Big Mouth's Deli & Catering

Best sandwich I’ve had since I was a kid in Brooklyn. Nobody puts love into what they do anymore but this place is the exception. Amazingly friendly folks and the owner went out his way to make a dressing for me they don’t normally use. First time I’ve been there and most definitely not the last. Their menu is also incredible. You will not be disappointed.

Amazing sandwiches with fresh ingredients and overall welcoming environment. I truly loved their Canadian breakfast panini special and italian sub. Can’t beat their incredible hospitality!

Just tried this place out for lunch today. I was in the mood for a sandwich and suggested Subway, but my wife said that the West Milford Mom’s Facebook page is always raving about this place!! Turns out that the food was wonderful, generous portions and the pricing is on point. Friendly service and a convenient location on Rt. 23 South. Plenty of parking spaces as well. We had a Joe’s Fresh Italian hero with extra oil and vinegar(made to perfection) and a chicken parmigiana sandwich. The cashier was right when she said that I would be back!! I think next time we will get breakfast.

Amazing place!! First time in town, went there for a coffee, the Staff is super kind and welcoming people. they are very careful to get your order done perfectly. I would rate this place 10 stars.
Sure I’ll be back for another delicious sandwich!!

Joe, the owner, is SO mean. EVERY day I wake up thinking "today is the day that I eat the food that I made purposefully for lunch" and then I look at the specials of the day at Big Mouth and the thought of doing such a thing disappears more quickly than it appeared, a distant memory, a sheer figment of my imagination. Fig and brie griller? Amalfi Coast wrap? LOBSTER RAVIOLI?!?! Yeah ok, let me ignore those and go eat my pb&j while I pretend it's nearly as delectable as their homemade loaded baked potato soup... yeah right🙄.

I should mention that, much like a cobra, you have to unhinge your jaw just to take a bite of literally ANY sandwich they make. It's unbelievable how much goodness they manage to fit between bread that I assume could only be baked to such perfection by Jesus himself.

As with most complicated relationships, I'm unsure if Joe and his gals (who are ALL lovely, I almost want to get a pt job there just to hang out with everyone who works there) do this to me because they love me or because they hate me... and without knowing the answer, I still keep going back.

Is there a "Big Mouth Deli" rehab? Should we all start meeting at the local Presbyterian on Tuesday nights and then ignore each other on Wednesday afternoon as we run into one another picking up our individual orders of the Michael sandwich? Or should we all just say screw it, give in and buy maternity pants?

The only real way for me to find the answers to all of those questions is to... in the name of research... continue going back daily. This is the sacrifice that I will make on behalf of ALL of us... you're welcome.

Joe... your talent has no equal, and neither will my Kohls bill if you keep it up.

First time here and I'm very pleased. The ladies were all so nice and it made me happy to see them dancing! Great vibe in the store and sandwiches were very good!

I’ve reviewed them on yelp but I’m gonna double down on here. There isn’t a bad thing on the menu. The specials are always creative and delicious. And all of that would be good enough for a deli in the woods of north Jersey, but the folks there are THE FRIENDLIEST people you’ll ever get to meet. If you end up in West Milford go here. Heck, just go here, maybe take hike while you’re around here!

Great deli! There are great new specials every day. The black garlic skillet hash is an awesome breakfast.

I’ve been a regular at Big mouths for awhile now. I have to say their food is pretty amazing with generous portions. The staff is always so friendly and engaging with the customers. Never had a bad experience or bad food at this deli. I remember when there were fires in the area this deli was preparing food for the first responders. You can tell they care about their craft and the community they serve.

I order once a week and they never disappoint!! The nicest people there !The food is amazing here !!! The best deli in this entire area !!!

I'm pretty impressed with this deli. I wasn't aware someone new purchased this location. I stopped in a few weeks ago and was pleasantly surprised. They are all very friendly and the food is pretty damn good. Other than the usual breakfast fare, which in particular the TH&C is on the mark. Their omelets are very good and this morning I got the Black Garlic Skillet Hash. Though I'm not used to spicy food for breakfast, I highly recommend it. And their coffee isn't bad either. I think they may be my go to morning stop in stead of Quick Check or WAWA. Far better than G&A in Butler.

This is absolutely the best breakfast sandwich around (spicy crunchy) you're welcome. Everything else is also amazing. Not a bad item yet. Sad our crew moved outta the area. We'll be back again

Hands down the best Deli in NJ ! Whether you go for their great breakfast sandwiches, lunchtime classics or their various daily specials, you will always get amazing food, great service and a smile. In the off-season [ fishing ] I gladly drive the 40 minutes from Fort Lee for my personal favorite sandwich - The Brielle !!!

My husband and I are always looking for a place to go for breakfast on the weekend, and we found a great one at Big Mouth's. We keep coming back so we can try something different, and each time we get something better! Friendly, efficient service. Reasonable prices. Always clean.
If you want a great tasting cup of coffee, you got it.
The muffins (I like the cranberry orange the best) are delicious.

I had to meet a friend for breakfast halfway between his town and mine and chose Big Mouth's. What an excellent choice - the place is clean, Christina, the cashier was super-friendly, and the bacon-and-egg sandwiches were made to perfection. Add to that hot, strong coffee and outdoor seating and it was a terrific morning. I would definitely go back if I am in the area again.

I loved it here! The food is amazing and the staff was so kind, quick, and helpful! If I didn’t live 2 hours away this would be a regular spot for me! So good!

I have been coming here a bunch in the past few months trying different things. Some better than others but nothing has been bad at all and some things were extremely good. The best thing so far is definitely the burger, love that it's simple and fresh (not frozen premade I believe) and cooked to the level you want it and has nailed it every time. It's rare to find good food in this area so it's exciting to add this place to the small list of places I will go back to around here.

OMG.... the Brielle is the best sandwich I've tasted. I'm from Brooklyn so I know sandwiches!!! Great little gem of a deli in Newfoundland on route 23 south.

A bite that will never let you down. This place is not your average deli- they make their own DELICIOUS Roast Beef, Corned Beef, Turkey fresh off the bone, every salad (macaroni, chicken, potato, slaw) in house as well and every single one.... is undeniably good. Fresh bagels and rolls daily, hot coffee, homemade baked goods (cookies, muffins, and CINNAMON ROLLS!!!!) a very cute place and sweet staff. If you’ve been wondering about this place... 100% try it! It’s a half hour drive from me but I come here all the time because it’s that good!

Sunnyside eggs drizzled with pesto on multigrain avocado toast. What a treat for breakfast this morning!