Madison Avenue Pizza

Late review from our trip to FL in May 2023, our last pizza stop in USA before flying back to the UK.

Absolutely love Maddison Avenue Pizza! Their pizzas were consistently delicious.
The crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this is a must-try pizza joint. Five stars all the way! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We went on a Sunday afternoon. We really enjoyed the atmosphere. Very warm and cozy and friendly. We could see old friends, eat pizza and watch the Bucs play. What could be better? The food was excellent. The mozzarella used is made there by the owner as well as everything else. Delicious!!! We plan on going back soon.

First time at Madison Avenue Pizza. Close to downtown Dunedin, the surrounding area was not very appealing but great vibes when we entered the restaurant. Nice bar area, lots of TV screens had football on. People seemed to be happy to be there. Got meatball sub and shrimp scampy pizza, both were outstanding. They were out of fries but tater tots were delish. Service was a little slow but pleasant. Would definitely recommend, hidden gem.

Awesome Philly Cheese Steak. Home made bread puts it a notch up. Hand cut fries reminiscent of Five Guys fry. Great NY style pizza as well.

I got a meat lovers calzone and it turned out very good. The bartender that took my order was very polite and friendly. I'll definitely return another time.

Madison Avenue Pizza is truly a gem! My family and I had an outstanding experience - the friendly service, delectable food, and welcoming ambiance made it a memorable outing. The pizza was unparalleled, and we appreciated the pleasant atmosphere without overwhelming crowds. Highly recommend to anyone seeking a fantastic dining experience! ⭐🍕

Great totally unpretentious neighborhood joint with nice, hard working staff and delicious pizza. The meat Lovers calzone is incredible! Naomi took great care of us!

Best part is the server, she was awesome. 6pm 2.22.23. I'm sorry I forgot her name but she was great. Had wings and pizza. Leftovers pictured, such awesome pizza

This place is amazing! The pizza is delicious, the options are endless and their specialty pies are top notch. Great selection of beer, wine and bourbon. The owner, Sean, is always there meticulously ensuring the quality of everything that comes out of the kitchen. The entire staff takes great pride in the immaculate reputation this place has built for itself over the years and it absolutely shows. My favorites are the fried ravioli, the Maddy Ave and any of the local beers on draft. Can't recommend enough!!!

Great place!!!! I highly reccomend. We walked in and the place was packed. We were sat quickly and greeted right away by our server. We ordered a couple pies (return of the Mac, and a meat lovers) definitely some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. What I thought was cool was not only was the food fantastic, it was just the whole VIBE of Madison Ave. The owner stopped by our table to chat and make sure we were happy. Great people, great food!!! We will definitely become regulars.

OMG the food at this establishment is awesome! The service is spectacular! A must stop in Palm Harbor for delicious pizza!

This was honestly the best pizza I have had in my entire life. My husband and I really had the best experience, from the service to the food! The owner is so kind and skilled at what he does! We chose the "we pick" options for our pizzas and oh my God what a delight it was!! He really went all out for us and it was heaven to me!! I am so thankful for the experience and for giving us such a special time together through his masterwork!!

Absolutely amazing pizza. Top quality ingredients that you'd want on your pizza. Very tasty and well cooked wings and deals you can't pass up. Highly recommend going!

Oh my goodness. I miss this place.
I love the remodel 🤩 and the food is amazing as it ever was, maybe even better. I haven’t been in quite some time. I will now make it a plan to pick up a pie on my way home from work at least twice a month. 😊

Love the customer service, the atmosphere, and especially the Pizza! This pizza dough is next level and that’s what separates them from most…the pizza dough. It will be hard for you not to eat each crust you encounter. I always ask for all my pizza cooked well done and this did not disappoint. The perfect slice of pizza!! Not soggy, greasy, or burnt! I could not recommend this pizza restaurant enough!! Weekly special pizzas…GYROS, BIG MAC, Chick-fil-A, and more…creative and thinking outside the box. Give it a taste!! You won’t be disappointed!!

Absolutely great food and wonderful waitress. We sat outside with our dog and the waitress even brought water out for her.
The best Philly Cheese steak I have ever eaten.

Came in last night and sat at the bar. The bar is huge and they have a wide variety of cocktails and drinks. I had the gluten free cheese pizza with ricotta cheese. It was delicious. Great Atmosphere. The staff was really friendly. I will definitely be back.

Service was spectacular. The pizza was delicious. We are huge fans of Nonas Slice in Safety Harbor so the bar was set very very high. We were absolutely blown away and not disappointed and now have another favorite pizza place. Our waitress in spite of being super busy was very attentive, helpful and knowledgeable. Our glasses never went empty and food came out promptly.

So First, we love Madison Ave Pizza. The food is awesome. The restaurant is very nice since re-model. We however have experienced poor service ( lost complete order, long wait time), We continue to get take out, because we love their Pizza.
We will probably try the restaurant again, but in the meantime, we are still customers. Thank you helping with our Super Bowl food making for excellent large pizzas !

Had pizza delivered for a birthday party. Came exactly the right time. The driver brought it in the house for me. Ordered 4 different kinds. Everyone raved about each one. They were huge and delicious. Also ordered meatballs for my grandaughter. She loved them! Will definitely order again!