Andy's Pizza Old Town

Great little NY style pizza place. Thin crust was delicious with lots of specialty offerings in addition to the usuals. Hit the spot and was exactly what we were looking for. Highly recommend if you’re in Old Town Alexandria.

Great spot for pizza. Went there for National Pizza Day! They are very accommodating. It is a small space so not always easy to find a booth or seating. They have a great Wednesday Wine deal if you like pizza and vino together.
Fun combinations for pizza if you want to try something new. They also have the classics. Great sauce that is a tad sweet.

I don't give out 5 star reviews lightly, but this place deserves it.

I ordered the pepperoni special pizza, and let me tell you, it truly was special. The basil is incredibly fresh and the drizzle of honey really puts the pizza over the top. Would definitely come here again!

This was my first time here from a recommendation and once we walked in it was a line towards the back which is always a good sign of an awesome pizza place! Amazing beer and wine selection and limited but amazing cocktail selection. As soon as you approach the counter Mikey and Ronan were there with smiles and efficiency! Made recommendations and even suggested I buy a whole pie with how much I ordered to lower the total cost! Great music playlist and some interesting choice of Samsung Television shows! Alyssia was a machine prepping and slicing the pizzas which prompted me to buy three more of their mushroom and onion which is by far the best choice to pair with the Weihenstephaner beer! Definitely coming back here in the near future! Awesome spot in old town I never knew existed!!! 15/10!

My partner and I shared a delicious Margherita pizza. This was our first time here, and we were thoroughly impressed with the freshness of the ingredients, the crispness of the crust, and the size of the pizza! I definitely recommend this place for a relatively fast, casual, delicious pizza experience.

I got their cream, cheese, basil and spicy honey on top of my pizza and WOW. 👌🤌

I’m not a big pizza person, but this New York style pizza has me converted.

What an authentic pizza place! Love the pizzas here! The crust is soft yet crunchy! This is definitely a go to pizza place for us!

Not a local, but this place forever has my heart! We tried cheese, pepperoni, mushroom & onion, and the white pizza. The white was my favorite, but all the others were just as delicious.

The space is super cute and clean. The whole menu is not fussy… just the right amount of yummy offerings. The staff is super nice. Were definitely coming back next time we’re in town.

This is the second Andy's I have been to. Basically all upside and small/knit pick downsides.

Pizza options and flavors are top tier for the DC area. I don't think Dave Portnoy has reviewed any Andy's, but I would think his rank would be 7.4 at least.

Can't go wrong with cheese or pepperoni options. Loads of canned beverage options.

I have been looking for good pizza in the area and this place was great! Now, I'm going once per week ! Loved everything we have tried so far!

Andy’s was not on my radar this road-trip but boy am I glad we wanted delivery to the hotel. Near perfect dough construction produced a nicely charred long fermented crispy crust that was paper thin yet still flexible. Good balance between sauce and cheese. No wonder these guys have racked up the accolades! Delicious!

Proper pizza slices - they were delicious! The pepperoni slices we ordered were devoured before we remembered to snap a photo, but here’s a pic of the margherita slice!

We were walking around and found this great local. Food is outstanding with quick service and a variety of beer to complement. Recommend to anyone visiting and will make a usual stop.

Just learned about this place at the Capital Food Fight this year and stoked to find they have a location outside the District.
If you are a lover of good NY Style Pizza: Look no further!
It's the kind of slice that tastes delicious in all temperature states: hot, warm, or cold!
And I am not a cold pizza lover.

First time at Andy’s was AWESOME, not only did I feel like I was in the club, the food was AMAZING. I couldn’t stop eating their pizza, wanted to try every slice they had!

Perfect spot to stop in for a quick slice. Great service from the staff and the pizza was top notch. Slightly sweet sauce, nice chewy dough and perfectly crisp pepperoni.

One of the best slices of pizza I’ve had in a long time. I was recommended Andy’s from a couple of locals and it didn’t disappoint. True NY pizza and the sauce is a bite of heaven! Staff is on pointe too!

Top notch, high quality pizza. Great customer service and the restaurant was clean with a great atmosphere. I will be back next time I’m in the area.

I’m so happy this location opened in Old Town! (RIP MeggRolls) The dough is delicious, crust is perfectly baked, no soggy bottoms. Great topping combos, some pretty fancy!! Also the frozen sangria is amazing. Plenty of beer and wine to go!!

What a great pizza place. Went there for lunch with my girlfriend. We got double pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza. Great service and great food. Will be back.