Fatzo's Subs & Pizza of Sturgeon Bay

Stopped in to have a quick lunch and the food was by far the best food we’ve had in door county. We’ve tried fancy sit downs but nothing could top these subs! Fresh, hot, and fairly priced. Not to mention the customer service was great, highly recommend!

My husband and I are here for the weekend on our anniversary trip. We’ve been away an order delivery or carry out.
We are far from disappointed. The meatball sub was absolutely amazing! I added jalapeños. Both the ordering delivery and overall service was amazing. Thank you for making the start of our weekend great.

So great! The subs here are amazing and they can customize them fit your any mood! VERY kid /family friendly, and quick service. Nothing I did not like about this awesome sub shop.

Stopped here for lunch because of the positive reviews. They weren't wrong. Awesome sandwiches at a great price. Starred this one on my map. Will definitely go back when in the area!

Great subs. Many choices. All that I ordered are yummy. 😋

This is my go to place for a good sub when traveling through the area. I always call ahead and my sandwich is waiting for me. They are very generous with the fillings. I love a good amount of veggies which they don’t skimp on. It’s primarily a takeout place with just a few small tables to sit at. Highly recommend.

I had a meatball sub on toasted herb bread and it was very very good

Good local sub shop. Nice change from the national chains that you can get anywhere. I remember their pizzas being pretty good from 20 years ago when I was a kid, so I thought I would drop in and try a sandwich. Pleasantly surprised.

I order my late afternoon- early dinner meals from Fatzo's everyday. I love their soups! They change daily so you always have something delicious. Friendly staff, super great! And such a large variety to choose from, including their sub of the month listing. Check that out, my fave is the Hawaiian cheese steak in wrap form.
Prices are rather reasonable too. And you can choose what you would like to put on your sub or wrap, it doesn't have to be exactly how it is listed. Example: I ask for honey mustard in place of the stingin' garlic sauce on my Hawaiian cheese steak wrap.

The subs were awesome. I would come here again in a heartbeat.

Very nummy subs. Fresh bread. Made to order generous sized subs. Employee taking orders was very friendly .

My husband and I each got the 8" Super Fatzo sub on herb bread. The bread and sub was awesome. The staff was friendly. When we're in the area again we will definitely be stopping in. The best sandwich that we had in Sturgeon Bay.

My new favorite place for subs! Hot or cold, choices abound. I love the taco sub 😋

Sad I haven’t tried them sooner after living here three years. Hands down better than Jimmy Johns and Subway. The bread is incredible, friendly staff, great prices and portions, and they weren’t kidding when they said it would be ready in ten minutes. I got there 7 minutes after placing the order and it was ready. Only bad thing I have to say is they don’t have images for their online menu but the items I did order absolutely exceeded my expectations and now I want to try everything lol. New fan.

Great great pizza! Fresh indgredients, Fantastic food choices, I would highly recommend, and we will definately return!!

It's so nice and has a super friendly environment. The food is to die for. Had a two hour drive to door county for errands and found this place. I would drive 2 hours again just for the food. Its amazing 😍😋.

Taco Sub is delicious!! This is my new go-to sandwich shop when I’m in the area for sure.

We had an absolutely awesome experience here. We're from our of town, had 4 women and 3 kids in our party, everybody wanted something different, and of course we had to keep a 6, 9, and 12-year-old happy. The lady running the counter was fabulous - made sure everyone as happy with their order, interacted with the kids - overall above and beyond! Thank you for a great lunch and a great experience - we highly recommend this place to everyone!

Smelled like a toilet inside (must have had some bathroom issues) but the pizza was great! The chicken BBQ has a good amount of toppings and the sauce was both sweet and tangy. One of the better thin crust pizza crusts I've had in awhile.

Super Fatzo sub with pickles so to die for ! My son who’s 4 also loved it! Couldnt stopping eat his sub! Great staff !! Very nice workers even though we came before they close! They still were great to us! Come way before they close! They will appreciate it more ! I know how it goes with people asking for service out of Bussiness hours. Got two more subs to try will update !