Toppers Pizza

I had to update my review from 2 years ago because, tonight, I just had my life changed. I ordered from the store in Whitewater and my life has forever been altered. My perception of what good pizza is is changed. I'm crying. Tears streaming down my cheeks at the glory of what I recieved; a slice of heaven served in a cardboard box. To the young men and women, working their hardest to kill it on every level of the customer's experience, you've done it. I've reached nirvana. From the amazing woman who took my order to the extraordinary man who took my money, thank you. All of you. I will never again let my eyes or tongue commit adultery with any other company. I am fully committed to Toppers for the rest of my life. Not a piece of cheese out of place, the pieces cut so evenly. This is truly the epitome of perfection. 🤌🤌🤌🤌

Wonderful location. We always have fantastic food and the service has always been great.

Other than they will no longer deliver to us because our driveway is 3 feet beyond the line on the map, we still love their pizza.

Joshua was awesome! Perfect service, I'll definitely be coming back again! This was my first time visiting toppers and the experience and hospitality alone was so top notch that I don't even care how the food tastes! I'll for sure be going to toppers for now on!
(PS, THE FOOD WAS PRETTY DANG GOOD)

This is from a few days back.

... extending back 25-odd years! Topperstix are probably the best snack-food ever invented.

Only beef I have with the place is that they ditched the old "Potato Topper" pizza to jump on the hash brown bandwagon. The old one was great, the new one is a great reason to buy something else somewhere else.

We love the pizza, however the waiting time can get out of control, had to wait an extra 45 minutes from the estimited time for our order last Saturday, there were only a few workers and they were obviously stressed out and doing what they could. I don't understand how management doesn't get ready for the weekend. A shame pizza is always good.

Edit- they have been on top of things every visit since that occasion. Im glad to see such improvement!!!;

Great delivery from Katelyn Spanner! She represents Toppers amazingly and perfect! Great attitude and very friendly, always smiling and always positive! Had her deliver to me a couple times and she’s always on top of the game! Glad she’s apart of the business!!

Absolutely love this place! I’ve been ordering pizza and other food items from here pretty frequently since I started going to school out here. The workers are always very kind and the service is always quick and convenient. Hands down my favorite pizza place in Whitewater!

Josh here at Toppers Pizza in Whitewater, WI is such a delight! He greeted me with a smile (you could see it through his eyes with his mask on) and was more than happy to help me with what I needed. I’ve been going to this Toppers for a while now and I’ve never had anything but great customer service. It’s a joy coming here to eat!

The staff was very nice. The guy that delivered our food was very patient while we put my friend's dogs away before we answered the door. The food extremely fresh and hot and delicious. I would definitely eat here again.

The staff is always killing it at every detail! The team members there never fail to give each customer individual attention and make sure the customers are satisfied. And the biggest thing I love about Toppers is their Honor Guarantee. If a customer is unsatisfied in any way they'll give you a remake free and maybe even something more.

Outstanding pizza, usually pretty quick though I have had to call once or twice when my food was 10-20 min over delivery time. (They have a HUGE delivery area.) When I have had to call though, they mail me a card for a free Topper Sticks or a free Pizza as a "thanks for your patience." Thus, they get a best ever!

Mike sersich was the GM today when we ordered 1000 dollars worth a pizza 90 pizzas later and handled it like a boss. A try gentlemen and timing was very good for the size order. I give them 5 starts for him and his team. You wonder be disappointed if mike is working. Thank you mike from S&R.

I always have a good experience when I go to the Whitewater Toppers. Gabe verified all my info when he took my order over the phone and ran the pizza's out as soon as I text I was there. They always get it right and the pizza is one of if not the favorite place we get pizza from.

If you talk to Vanessa she is a literal angel. I wanted to get some toppers sticks with a coupon, but the store was closed for mystery reasons, and she helped me figure stuff out and gave me my order for free. She handled it beautifully. She needs a raise.

The most delicious pizza in town! Also, there is very little time to wait after ordering. They do a great job of getting pizzas out the door quickly.

Pizza is Excellent. Order App can be Problematic tho. Call In order is still fastest and most accurate.

This was the first time my family had Toppers Pizza and they loved it. Everything was hot and fresh. Our boys said it was the best pizza better then both PizzaHut and Dominos. If they could have it every day they would.

This place is amazing, accurate, fast, great specials, delivery and everything you could ask for. I love their crust!!!

Josh was our server—he exhibited an excellent work attitude, great knowledge of the menu & made our experience at Toppers a happy one!