Papa Tino's Pizzeria

We had a giant pizza and a salad. The food was great! Would highly recommend for a party. We fed six hungry teenagers, two adults, and still had a few slices left over to have for lunch tomorrow! The pizza barely fit on my stove top and the delivery lady was very kind and brought it into our house for us. We've ordered party pizzas before, but I've never seen a pizza this big!

First time ordering food from this establishment, and OMG it was great. We ordered online and got the pizza and wings combo, a fried haddock dinner, and a couple peanut butter brownies.

That was the best pizza I’ve had in awhile, same with the wings. I’ll attach a picture of one of the brownies I got because it looked like advertisement quality. Go try the food here!

i love this place! we got a huge pizza for 4 adults and 4 kids and it was perfect! it lasted us a couple days after getting it too so that’s a bonus!! the wings were also delicious too! even though it kinda cost a bit much but the food was worth it! i would def go back here when i visit again!

First time eating there in a few years. I had the chicken riggies and my husband had the pizza sub. Both were amazing! His sub was loaded! The chicken riggie dinner is enough for two meals, and the sauce on it was so delicious! Got the peanut butter brownies for dessert,
but we were too full! Staff is very friendly as well. Check it out. You won't regret it.

My first time and I was blown away by the pizza and wings. The pizza I ordered a large (thinking about other places) and the thing was huge and loaded with toppings, the taste was great.
I will be back but now I know I have order a smaller pie.
Thank you for the great food.

The only pizza I have found in Watertown to be good. I'm a Executive Chef and have tried multiple pizza places and cannot bring myself to order anymore but Papa Tino's.

Went with my kiddo and a friend for pizza. We were so glad we could dine in. It was pretty chilly outside and raining. My son had a pepperoni and cheese that was really good, I had a Supreme that was delish, and our friend had a meatball sub. She said that was good! We all had the Greek salad and really enjoyed how fresh everything was. Was filling and helped warm us from the weather outside. The staff were very friendly and happy to answer any questions or check to make sure we were okay. Definitely going back!

We sat and ate personal pizzas, the food was good. It was very busy!

Great counter help, quick friendly service, great sub. Definitely will be back.

Pizza was good. 30 minute drive but worth it. Will be visiting again.

Only thing to say is if you haven't tried the party size pizza. It's GIGANTIC. I had to bring it home in the bed of my GMC Sierra 1500. Best pizza around. Definitely the hidden gem of Watertown.

Been her in Watertown for 5 years, this is by far the best pizza.
Hot and delicious!!!
Now if they would do a deep dish Chicago style.

Great pizza and the mango habanero wings are the best.

We ordered two of their giant pizza's for a church event and the food was excellent. I was most impressed with their delivery time. We requested a delivery at noon and the driver showed up four minutes early. Perfect timing! We've eaten here a few times and have no complaints. They probably won't be earning a Michelin Star, but not a bad place to eat.

I have been searching all of upstate New York for some good wings. The wings here were so good I'm leaving this review. They were hot and crispy. One tip is DO NOT ask for extra sauce, they understand that principle here, they were spicy and each wing had a nice thick layer of sauce on it that had me worried and sweating every time I went back for more. 11/10 highly recommend

Came in from out of town looking for authentic Italian pizza,they did not disappoint. Super fast & friendly delivery.very happy customer

I love coming here when I come home to visit family. The Buffalo wings are great and their Calzones are awesome!

We live a few miles away from Papa Tino’s. First of all I’m thrilled they deliver to me, but most importantly, the Pizza is always pipping hot when we get it. The toppings are generous and always consistent. The drivers are always pleasant and professional too. Well done!

I order from Papa Tinos whenever I get in a craving for buffalo chicken wing pizza and/or wings and I have not been disappointed once! My food comes in about an hour from when the order is placed and it is still delicious and hot upon arrival. Their staff is courteous when they take my call as well as when they deliver the food. I definitely would recommend them to anyone who wants pizza and wings!

Best pizza and wings in town. No dry pizza here as they use plenty of sauce and their toppings are fresh. The wings are meaty and the sauces are full of flavor and there's enough for extra dipping if you like.