes, salami

With pizza as good as this and such a friendly owner, supporting local business is easy. Planning to make this our regular pizza spot.

Just tried out a large sausage and pepperoni pizza and the cheesy garlic bread. Both were amazing and had tons of cheese. Crust is tasty and on the thinner side, sauce is thick and flavorful and as I said before, tons of cheese.

I highly recommend Panzeras.

I love this thin crust pizza and it's nice to support a small business instead of a chain. Just wanted to provide an update 3/31/2022
Small business with a great thin crust pie. I got a small pizza with extra cheese and I swear there's over a couple of pounds of cheese on it! Go check him out.

The pizza is really good and the owner cares about the quality of his ingredients. He gets he rolls for the subs from an Italian bakery everything is fresh. Customer experience when ordering etc may not be the focus here but the food is and that's what's important and they are really nice.

Excellent pizza!!! My favorite in Columbus. Very flavorful and tasty. My favorite is Pep, 1/2 Sausage and double cheese. Managed by local dedicated owner who is very proud of his superior product. Gotta try this pizza!!

😁Closest to a NY Slice in Columbus, without a doubt. 🍕Quality ingredients, loads of cheese, perfect sauce. Crust is foldable, even though it's in squares (🙃). This is our Go-To pizza in Columbus. 🥰 Carryout only. It's a one man show. Not connected to Panzera's in Grandview.

First time customer. It was super good pizza. Reminded me of Fort Ball Pizza Palace from my home town in Fostoria. Will certainly go back.

Awesome pizza! Had a unique request from a picky 5 year old and they offered a great suggestion she loved (and that saved us money). Will definitely be returning!

Nice local place and the owner is super friendly. Our favorite things to get are the subs, followed by pizza and the garlic loaf. I love that the crust and sauce are totally homemade.

Delicious pizza every time. My favorite local Columbus pizza place. I love coming here to get a pizza while I have a beer at the daily growler next door. Definitely worth checking out!

They actually walked my pizza to me one night when their car wasn't working. They truly just want to get people yummy, tasty pizza! The pizza is so delicious, the ingredients are obviously fresh and it's just as good the next day. Buy local!

Awesome pizza I wish I had found years ago. Fresh dough, tasty sauce, but the cheese is where it's really at.

Friendly staff as well.

Tim is a wonderful host who knows his customers and serves them with efficiency and a great product!!!

If you love cheese, then this is the place for you! Pizza is good and the owner is personable.

Good pizza, friendly local owner who is in there making the food every time I've walked in to pick up a pie.

Really delicious pizza. Great crisp crust. The sauce is just right. My new favorite pizza!

This pizza is something special. Truly the best pizza I've had in Columbus. Wow. Thanks!