Forest Hill Restaurant

What a gem! Delicious food, generous portions, unique dishes, wonderful folks, and excellent service that is so rare these days! We can't wait to go back!

This is my very first review. I couldn't let this gem of a restaurant go unnoticed. I ordered the haddock casino which was unbelievable. House salad/ dressing was also very good. Big portions and fair prices. Wish I could take this restaurant back home to Indiana with me. Wouldn't hesitate to go back.

I was told about this restaurant a few years ago.But because of my busy worke schedule unfortunately I wasn't able too make it .Then it was bought up again. I tried it and I was very impressed with the food it was very delicious. And fresh I got the shrimp soprano I've eaten off of it for two days very nice size portion the bar tender was very nice and the place is very clean in side everyone was very nice.
Only down side was that iam a women of color and Iwas getting a few stares.And come too find out it was the owner. Maybe it wasn't anything personal 🤔 probably not use too ppl of color visiting his establishedment.But I will diffennitely be back.

Such a gem in North Greece! Love this place. The food is so good, and the service is great. The atmosphere is like a family gathering where it gets loud at times with everyone talking, but thats not so bad. Its better than having loud music to contend with.

The local Happy place for North Greece! The food is Great but the company is always better

We have been coming here for awhile. Hilton has a LOT of restaurants all with wood fired pizzas, bar food etc. Forest Hill is beyond. Amazing diverse menu, EXCELLENT proportions, NOT the usual mundane. Jaime the server can handle the whole dining room blind folded, and Doug the bartender will make you feel like your on Cheers. Complete with an actual FULL pour on a glass of wine. We LOVE it here and are always full and satisfied. Only downfall, no reservations on Fridays so get there early!!!!

First time there. Food was excellent, service was great. Good size menu. Barmaid was very professional and personal. Portions are good size, prices reasonable. Will be stopping in there again for sure. Very impressive.

Forest Hill restaurant the food price cannot be absolutely delicious. Everything on the menu is phenomenal large portions great service great place for family and friends to dine.

Great drinks, food, and service. Clean and well run. What more can you ask! Thank you. We'll be back.

The food was amazing! The chicken parmigiana was delicious! Don’t even get me started on the two sides. Hands down the BEST corn I have ever had at a restaurant! Definitely the perfect spot to hit after a nice day at Niagara Falls!

Excellent! First time at establishment, honestly never heard of. It's a hidden gem. The food was SO good. The blue cheese dressing was delicious, thick chunky, and pair perfectly with salad. Fried calamari was really good. The broiled seafood platter was cooked perfectly and included haddock, stuffed shrimp, scallops, and clams casino. The stuffing on the shrimp was so unique and yummy. Others in party enjoyed their dishes too. The restaurant is pretty small and filled up fast. Will definitely be back, so good!!

I've been wanting to try this place for the past couple of years and I finally did tonight. It was the best meal I've had out in a long time. Everything was delicious and they give you large portions. I will definitely be back soon!

Have been coming here for years. It is a hidden gem to put it lightly. My wife and I have never had a bad meal. We frequently bring friends for the first time and they are always happy with pricing, selection and quality of food. Jeanine and Jamie are 2 of the best servers around and make everyone comfortable. If you haven't been there you really need to get there. You will not be disappointed.

Love eating here when I'm in town. Delicious, creative dishes packed with so much flavor and fresh ingredients. Always excellent service and attention to detail. We didn't have reservations but luckily got it in right when they opened. The place filled up fast.

First time visiting this restaurant despite having heard of it forever. So glad we took the drive - totally worth it. The chicken saltimbocca was one of the best we ever had and the Tuscan Chicken was delicious. Jeanine our server was friendly and knowledgeable. Great night all around.

We have been longtime customers of Forest Hill and have always loved it there. Mike, the owner, is a great guy that puts out a delicious meal for a very reasonable price. Even during this current situation the food remains spectacular! Shout out to Jimmy in the kitchen! We had haddock Cleopatra and it's hard to find this anywhere else as good as it is here.
Mike & Lauri Davis

Wanted to jump on here and say thank you! We just returned home from a 'back-to-basics' vaca and the whole family was in need of a good, home-cooked meal, without me having to cook it tonight, still unpacking lol! I had the shrimp gorgonzola, my son had the pasta and meatballs, hubbie had the wing dings and potato skins, daughter had chicken fingers and french onion soup. Absolutely Delicious! Still really hot for a take-out dinner. Everyone Happy! This shrimp gorgonzola is comfort food served right, I lost count of how many large, perfectly cooked shrimp were in this dish! Wow! We go on this trip every year, and as of today, I am starting a new tradition of ordering Forest Hill for dinner when we return! Excellent, Thank You!

Excellent food, service
Price is right, and the portions....
Fugetabouit

We have been going there since before we got married and had our babies. We have been going there for 33years. We have three baby's. They are 30, 27 and 23. They are all grown up and it is still the only restaurant we really go to. Everyone there is great form the bartender Tina to the wait staff Jamie and Janeane. They have great food and great prices and the places is always clean and has a great atmosphere. When we go we see a lot of the same people there. It is a great place and you really have to try you won't be disappointed. My name is Tina Jackson and I am not the bartender Tina you will love it there. Try its

A small bar and restaurant make this a cozy comforting place. The food is delicious, my personal favorite is the Eggplant Parm, great steak and the chef always has new and original recipes on the specials board. The servings are huge, always need to bring a doggy bag home with us! Staff is attentive. Great place highly recommend! If you are going with more than 6 people you should call and make reservations seating is limited.