Crusty's Pizza

OMG!!! Had pizza there tonight! Best pizza I have had in a long time!! The thin crust was perfect! We did a half pepperoni, half artichoke, sun dried tomatoes, Italian sausage, and Parmesan cheese. The crust was so well done it held up the heaviest yummy packed slice! The service was great and the guys working were super nice!! I’m stoked and will definitely be back!!

Arrived right at opening on an off day. Nobody but me and my sister. If you like thin crust pizza, you came to the right place. Casual atmosphere with a peerless, eclectic music selection that made me smile. Everyone that works there are absolute dolls. Would like to come back on a live music night.

Just visiting up here but if I come back I'm going here. It's my Lil hole in the wall
The pizza is made very fresh and it is really really good! Recommend 10 out of 10.

Great thin crust pizza with lots of flavor. Try the Big Crusty’s if you like meat. Fun music from the late 60’s to early 70’s. Good selection of locals beers from McCall brewing.

Good stuff!
Had the Smoke Jumper and two other pies, all were very good.
Crispy and thin dough and crust style but not too dry or burned at all.

HONEST REVIEW: First time here in McCall, was craving pizza found this place.
Absolutely delicious , perfect thin crust, we got the Margarita pizza.
DEFINITELY Recommend to anyone who is hesitant! Awesome dudes working there🤙
Pricing is very fair.

Fantastic pizza, wine and beer after a long day of riding side by sides in the mountains. Best pizza ever!!

Saddle season so we were the only one's around. Pizza was great. Had the Butcher Block and the flavor combinations were great. Wish I could remember the beer I had because that was great too.

Just the best pizza and plenty of beer to choose from. Great staff, loved sitting by the pellet stove. Must eat here if you love pizza!!!

We had 3 different pizzas, a salad and cheesy bread last night. The food was fresh, piping hot and arguably the best pizza I have ever had. Crusty’s , y’all have made me a new regular!

We are in McCall visiting for the weekend from the Treasure Valley. Locals recommend Crusty’s Pizza to us and boy oh boy was it good! If you like thin crust pizza (and even if you don’t!) we definitely recommend! It was flavorful and memorable. Can’t wait to try it again when we come back next year. Please bring a Crusty’s to the Treasure Valley!!!!

Amazing pizza! I ordered the "BIG CRUSTY".
At first I was apprehensive...but I was amazed.
This pizza has its own pizza section in the pizza world 🌎. From the impressive mix of fresh flavors to the crust which stands alone to the Asiago cheese and garlic punch. I experienced all the flavors individually was totally different and amazing!.
PS
I was only able to finish half if a pizza 🍕.
Dinner tomorrow today!

First time to Crusty's and it was kinda slow.... We ordered 2 12" and large salad.
Salad was very large, lots of veg varieties in it and crunchy, not soggy!!👍 Both pizzas were great, a pesto chicken and Big Crusty. Sourdough crust was thin & crispy and both had generous amounts of toppings!!👍👍
Good job guys, we'll be back as we are locals and believe in our McCall businesses. Nice playlist too.

Always have had a good experience here. The pizza has been just right with done-ness and right amount of ingredients. I always felt like the employees and owner took good care of my family. The whole vibe is worth jumping into, especially with live music, good pizza and good beer.

Love the pizza! Laid back and friendly atmosphere. Live music Wednesdays and Sundays, so get there early and grab a good spot before the crowds!

The Pizza, Service, and Location is awesome. The owner is super friendly and I highly recommend this spot. We will definitely be back anytime we are in town.

Great spot to grab a pizza and chill after a great MCCALL ADVENTURE. THANK YOU FOR THE GREAT GRUB.

I’ve been a pizza freak for over 50 years and Crusty’s is the best I’ve ever had! Fantastic thin crust cooked perfectly. The exact amount of sauce (red) needed and the toppings were fresh & delicious. Plenty of cheese and I liked that there wasn’t 3” of plain dough at the top. Lastly, there wasn’t a drop of wet grease on the pan. Like Arnold says “I’ll be back”

Amazing pizza!! Received exactly what we ordered. Definitely will order again our next time back in McCall!

Super guys making pies! Elk sausage on multiple pizzas! Low key spot, not many tables but good beer selection while you wait to take your pizza to go. Friendly service!