Mario's Pizzeria

Old school style pizza joint with great service and pizza. Great prices on pizza.

I have loved pizza my entire life but most places don't come close to this Mario's Pizzeria in small Oriskany Falls, NY. The garlic knots are amazing, the everything wings, crisper to perfection and ham topped pizza. All made with love and devotion. The result is something so delicious it is hard to find anywhere else other than in the middle of nowhere, Upstate New York.

I haven't had pizza in four months and this was my amazing reward to waiting. I have been coming here for over 30 years. My family, no matter where they are always ask me when I am going next. They long for Mario's as I do every time I have been away for awhile. Tonight my brother was in town from Denver and all we could talk about was going to Mario's. We had this meal to carry on the traditions we had with our parents and grandparents. We enjoyed it as I know they would want us to. Mario, the owner has become close to my family over the years and it makes the meal special every time. It's not going to a pizza place, it's like going to a family member's kitchen for a special dinner. I can't wait to have it again soon.

I was recommended this place when I came into town by a client. I'm from Texas but have a soft spot, read craving, for a NY Slice. Always. The spot it self was cool. The staff were very nice and the pizza. Oh man. The pizza. Crispy, cheesy, good topping distribution, pepperoni not to greasy. The dough was superb. The kind of crust you enjoy as much as the pie. I may never make it to this part of NY again. But if I do. I'll be stopping back by here.

Wonderful service and the food was amazing. Their Calzones are MASSIVE. The portions are very big for the price. I consider it worth checking out! Highly recommend.

Nice little place.
I often eat out when on the road, most of the time the food sucks. Not this time. The salad reminded me of the salad I had at a Italian restaurant in Germany, when I was their last.
The food was Great.
Hopefully, I'll be back.

The most amazing pepperoni rolls I've had! Great place to grab slices of delicious pizza. Friendly staff!

Great pizza and calzon, good prices, the two lady's that make the pizza and food are the best!

Love Marios! HUGE delicious calzones that I can eat for more than one sitting.. pizza is amazing, greens are yummy.. I travel quite a ways to eat here because we've never had a bad meal. Mario and his wife are so pleasant, as well as their staff!

Love Mario's I stop here all the time great pasta pizza wings and the antipasto is perfect everytine

Mario's has always been a great staple in Oriskany Falls. I moved away years ago. I went back recently and nothing had changed. The owner's and their product was as good as we remembered. This time my granddaughter got to eat there. It was wonderful. Thanks Mario and Lucia. We love you guys.

Always one of my very favorite places to stop when I'm in the area. The food is outstanding and the service is always top notch!

Ate there for the first time with my friends tonight. Must say it was the best garlic pizza I’ve ever had. The rest of the food was amazing also. Cute waitress, polite people, very clean and a reasonable price. Definitely will come back again when back in this area.

Take out only (pandemic), but great food! Slices were good - large and loaded with toppings. The sàusage and pepper roll w red sauce for dipping was out of this world delicious. Nice balance of flavorful sausage, peppers, cheese. Certainly enjoyable w/o sauce,but with the dipping sauce - oh my!

I absolutely recommend this restaurant 👏🏻 Mario & Lucia are the owners. They treat their customers like family. It's very clean. The food is absolutely delicious 🙌🏻💗 The greens r so rich and tasty. Pizza is like u just arrived in NYC.

I love Chicken Subs and They make awesome greens extra cherry peppers 🌶 😋 🙌 👌 😍 yum!

Stopped to have lunch with a friend and was like I never moved out of the area. The fish fry was right on the money and a big portion of fish. Mario and his wife came over to make sure we where happy with everything multiple times. Will be going back soon !!!!! Miss there food

Great pizza and a nice motorcycle theme going on glad I stopped by on my way through.

True Italian food made true true Italian people in a small town setting. If you haven't tried it you must because you will always go back, guaranteed. Mario and Lucia are beautiful, caring people. The food is amazing, fresh and delicious!!..

Wonderful Scicilian pizza!

Love everything about this place. I have known the owners for most of my life. Great staff and most importantly the best pizza ever! They have other tasty eats definitely worth a trip to this small town restaurant.