Sergio’s Pizza

I was in the area for business and I wanted pizza. This was the closest place and was awesome. I ordered a large pepperoni and black olive pizza. The staff was extremely friendly and the food delicious. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

We made two trips this weekend after a long day of soccer. Pizza was fantastic, loaded with toppings and cheese. Owner was exceptionally friendly, chatted about sports/soccer with another employee who were genuinely engaging. Returned the next day and ate in. Again, same service, same smiles and very consistent great pizza!

Huge slices, tons of toppings with extra love.

You can tell someone took their time spacing the buffalo chicken out evenly and thoroughly to the edge. I'm not complaining but there were so many toppings I couldn't fold the crust! The crust was thin like it should be for Brooklyn style pizza.

This is the spot to go for pizza in Malta

Love Sergio’s and the staff!!!! There is a gentleman that works here that watched my daughter drop our pizza, he instantly came to check on us and made us a new pizza! He even saved the old pizza from the garbage. It was messed up but stayed in the box.

Sicilian is just so good. Dough is perfectly done. Sauce is great, pepperoni is very good. Garlic knots are very good as well. Store is clean, sodas cold. Friendly staff. Will be back!

First time ordering a whole pie here. There wasn't a bite without toppings on it. You could taste the maple oozing out of the bacon. Perfect amount of ranch, enough to taste it but not swimming in it.

We also got a grilled chicken panini and chicken francaise. For being a pizza joint, this panini rivals and sub/sandwich shop. The beauty is in the simplicity of the recipe and then authenticity of the ingredients. It's just chicken, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella but it comes together like heaven in your mouth.

Did I mention they make their own doughs and breads? House made panini rolls and pizza doughs. Found myself eating the complimentary bread that comes with the salad plain because it was so squishy, no condiments required.

My only regret is not taking more pictures.

Pizza is very good. I order here fairly often. Maybe that's why I'm fat? Highly recommend!

Love this place affordable, tasty. highly recommend! favorite and a must try pizza is garlic knot pizza and my favorite sandwhich is the grilled chicken panini! Favorite pizza shop in Malta.

The pizza is great and some of the best I’ve found in the area. Tyler served me and was very personable, he greeted me and helped me navigate the many pizza slice options available. The taste and consistency keeps me coming back, but people like Tyler make me glad I stayed!

I’m originally from NYC metro area and this is the best NY style pizza north of Wappinger Falls. I love real NYC, real Chicago, real Detroit, and healthy Nine Miles east but if it’s not genuine I don’t go back. I’ll be going back to Sergios when I want NY style.
Not only that - but when I arrived ten minutes early for my pre-order and it wasn’t ready they apologized and threw in the Garlic knots!! Customer service is a 10 out of 10.

Absolutely delicious! Our new favorite pizza place. The marinara is the best we have ever had. Highly recommend!

Awesome environment, owned by an honest businessman. Really friendly people, and the pizza will surprise you. Full of toppings so you get what you pay for plus some. Amazing

Delivery driver was super nice. Food took a bit to get here but it was worth the wait. Food was good. Will order from again.

Best pizza ever. Tyler is amazing and the entire staff at sergios goes above and beyond. There’s no pizza like it in the capital region. I’ll never go anywhere else

Great pizza by the slice. Their Buffalo Chicken slice is a meal in itself and it's delicious. Pinwheels and sandwiches too. They're open late. We got slices at 9:45pm, 15 minutes before closing, they were fresh and great tasting. Great prices, staff are awesome, easy in and out.

I was headed into 5 Guys but the smell lured me into Sergio’s instead, and I’m glad it did. I’m not sure if I have ever experienced such great customer service as I did at Sergio’s. Everyone working was so friendly and everything we tried (and we tried a lot of it) was soooooo good. Favorite new pizza spot for sure! 🍕 👍🏼

Great service. They gave us free pizza because they were closing for Easter.

Finally a good pizzeria in Malta, NY. So good! NYC style pizza by the slice and pie. Great salads too! 😋

Great location for lunch, lots of great options to choose from, clean restaurant throughout, the owner Tyler is very friendly and accommodating. Try the cream brûlée cheesecake 🥮

Came here with a couple of coworkers and we all really liked the food. The service was really good, too; server was eager to tell us what pizza was what, brought it to our table, even offered us a dish they were trying out free of charge. Highly recommend if you're craving a slice!