Payne's Pizza & More

I haven’t had Paynes in awhile but I’m glad that I recently found them again. Really friendly team. I placed a to-go order on the phone and they told me about the specials and made recommendations. The pizza was good, too.

A long time go to for our family. Pizza is solid, bakedSpaghetti is awesome, the grinders are awesome. and the macaroni salad is amazing! Customer service is also always top-notch and they are a big community supporter!

Delivery times and service are both top notch. The food is Great! Best subs in town, and pizzas are certainly in the Top 5 as well. Haven't dined in yet, but I'm sure we will soon. Highly Recommended!!

Very good pizza and they have a combo pizza and salad bar on most evenings. The price is very reasonable. I will definitely eat here again

Always good food and service. We have monthly meetings here and always feel welcomed. Cannot recommend 1 item over another as all of their food is good.

Pizza Perfection at Payne's Pizza & More!

Payne's Pizza in Delaware, Ohio, is a pizza lover's dream come true, delivering a dining experience that goes above and beyond.

The menu is a masterpiece of pizza creations, offering a variety of flavors and toppings to suit every taste. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous with unique combinations, Payne's Pizza & More has you covered.

The quality of the ingredients and the perfect balance of flavors make every slice a delight. The crust is just right – crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside.

The staff is friendly, efficient, and ensures a prompt and positive dining experience. Whether you're dining in, ordering for delivery, or grabbing a quick takeout, their service is consistently excellent.

The ambiance is casual and inviting, making it a great spot for a family meal, a night out with friends, or a cozy dinner for two.

For pizza perfection in Delaware, Payne's Pizza & More is the place to be. Five stars for their delicious pies, excellent service, and overall fantastic dining experience!

We love their food. They make the best heated subs in town and Pizza. And their buffet is so filling and a great way to sample Items on the menu that we have never ordered. And the drive up window for pickup orders is so convenient. No need to get out of the car. Their 16 inch subs take up the whole dashboard. Never tried delivery bc we are pretty far out so we always order when we are in town and about ready to head home. Prices are reasonable too!

Really delicious! Kind staff. Wish the Paynes in my town of Marion also did a buffet, worth the drive everytime❤

I ordered online and food was done in 15-20 min. Drove through their drive thru and picked it up. Fast, hot, and delicious!!!

Very pleasant employees and have never had a bad pizza or a bad experience. Highly recommend

Great food and to the minute on delivery. Very friendly and if it's not right they will fix it no charge. Great place

Best sauce I've had in ages. $25 after tax for 2 large pizzas, bread sticks, and garlic bread since I got the Saturday deal, but they have deals every day of the week. Pizza was out in about 15 minutes and gave us a mountain of napkins and extra plates

Love Paynes! They are always fast and the food is always on point. Great prices!

My teenage sons and I love to get the subs. I pick them up on the way home from work and they are so good! My youngest and I always get the club sub and my other son loves the meatball sub. They are always so good ❤

Needed last minute catering for 25 people to follow a funeral service. Worked with the manager, she told me exactly what to order and gave me a great price. Delivered perfectly on time and everyone was impressed with the food. Thanks so much for making a difficult day easier.

Can't say enough good things about this place! Every pizza we've ever tried is delicious. The workers are always so friendly, and the vibe inside is always chill and cute. We live quite a drive away, but every time we're in the area, we make sure to stop in! Wish there was one closer to Dayton!

Payne’s delivered 28 delicious large pizzas to our cub scout meeting at Camp Lazarus today. Pizza was a big hit! Staff is super friendly and made it easy.

Thanks Payne’s!!!

Payne’s is our favorite Delaware pizza spot. Recently we had a family event and Paynes provided an amazing and delicious dinner of pasta, salad and breadsticks, complete with utensils and serving utensils, plenty of salad dressing and ready to go on time. The price was super affordable and everyone loved it. Perfect experience. We 💛 Paynes !!

Lunch buffet is so good, dinner buffet is ok. Love coming to this place. Will be back again.

Best Taco Pizza ever!!!! And OMG I've never seen a pizza that big and heavy! Delicious highly recommend just make sure you get plenty of sour cream or have your own sour cream.