Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

This was our first time at Sorelles, and it did not disappoint! The restaurant is incredibly family-friendly; we brought our three kids, and everyone had a fantastic time. The atmosphere was lively, and the food was exceptional. We enjoyed generous portions, and everything tasted great. We ended our meal with a delicious old fashioned and some cheesecake. Highly recommend!

Outstanding authentic Italian food in College Grove. Very friendly staff especially the owners. This was our first time and we will definitely be back. Excellent value. Worth the beautiful drive from Nashville, Brentwood and Franklin.

Kudos to Caitlyn. Meeting friends got us stopping in the tiny town of Eagleville and in the doors of Sorelles on a bustling Friday night. Not bad being our friends are from Minnesota and us recent transplants to South Carolina to find this gem after both being in Tennessee for a baby shower. We were seated in the bar area, which is situated on the end of the kitchen just past the takeout window. Wood floors, tongue and groove plank ceiling, faux brick wall on one side and windows on the other with a four stool bar on the end. Tables and chairs ran the narrow run and live music from a sax player permeated the air. Sorelles, which means sister in Italian, is owned and operated by sisters Kyah and Jodi formerly from Northeastern Pennsylvania. Recipes passed down from generations with fresh ingredients and made from scratch items like chicken parmesan, baked ziti, spaghetti, homemade meatballs, sausage and hand-tossed pizzas. First was an appetizer of Mozzarella Sticks that had a crunchy texture with a chewy cheese middle served with their own homemade marinara. Followed by their sizable 18” hand-tossed New York-style Meat Lovers pizza that was loaded with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham and bacon. Crust was baked to perfection and we enjoyed every bite. Caitlyn was our server and she made our dining experience even more memorable.

Sorelle’s is hands down the best Italian restaurant! The food is delicious! The owners are the sweetest, most attentive ladies ever! We are regulars and eat here often! Stopped in today and had the best lunch! Would give 100 stars if it let me!!

The Chicken Picatto and the Parmigiano were fantastic! Also, the Calamari was excellent. Bathroom was clean and the staff was pleasant throughout our visit. We had good service, good times, and nice atmosphere. 👍 Definitely excited to come back to lovely Eagleville. Fyi drop by the antique store next door too for some great finds 😉

Sorelles is among one of my favorite restaurants. The food and service are always very good and consistent. The lasagna is an absolute must and the fresh bread is one of my new favorites. Highly recommend.

Had an amazing experience at Sorelle’s Italian restaurant last night located a little outside of the Boro. Make sure to get there early because they get busy on Friday nights and the restaurant closes at 8pm. Let me rephrase that: they stop seating people by 8pm. My wife and I got there at 7:00 and the lady at the front said it will be an hour wait. I’d say their maximum capacity is around 40 people when it comes to seating. And sure enough it was almost 50 plus minutes before we got our table but it was so worth the wait.

Now for the food:
They bring you a basket of warm Garlic Knots drenched in butter with a sprinkle of Parmesan. It was nice and comforting. We couldn’t help but notice fried calamari on their appetizers. Had to get them and I’m glad we did. They’re nice and golden crispy and came with a delicious house made marinara sauce. And the best part was they came out in less than 5 mins of us ordering them. Yea it was that quick.
For the main course wifey got the Scarpariello with spaghetti and I got the chicken marsala with ziti pasta. Both had great flavors. I like the fact they were made to order and came out piping hot. To finish off, we ordered a Tiramisu and shared since we were full from the main course. Overall experience was great. We’re definitely coming back to try their pizzas next.

It’s rare to leave a 5 star review.. where do I even start. this restaurant was next level. My fiance and I went for date night and it was incredible.

There was a wait (rightfully so) and they seated us 5 min earlier than projected. I’d recommend calling for a reservation if you’re going during peak hours.

The meal started off with garlic knots that they comped, so that already had me in a great mood. The pizza dough was super fresh and you could tell their ingredients were high quality. They advertise their pizza as “New York style” which is debatable. Iv been to New York and Sorelles’s pizza was better. I’d say high end Italian pizza instead of New York but needless to say we were blown away.

