Joe’s New York Pizzeria

I heard good things before and was traveling through so i decided to stop.

Glad I did, the slices looked good but nothing spoke to me so I got a small meatball sub. After crushing the first half I decided I needed to take a pic and leave a review. It was that good. I imagine anything with the red sauce will be choice because it's delicious.

Service was great and the food came out really fast.

We have used them for an event. They have opened early to accommodate the party time not just last year but this year as well. We could not be more thankful! Best staff, best atmosphere, best food :)

Visiting from out of state , I was worried it would be mediocre given the small size. Looks are deceiving! Friendly staff and owner, the food was quick , fresh, and absolutely delicious! Highly recommend. I will be sure to come back when I visit again!

I am a local and have been getting pizza here all my life I know I am spoiled you just can't find pizza like this anywhere else in my opinion. I remember when they were right next door used to walk down for lunch in school once a week when friends and family come from out of state we always have a pizza party from joes. There a family owned and run shop as far as I know the best around

I used to live in West Winfield, right across from the Pizzeria actually. We ordered from here at least 3 times a week. It’s was and still is my favorite pizza and food! Everyone is so friendly and inviting, they all make the experience of even just being in the building, worthwhile. I recommend Joes New York Pizzeria to ANY and EVERYONE looking for some good pizza and food!

Great Atmosphere... Wings were cooked to perfection. And the ingredients for the Pie were Fresh and Tasty... Definitely Filling. I'd recommend it...

Definitely recommend for a low key cozy lunch ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Great pizza, AMAZING wings. Wings that are actually saucey. And they still give celery and blue cheese.

Absolutely love their food here it’s the only pizza place I will go to now and the workers are always very nice to us!

The best pizza ever! This is one of our favorite Friday night spots.

Drove in from Chicago, and you know how we love our pie. We really wanted that NY style, and this place was perfect!! Got an XL Cheese. We were so hungry we tried it before we left the lot and OMG. Absolutely AMAZING!! The slices were huge, so was the flavor! The crust is even delicious! I wish we got more than 1! We also tried the wings, the Golden BBQ, Bourbon Molasses & Sweet Chili sauces added just the right flavor. They’re really crispy, and juicy. We are definitely coming back before we leave town!!

My favorite pizza for years! Their sauce is amazing- no other place I like it. Wings and other items awesome.

First off, staff is amazing! Pizza is AMAZING! I had sausage and bacon slice a few days agooo and it was just the right amount of toppings and dough! the crust is absolutely amazing and so crisp! hands down my new favorite pizza spot!

I've seen some reviews saying it wasn't good but honestly the pizza was probably the best I've had and better than anything you can get in the valley. I had no idea it wasn't super far I'd definitely come back. Absolutely loved it. And the people here are super friendly and amazing. Absolutely amazing.

Nice little pizza shop. It's been there as long as I can remember and still as great.

We use joes for our sons birthday party, last time they were helpful in helping me decide on the best options for the amount of people we were having, I ordered a week ahead and everything was ready for pick up and was a hit with everyone.

Incredible pizza, all across the board. Amazing calzones that are basically just pizzas folded in half. Best chicken wings in the area, so many flavors to choose from. I recommend the bourbon molasses and the sweet red chili!

Great customer service, excellent pizza, and hands down the best chicken riggies in town. Highly recommend

Pizza was great and wings had sauce with them

Fast friendly service. Very pleasant atmosphere. The pizza was amazing!! Great job thank you for your hard work.