Mugshots Bar & Grill

I wanted to try something new, but also close to home. It was only about a 13-minute drive. There was parking when I arrived but it was a slower night. I ordered so many things because I couldn't decide. I absolutely loved the building and how it was designed. Then, the menu also matches the vibe and aesthetic of the restaurant! Had a great time there and will definitely be going back soon.
Also, everyone, please try the Italian wedding soup!!! It was awesome!

I have been a fan of this place since the day it opened! My favorite is their Chicken Diablo. Today I had the Tommy Guns Mac n Cheese with pulled pork and BBQ. I haven't tried anything I don't like, and the owners are the best !

Gotta give them 5 stars for sure! This joint has a gangsteresc feeling. Decked out in all the most famous mobsters America has ever seen. The food was delicious! Ordered 2 personal pizzas and 2 appetizers and both were fantastic, full of flavor! The mushrooms are wild hand picked and battered fresh for the serving! They were hand down the BEST! mushrooms I have ever had! Keep the great food coming guys, good work!

Very cool style restaurant with nice bars and booths. Gangster/bootlegger themed. Waitress was super awesome and very nice. Food was great. The sandwiches, burgers, and pastas are great. The pizza could use some work as it is not over impressive. Overall it was a great time and very delicious!

I ordered the Jalapeño popper cheesy bread, Al Capone sandwich and coconut cake “to go” and let me tell you, my taste buds are going wild. The sandwich is juicy, crispy and flavor packed, the popper bread is cheesy and creamy with a kick and the pie is light and airy (ask for some caramel drizzle and chocolate drizzle like on the brownies and you have a Samoa cookie tasting cake”.
The wait times were great considering they are very new and was told understaffed; You never would’ve guessed. Can’t thank the kitchen staff and servers enough for doing what they do to make such a diamond in the rough run smoothly. Can’t wait to go back
⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐

It was a great place to eat fun servers, great food, and the mafia theme made it very fun owners Jason and Lisa were great people 10/10 would come again!

Great experience love the food especially the meatloaf, also green beans and mac and cheese are amazing. Dont get me started on the cheesecake it is AMAZING!!! The customer service is great and everyone makes you feel comfortable like family. We will be back many more times cant wait to try all the different menu options. I love that their is a lot of different menu items if your trying to eat healthy it is not an issue and you can choose multiple different things.

If you’re looking for an alternative to bar food you must try Mugshots! Only 15 min drive from Buckeye Lake. I had no expectations bc it hasn’t been opened long, but I was very pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was cool, the staff friendly & attentive but it’s the food that’s going to bring me back! Everything is made from scratch, even the sauces & dressings & you can taste the difference! We started with meatballs - moist, amazing sauce & garlic bread. I didn’t try the bread bc I had the jalapeño poppers cheese bread - spicy & flavorful! The fried pickles with homemade ranch were crunchy & tangy. Our entire group raved about their entrées: cheese burger; chicken Diablo & meatloaf. I can only speak to the Frankie’s spaghetti which I enjoyed very much! Portions are huge so we didn’t have room for dessert but I’m definitely going to try the dessert flight next time!

My first time visiting this establishment and I will be back more! Mariah was fantastic and helped me pick a great meal. I had the special which was Mac and cheese with a hot honey chicken tender on top. HIGHLY recommend trying it when it’s a special again because it’s not on the menu.

Phenomenal experience everytime we eat here. The food is leaps and bounds better than any other place near Buckeye lake or Lancaster. The decor inside will take you back in time to 1920's Chicago with all of their gangster memorabilia. The wait staff will greet you with a smile like your family. If you haven't gave them a try yet, stop in and eat you won't be disappointed

Environment, staff, atmosphere AMAZING! Only thing better is the food 🤩 tried the mafioso four, wings and mushrooms and nothing disappointed! 10/10 highly recommended

DO NOT be on a diet when you come here to eat!! LOL. I always enjoy eating at unique places. The atmosphere is very relaxing and the food is very delicious!! The staff and patrons are really friendly.

With the exception of their tater tots and ketchup, EVERYTHING is made from scratch. Their pizza is cooked in a stone oven, with a pizza crust not too thick and not too thin. I ordered the mobster meatloaf and all I have to say is yuuuummy!!

It is worth the drive!! What made it more personable is one of the owners stopping to talk!!

Went to opening night at Mugshots! Food did not disappoint and service staff was very friendly. Atmosphere was great. Definitely a gem for the small town of Pleasantville, OH.

Mariah is the best! So attentive, and her suggestions were awesome. Will def go back again and again, and hope she is our helper. 10 out of 5 stars!!!

Absolutely the best bar and grill I've been since coming to ohio! Karaoke on Friday to boot! Definitely will return, the staff, the food, it all was so inviting and delicious. I encourage all to try this gem off the beaten path!

This is the old Pacers in Pleasantville, Oh.
Listen!! This place is amazing!! Grilled Cheese Gangsters teamed up with Mug Shots and they have a huge menu & full bar! We ordered the Fried Pickles and Gangster Tots with their special sauce and a pizza which was all super yummy.
There are large screen TVs on the wall with every sport available, classis rock playing on the speakers and a friendly atmosphere with smiling faces!
10/10 Would Recommended!!
There's a cool vibe sports bar right here in little old Pleasantville, Oh.

Let me just say the service is wonderful! I had such a great time, food was amazing, and our bartender Mariah was the best! 10/10 recommend and I will be going back.

First visit and definitely will not be our last.
The decor is fun, food delicious and our servers was awesome.

Super nice place with a pleasant staff, tons of TV's and s gangster theme. Excellent pizza and meatloaf was excellent. The owner interacts with the customers making it a very good overall experience.. highly recomend!!!

Fun atmosphere and great food. Met the owner what a nice guy. Wishing them much success. We will be back!!