Pie Squared Utica

We've been ordering from Pie Squared for about a year now and we have always had delicious and fantastic food. It's always fresh and hot. I totally recommend the Cali wing's because they are the best wing's I've ever tasted, ever!! The sesame are good too, but a little spicy. We love the grilled, but they are all spectacular. If you love pizza, this is your go to place, no need for another.

I was in town on business and stopped in to check it out. Anthony, the owner was very friendly and helpful. Despite being very busy and no apparent help, he was in total control. There was a few people ahead of me and he apologized in advance for the wait. Anthony recommended the square pizza. It was very good and fair price. I'll definitely be coming back when I'm in town. Can you imagine how great it would be if he had some good help? Great job Anthony!!!

This pizza changed my life!! Literally!

I was on the road with a couple friends, busking in the street. Anthony had just opened Pie Squared and invited us to all come try a slice.

He gave all three of us a perfect, freshly made, classic cheese slice on the house.

Not only was this one of the nicest things anyone has ever done, but this is literally the best pizza I’ve ever had!!!

My family is Italian (first generation) and lived 30 minutes from NYC so I’ve had good pizza, but this one was truly the absolute best, ever.

It’s been 3 years since I was in Utica, and I’m still dreaming of this pizza!!

It has forever ruined pizza for me lol 😉
No other pizza even comes close!

P.S. - He also gave us the little fried donuts with fresh raspberry sauce. Incredible also!

The food is absolutely delicious! I have eaten the same upside down pizza for many many years...i just found my new favorite! The grilled wings are phenomenal!!! It was very busy when I went but but the way they worked together was amazing, they all complete each other

I've been blown away by every new item I try from their menu. The very best pizza in Utica and beyond. Every specialty pie is out of this world. I especially like that the boneless wings are made from real, shaved off the bone chicken, and not just frozen breaded nuggets like most places. You can tell everything here is prepared with talent. So many creative flavors and options. Definitely try this place and it'll become one of your favorites!

Hands down Best Pizza and Wings in Utica, NY!!!! Almost every week I have to get the wings and pizza here. 5 star service and 5 star food! The staff is so friendly and helpful. Always there greeting you with a smile. Last several times I have gotten food from here smells and looks so good that we dont have time to write a review or take pictures of our order. If you want some great food for a good price locally, Pie Squared is the place to go!!!

Love the variety of wings. Pizza is pretty good. Customer service is amazing. Sometimes they're just too busy. But on more than one occasion def worth the wait. Always a good experience

Anthony has created and perfected his recipes that can’t be beat. He uses only the best ingredients and makes everything fresh. Not only is he a talented chef but, he serves with care and treats everyone around him the way he wants to be treated. He has grown so much and accomplished the first of many goals by just creating his brand. Hopefully expansion will be in both Anthony and the business’ future because someone and something this great should have no limits.
Getting started is the hardest step and no one can say that this industry is easy.
So, please.....give credit and encouragement where it’s deserved. As well as constructive criticism, that’s a major factor in how people and businesses grow. :)

We have never tried this place but we have heard the buzz around town about how wonderful the pizza is. So tonight, we finally tried a large pizza with extra cheese. We are officially changing our go to pizza joint to this establishment! Kudos to making delicious pizza and the friendly staff.

Just picked up a gluten free pizza and a calzone on our way home and it is fantastic! The folks working were very pleasant, and the calzone is massive! The gluten free pizza is 12", which is bigger than any other place I've been, and the smell alone is incredible. Absolutely reccomend!

I always get the 10 wings (sesame, grilled) and a small cheese pizza. Comes out to around $17. Feeds 3 polite people, 2 hungry people, or 1 glutton. . Pretty good deal, and in my opinion, the best pizza and the best wings in town.

Great service first time ordering from here. This is the customer service that makes people come back. Keep up the great work. you'll be seeing me agian! Family loved the food as much as i enjoyed the service.

Pie squared is just all around amazing. Great food, great people, and great service. I highly recommend it to everyone. You won't be disappointed! And they are also now delivering.. $3 for local Utica, $5 for North Utica, Whitesboro, New Hartford.

Food was very good and well priced, the young lady was very nice at counter. I have new pizza place but only one thing they mite want answer phone with just a little more than just a hello, I thought at 1st I dialed the wrong number

My cousin talked me into trying this place and I wasn't disappointed. Very, very good pizza and crispy wings. Did I mention the pizza was very good?

Best boneless wings around! I was pleased overall with all my food and will definitely be a repeat customer..great customer service too

Pie Squared Eatery and it's crew are among the best of the best in it's category. You can't go wrong choosing Pie Squared for your next pizza party.

Best PIZZA in Utica, NY. Best Pepperoni, I'm addicted! Prices are decent and their Staff is super nice as well.

Great food, great service. Garlic knot sliders are great! Chicken Cali sub on fresh bread that they bake everyday is great

Best pizza in the area....hands down. Wish I could say I taught him everything he knows about cooking....but he did it on his own.