Grand Island-Pizza Amore' "The Wood Fire Way"

The girls at the counter were super nice! Such a gem inside an unsuspecting gas station. Definitely try it out

The owners and staff are always professional and friendly. My favorite pizza in WNY hands down. Perfectly crispy along the edges. You will not be disappointed. Every pie I’ve gotten has looked and tasted fantastic.

We were pleasantly surprised with an incredible menu, friendly staff and very clean restaurant. This is done it the absolute best pizza I've ever had and we definitely plan on coming back. The Italian stallion, barbeque chicken, and 716 were perfectly cooked and left us wishing we had more. I cant wait to eat here again.

Edit: 2 years later and we finally made it back here on a family trip. Same great quality of food. We weren't disappointed in the least! This pizza is amazing, you won't regret it. Try the s'more log. It is as delicious as it is messy, the kids loved it!

Excellent pizza! Tons of cheese and pepperoni! Friendly service too.

OK: no gas station-food jokes about this TRULY terrific wood oven-fired pizza, but the physical location is in a gas station! It's nearly, cleanly separated, and the location is unimportant because most customers get the pizza to go. We discovered this award-winning pizza @ an outdoor concert, where their food truck housed an actual wood oven. The pizza is superb, with very fresh and generous toppings. The staff are personable. There's even an old school video game to play while you wait. Bravo!

I recently visited this gem in Grand Island, NY and I must say the pizza was OUTSTANDING! Pizza was cooked to perfection and the taste was phenomenal. Perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. You can tell the ingredients used are respectable! This restaurant should have more notoriety in the area. A must recommend and I will back when I crave pizza again!

Really great pizza!! I got a personal cheese pizza with the sweet sauce and it was amazing!!!!!

Ordered the Nashville Hot Chicken Pizza and it was great! I called about 15 minutes before they closed and wasn't sure if I'd have time to stop in but the woman was super nice on the phone and I was able to get my order in! Once I got in there the woman who cashed me out was super friendly and I was happy to hear they would bring my pizza out to my car so I didn't have to wait inside! The pizza was great and I'm so glad I could try out a new local place (NT location)! Can't wait to try more of their delicious looking combos/creations!

Love the pizza. I could stop every time I am on Grand Island

Where to begin? The pizza is absolutely perfect! Two different sauces, lots of toppings to choose from, baked in a wood fired oven. This is what pizza should be.
Wings are also baked in the oven instead of deep fried, maybe not quite the traditional Buffalo way, but offers a bit of a less greasy experience. Multiple sauces are available, you'll definitely find a few new favorites.
Staff is always friendly, service is quick.

So on June 22 ordered food and it wasn’t good at all called up spoke to someone they apologized over and over and said give us another chance. So I did ordered last night everything was spot on it was awesome they comped my whole order and made things right. So glad I gave them another shot thank you so
Much for remembering me and taking care of my order. The owner that I talked to was so nice too. She lived up to the guarantee that this time would be better. See ya soon

The sweet sauce slices were amazing, very good pizza. If I ever end up on Grand Island again I'd definitely get this again.

Amazing pizza- I recommend "the big dill" if you're going gourmet, but the cheese and pep was also incredible! I usually feel yucky after engorging on pizza and wings, I didn't get that at all with Pizza Amore.. will definitely be back (often lol)

One of the best pizzas around if you like wood fired and they got great specialty pizzas.

Pizza Amore is one of the best pizzerias on the Island. I think the fact that it shares its location with a gas station deters some people from visiting. At lest that's what I thought for a while before I really realized there some of the best to do it. I called to order a pizza and when I realized I wouldn't be able to make it downtown in time, I called to cancel the order, but instead, they made my pizza a priority and told me it would be ready in time. I can't think of any other place that would do something like that, most places seem bothered that you actually want to eat there food. I've never had a bad slice from here. If you like Dill Pickles, try the Big Dill, it will change your life!

Ordered for the first time..website was easy to navigate, ordered two personal size pizzas and BBQ wings. Everything was absolutely delicious! We love wood fired pizza and always wished there was a place in North Tonawanda.I would Highly recommend Pizza Amore and will definitely be back again...and again...and again!

I was in buffalo last month, and I tried this Pizza, it was absolutely delicious, the guys at the truck were very nice, Great people and great customer service.

while i do not believe this company cares about its customers like i feel like they should, there food is some of the best quality on the island. there customer service isnt satisfying but if your looking for good food then stop in, while i personally will no longer do business here I can appreciate quality ingredients. The owner generally is a great guy along with his wife and his daughter is a good friend. I hope some day we as a whole will see eye to eye again. But if your on the island and want GOOD pizza not BLAND then this is the place to go.

Perfect place for lunch or dinner! Menu has ingenious ideas that are so unique and well done. There are special seasonal items that are posted on social media that you really must try (these items are not on the menu). I got the reuben pizza which was one of the best pizzas I have ever gotten. The crust was a little thin but fluffy. Toppings were perfectly cooked and very tasty. I'll definitely be coming back!

Oh my I hope I have enough space to make this recommendation. Dave and Diana and their team are wonderful. They catered my daughters graduation party. I had to have Gluten free food. Diana went above and beyond to make gluten free pasta and homemade meatballs. Not to mention the gluten free wood fire pizza is amazing. The rest of my family couldn’t stop their comments on how amazing the rest of the food is. If you are looking for a caterer for an event check out Pizza Amore’. Also don’t forget to check them out for a weekly family meal. Their pizza is amazing! Thank you Diana and team for making my daughter’s grad party a huge success!!! We love you guys!!