Forest Street Pub

Did not take pics of our food unfortunately but we had an amazing experience here. Our first time eating here while in our travels. We highly recommend 👌. Excellent service. And the food was great. A little pricey but understandable in today's economy.

Nice family owned business. The staff was fun and friendly, even being a little short handed. We had delicious specialty cocktails (Watermelon Cooler and Orange Crush) , and a great Long Island Iced Tea, then since we couldn’t decide we got Pork Wings, Mozzerella Sticks and the Shrimp. We were licking the plates clean!!!! We enjoyed 2 of the flatbreads, Steak Tips, and an Apple Salad on the specials menu that was incredibly delicious.

Our server was a gem, keeping plates cleared and checking on us. The atmosphere was charming and homey, and very clean. We opted to eat inside, but they have a beautiful wrap around porch with seating to enjoy the weather.

Our only regret is that we will not be in town longer to visit again. Definitely worth your time

This amazing hidden treasure is absolutely worth the trip! I have been here a few times and every time I’m completely impressed. The atmosphere, staff, food and drinks are all some of the best I’ve ever had. I would eat here daily if I could. Kendra at the bar is great also! 100% recommend the Forest street Pub!!!

This was an impulse stop and it was a home run! Food, atmosphere, and server were fantastic!

Excellent food, attentive service, and a unique menu that sets Forest Street Pub apart from the rest. I highly recommend it to all my guests at Hilltop View Lodge!

The food was amazing! Best gouda mac & cheese in the area! We had a great experience and we will be returning to try more food.

A gem!! Everything about this place deserves 5 stars from the stellar friendly and helpful service to the tasteful soothing environment to the culinary delights we devoured. My partner gushed over his pork chop and my chicken masala was perfectly seasoned, a true to form classically prepared dish I would order over and over. The sides of fresh fields greens were so fresh they stood up on the plate, which as a farmers market vendor of 20 years and avid cook, I appreciated. Our desserts of strawberry shortcake and chocolate custard mousse were outstandingly delicious. Kudos to this fine establishment! Highly recommend!

We are staying at the Nootka Lodge 1/4 mile away and wanted something local. We originally wanted to just get takeout, but be aware, THEY DO NOT do take out, as the google search said they do. The place has a great atmosphere, very quaint, with friendly staff. Very clean and the food was excellent! My gf ordered baked stuffed shrimp, rice pilaf & fries. Best rice pilaf I have ever eaten. Perfectly seasoned, as was the stuffed shrimp, that were perfectly cooked. I wanted the chicken picatta, which was no longer on the menu, but they were able to make it for me as they still had ingredients. Again, best chicken piccata I’ve ever had. Very balanced flavors, chicken medallions were kinda small for the price ($24) but again, flavors, service & atmosphere made it worth it, and being a small local business, I don’t mind. We will DEFINITELY be back! Thank you to the staff! Enjoy! I’ve added the most recent menu pics as the others were out of date.

Really good food!! They have kid friendly options on the menu, and the fish tacos were very good!! A bit of a wait because it’s made from scratch, but well worth it.

Great find!! Was looking for dinner in the area and so glad we found this place!! Will definitely be back. Food was Amazing!!!! Service was awesome and it is wicker cute inside!

My wife and I stopped by for the first time and it truly was the best food experience I’ve had in my life. I had a pork rib eye cooked to perfection. The chef is absolutely amazing with such fresh and amazing flavors. Her drive to satisfy her customers is displayed in her dishes. The waitress Kendra was so sweet and kind. Made the whole experience worth everything. There is a wait but it’s due to it being made fresh. Worth the wait and the time spent here was worth every second. Thank you

The place is fantastic. Food, drink and staff were incredible. Highly recommend !!!

Everything was DELICIOUS! We were celebrating our second wedding anniversary and it was perfect. We did apps, entrees and dessert and everything was outstanding. Our waitress (Kendra I believe?) was very attentive despite being busy. We will absolutely be returning.

Great service. Our server Shelby was very polite & attentive. Once she realized that I am on a gluten free diet she related that her sister has celiac so she knew all about the dietary restrictions. She took good care of my needs and made sure everything I was served was safe.
Also, the food was AWESOME!!!!
I highly recommend this place!

We came in late, party of six. They had just closed the kitchen but opened back up for us. We had wonderful service from Megan. The food and drinks were amazing and the owner made us feel so welcome. We'll definitely be back!

A hidden gem that is well worth the trip! Food is amazing!

A cute place. Great food. Kendra was awesome as a bartender. The owners were amazing. Chicken Parm and Onion rings were outstanding. Made from scratch makes a world of difference! Will make a special trip back just visit

Owners did an amazing job of restoring an old property, respecting and keeping it part of the community they serve. Staff are very friendly, greeting and welcoming all. Bar is very attentive and they make a great drink! Amazed at the food and service for only being open several weeks, not easy to pull off. As they work out any kinks, we can only imagine the creative menu the chef and kitchen will prepare. Portions are fair, some local ingredients are used as well as meat from a local farm. We also enjoyed meeting guests as excited as us about a new place to gather. Their drive to succeed and their attention to customer satisfaction will serve them well. We wish them great success!

Adorable place. Loved the place.

New to the area. We have been here twice and both times everything was fantastic. Really nice waitstaff, great ambiance and magic coming out of the kitchen. Everything we ordered cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!