Sticky Fingers Screamery and Lounge

Best ice cream in town! Owner is very nice and friendly 😊 love all the colors and very cozy atmosphere 💕 will definitely come back again and recommend to everyone! I can't wait to try their milkshake 😋

Picture this: the year is 2024, and the world is a drab, flavorless void where the concept of "dessert" has been reduced to mere memories and whispers of sweetness past. But then, as if by some cosmic joke, an ice cream shop named Sticky Fingers ~ a beacon of hope shines through the gastronomic gloom—a key lime pie ice cream so outrageously delicious, it could only have been concocted by a mad scientist with a PhD in Flavorology and a major in Wizardry.

This ice cream isn't just good; it's a dimensional leap. The key lime zestiness zips around your mouth like a caffeinated hummingbird, delivering punches of flavor so potent, they could knock out a heavyweight boxer with a sweet tooth. It's like the limes were handpicked by Zeus himself, juiced by Hercules, and then tenderly mixed into the ice cream by Aphrodite, all while Dionysus plays the flute in the background.

The graham cracker pieces scattered within are not mere "inclusions" but rather crunchy treasure troves, each bite a lottery win in the mouth lottery. They're the kind of crunchy that makes you question the fabric of reality—is this a dream? Am I a pirate discovering hidden gold? No, it's just incredibly well-executed pastry.

And the ice cream base—oh, the base! Creamier than a sonnet by Shakespeare, smoother than a jazz solo by Miles Davis. It's like your taste buds are gently being rocked to sleep in the arms of a dairy god, only to be awakened by the lively zing of key lime like a symphony's crescendo. This is not just dessert; it's an experience, a sensation, a creamy, tangy rollercoaster ride through a citrus wonderland.

Finishing a bowl of this key lime pie ice cream leaves you in a state of euphoria, akin to finding an extra fry at the bottom of the bag or getting a full 8 hours of sleep on a Tuesday. It's an emotional journey from the first bite to the tragic last, leaving you to ponder the great mysteries of life, like why all good things must come to an end, and whether it's socially acceptable to lick the bowl in public.

In the halls of fame, this ice cream will go down in history, this key lime pie masterpiece stands not just as a dessert, but as a monument to human achievement, a testament to what can be accomplished when prowess meets outright audacity. It's not just the best key lime pie ice cream ever—it's a lime-flavored mic drop in the world of frozen desserts.

I had a coconut chocolate milkshake and it was delightful. Prices are very reasonable and the owner was very sweet answering any questions I had. Solid experience will come again.

Ashley was SO great! She was patient with my kids and helped them select an ice cream flavor that they both enjoyed so much! Will be back!

Popped in kind of late. Ashley was super nice! I suggest the salty caramel truffle. Great ice cream and staff. Thank you!

Cute little place downtown. Owner was friendly and the ice cream was delicious! Also, the price was definitely fair.

Absolutely love the ice cream! I'm from ND, and whenever my husband and I come to see his family, we always have to go with his little sister a few times during our visit ❤

We're pretty thrilled that there is a new ice cream shop 😋 The shop itself still needs some love inside, but we can definitely see the potential, and the ice cream was great. ALSO, they have dairy free options!

Atmosphere is a bit lack luster, but they’re brand new, I’m excited to see what they do with the place. But they had plenty of ice cream options and the staff were very friendly. My daughter enjoyed her ice cream and the location is great!

The place is really nice the ice cream is good and I would definitely recommend this place I'd love to come here again

The ice cream here is delicious, and the banana split I ordered was fantastic. I always come here if I want ice cream or a sweet treat downtown.

I love this little place. They have lots to choose from being gluten-free and lactose free.

Service was great ice cream was perfect best ice cream in Panama City

Loved the ice cream. Friendly service!

I had a simple single scoop of vanilla. Though the selection of flavors was abundant. The prices were reasonable.

Amazing service and ice cream

Love it so good