Slice of Amish

What a wonderful place to visit in old town Montgomery. There is everything here for your party table…cheeses, summer sausage, Amish Butter, flavorful coffees, candies, jams and preserves plus dip and cheese ball mixes. We sampled and bought several cheeses , sausage and the Amish butter. The owner is very knowledgeable about the cheeses and is very passionate about what she does. Many more yummy items for sale. This will be a regular stop for me.

Every time we're here we try something new and end up taking it home. The staff are always so helpful in recommending new things for us to try.

It's also the excuse for my retired Marine to get a scoop of ice cream. He swears that it cleanses his pallet between cheese tastings :)

What comes to mind is Slice of Amish is such a unique place. There's really nothing else even close. Coming from the restaurant industry it's like Montgomery's specialized market. Definitely the most diverse availability of staples you will find. On top of this...the weekly offerings of grilled cheese and reuben sandwiches are as good as you are going to find. I just couldn't believe how one place could be so fulfilling. Talk about your one stop shop. And to top it off Angie is about as good as it gets. Montgomery support this gem. How lucky we are.

Great cheese selection amongst all other products. Don't go without trying/buying some blueberry cheddar. It may sound strange but your taste buds will thank you instantly! Have had wonderful service every time to boot. Enjoy!

What a sensorial experience. The lady who runs the shop gave us so many samples, with explanations of each one of them, we bought her all of them! The cheese is so creamy and tasteful, the store is lovely and well organized, we loved the whole experience. Will come back soon.

This is a wonderful shop and right in downtown Montgomery, Texas. I ordered 5 kinds of cheeses sliced and cubed for a memorial service for my brother. The cheeses were perfect and so delicious, a big hit, served with cold meats, crackers and a vegetable tray. Perfect. This shop has so many things to choose from and the people are great!

This place is a hidden gem. Super unique and everyone is friendly.

LOVE the grilled cheeses/ruebens.

I also hate bread and butter pickles but theirs are incredible!!

Amazing grilled cheese sandwiches! Buttery and hot cheesey delicious! This place had all your cheese needs!

We love this place with a great variety of cheese ,sausage and pickled products. Always friendly service . we always try to stop by whenever we get a chance

The butter was amazing and the cheese selection was great. Try the Amish Butter Cheese. Great spot to grab cheese for dinner parties. They also have ice cream, coffee, jams and more.

This place is a treasure for our community. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. They offer a unique selection of cheeses (real cheese), sausages and other items. My children love the candies and my wife and I love trying different things each time we go. If you've not been to Slice of Amish, you are missing out.

I love everything about this store! I always find things that I cant find elsewhere. People there are always so helpful. Highly recommend!

Very nice shop. The person who waited on me was very knowledgeable about the different cheeses they carry. You are able to sample whatever cheese you would like to. My favorite that I tried was the Horseradish Cheddar..Yum!
They have pickled food, jellies, jams, dip, soup mixes, plus much more.

What a great place to have in our community! We've been many times already and they are always fun and helpful. Always offering samples and suggestions. We are hooked on the curds and a few of the amazing cheeses. It's a must stop if you're anywhere near.

Cute little shop with unique options. Walked out with some jars of jelly, sweet balogna, and smoked garlic onion summer sausage along with some chocolate candies. Great customer service.

It is a lovely place with fabulous items, and Holly is a gem.

Great little shop! Knowledgeable staff of all the products! Nice assortment of cheeses, candy,ice cream, meats, spreads, and jams

Great selection, friendly service! Love the cheese curds too. Will definitely be back for more of everything!

Great foods, the most wonderful cheeses. Friendly service.

Love the cheeses, love the products, love the people!