Casey's

Just moved to Tomah. Nothing but a great experience for me at Casey's. Went there to get a beer after waiting for 2 hrs for pizza from Dominos that never showed up. Told the story to Blade and infinity that were working at the time. They were just shutting the kitchen down but offered to make me one. It was excellent and will continue to get my beer and pizza there at Casey's.

Thank you Blade and Infinity!!!

The pizza here is unstoppable!! I doordashed a large pepperoni pizza and the worker, Kathie, made my pizza to perfection! Always a hit! Will continue to order pizza from here!

🍕🔥 ordered around noon over a week ago this pizza was made by Hayna B. we absolutely loved it and our son SMASHED so hard. He loves Casey's pizza!

Wyatt is an awesome manager here well rounded works well with the employees and their schedules. Kathie the kitchen manager is so amazing she works extremely well and hard. She definitely deserves the position she has. There's times where I forget money or have not enough they help me pay for things. The staff are awesome hard workers. The pizza is great. The staff are blessings. If you want good pizza come to caseys. They will hook it up!!!

This place is amazing the food, the people, the best person I know there is Kathie. Kathie is polite and friendly to everyone. She works so hard everyday and I'm so proud of how far she has come, she deserves the position she got handed and no one can take that away or take her place. Thank you for everything you do Kathie. You work so hard everyday and everything good that had or has happened you deserve that because you work so hard for everything you earn. Keep up the great work Kathie.

I stop here very often for a quick slice of pizza around or after lunch time. 2.50 is a okay price for a fair size slice of good pizza. I see a lot of bad reviews about the delivery, but carry out has always been a 10/10 for me. No problems. The Apple fritters are awesome, and friendly people that make the stuff there.

I ordered online and it was easy and quick to select my purchase. Very convenient. My order ready on time and pick up was a breeze. I drove 30 minutes home and my pizza was still nice & warm when i got home. Pizza looked great and tasted even better!! I'm extremely satisfied with my order today!! I love Caseys pizza its my favorite!

Everyone says that delivery here is bad, but every time we've ordered they've come through, on time (and sometimes earlier than expected!), with delicious, gooey-cheesy, fair-price pizza. Beware when pulling a slice out of the box as if you're not careful the cheese & toppings may slide off. Subs are really good and you can have them make it on the phone and carry-out if you're short on time. They even have their own soft-serve Ice Cream machine which is out of order sometimes, but when it is working you can make the cone (or dish) as (reasonably) big/full as you want with no price changes. They serve 3 flavors which consists of Vanilla, Chocolate, and Twist, which is a mix of the other two flavors. Staff is really cool and every time I come in I feel welcomed. Not like a customer, but as a friend.

I’ve been going to to Casey’s general store since I was a young child unfortunately where I was living they no longer had a Casey’s so when I found this old gem it was like walking back in time Down memory lane which then in turn made me feel really old lol but it was well worth it the staff here are very friendly and helpful and seem to know a lot of their customers by their first name.

The cashier paid for my monster and recently when I keep forgetting about 50 cents to a dollar other people are generous and pay for it. Five stars

Excellent pizza. Excellent DoorDash delivery guy. Justin I believe his name was. Casey's pizza is my favorite to order in Tomah.

GREAT pizza And Great Home Made Sweetser To Cut That Sweet Tooth! This Is Very Competitive With Your Kwik Trip Stores! Sandwiches, Pizza, And Plenty Of Cookies And Drinks! ENJOY!

O so much yummy for the tummy n I've been there many of times after work to get a great tasting slice of pizza for on the way home n have ordered a big pizza many of times to take home as well so outstanding n will always come back too n always I check out their sweet goodies in a plastic cup so much yummy too,, you've gotta check this place out nice friendly smile from wait staff n always welcome n very helpful very nice clean restrooms too.

Just picked up pizza and they were all very friendly and helpful! Would definitely order from there again! Thank you for the great service!

My brother ordered a bunch of pizzas and i also had to get drinks and when i checked out, the lady that was working the register offered to carry the pizzas out to my car for me so i didn't have to attempt to carry everything out to the car, and risk dropping it, didnt catch her name but she was super polite, and helpful, thank you caseys in tomah

I personally think the burgers are too dry if I don't order them I will order anything else but remember

Casey's has some of the best subs ever! And their soft serve is great too!

Love their pizza and subs. People are friendly and delivery is fast.

Highly recommend their pizza and wings! Much better than anywhere else in town!

Everyone is so friendly and quick! I love that they have soft serve ice cream, too!