Their desserts are memorable to say the least. we ordered a piece of cake and a cannoli which were 5 star worthy across the board. The drinks were also next level.

The entire staff was amazing and we will be going back on a monthly date night rotation moving forward. Looking forward to see what the experience is like during lunch.

If you’re in the area 100% try this place out.

Sorelles continues to deliver great food and service. We always meet new, first timers that are amazed at the food quality , service and atmosphere. We love Sorelles and continue to come back for the fabulous sauces and food options. They have the best lasagna I’ve ever had… better than NY, Philly , Chicago, and many other Italians restaurants we’ve dined at. These sisters have it going. Highly recommended.

We really enjoyed this Italian-American restaurant. We were greeted at the door promptly by the owner Jodi and there was just a few minutes of waiting until our table was ready. There was live music that evening so we asked to sit in the bar area so we could enjoy the guitar player/singer. Our server Shaina was friendly and attentive. we enjoyed our meal (the garlic knots were so good) and even took a pizza home to the kids. We will definitely be back!

My wife had our daughter's Bridal shower there this past weekend. After the Bridal Shower was over we opened up our home to everyone and all I heard were raves about the food, service and the restaurant in general. My wife went there last year after it was recommended to us by a family member to the owners. We live over an hour away and it was worth the trip there.

GOOD NY style pizza, very good vodka sauce, definitely the best Italian(American) food in the area.

Fantastic service, good pricing, very flavorful well prepared food.
Can’t wait to try the rest!
If you haven’t had the penne a la vodka, definitely try it!

Yum! So delicious! It smelled wonderful as we wanted our turn to go inside the restaurant this weekend. It was a beautiful evening & I had heard this little new restaurant in Eagleville was so good! We came with friends to give them a try! So happy we did! How many times can I drive back to Eagleville now?! Wow!! We each ordered entrees & salads. All around us, everyone was having a good time & their food looked amazing!! Pizzas were flying out the door!! We must come back to try their pizza. Our entrees were each so delicious!! My husband loves spicy, he got it! I prefer mild spices, mine was perfect!! Their service was superior! Everyone was so friendly & eager to get whatever we might want!! Amazing new place to enjoy!! Can’t wait to go back! So yummy!

Never had a bad meal here! The pizza is classic New York style, the calzone and Stromboli are perfect and the garlic knots and great. Service is always fast but they don’t rush you.

Absolutely delicious! The restaurant itself is warm and inviting. Cute intimate bar area. We had the bread service, garlic knots, penne al la vodka, and scarpiello. All excellent. I can’t recommend this place enough!

What a great Italian restaurant this was! Very impressed and will be adding this to the regular stops!

This place is excellent! Doesn’t make you feel like you are in a small town but more like Nashville caliber homemade Italian food!

Call ahead for dinner to get on the waitlist. Expect over a hour wait. But you can get drinks when you wait and there are other businesses you can visit too. They will text you when your table is ready.

Try them out!

Best garlic knots soaking in dipping sauce ever!!

Heather was our server last night, Friday night, our wait was about 30 minutes or less…the service was wonderful, food was delicious and Heather took care of our every need. We have been looking for new places we haven’t tried…tired of the Murfreesboro food scene..:this was a delightful surprise!!!

Wow it's really worth the drive to Sorelles in Eagelville to experience the Fantastic Service and Food. My daughter Donna and I chose to dine in here tonight. I ordered the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Excellently prepared with housemade sauce. Donna ordered Pasta with Meatballs and housemate sauce all served with pizza dough knots, delicious. 5 stars with our server Shaina taking Excellent care of us made even more Fantastic. If you have not been here yet, get in there. Nothing of this quaiity that I have found yet.

They are really doing a great job here. It has the feel of the kind of Italian restaurant you might find in NY or FL. The service was top notch. The atmosphere has really improved and had a great feel to it now. You can tell that they are doing their best. It really felt like going to a restaurant in the pre Covid days when service was so much better. You don’t find that much anymore. Everyone love their food and everything came out fast. We will be regulars I’m sure. I can’t remember her name, but the person that was serving us was new and you would have never known it if they didn’t say so. She was knowledgeable about everything and did an excellent job.