Sweeties Gourmet Treats Fishers

Sweetie's came through like champs for my wife's 44th birthday! They made it a seamless and effortless process to give them the parameters of what I needed. AND DID THEY DELIVER!! They exceeded my expectations with flawless and master -level results! Sweetie's Gourmet Treats are now my go-to place for custom pastries and baked goods!

I don’t do reviews…maybe one in my life. But, Sarah and the team at Sweeties are the absolute BEST!!! When I sent her a pic of the sweet 16 SpongeBob cake I wanted for my daughter (it’s her favorite episode with the Boys who Cry band), I was skeptical that it would turn out right. I WAS BLOWN AWAY by how well the cake turned out; it made my daughter cry. Not only was it perfect, but it tasted awesome too! I crushed the topper before i could take a pic. I went back today for some cupcakes and they are just as awesome. I would definitely recommend them to anyone!

Love this bakery. My go to for birthday and events especially since they have gluten free options.

Am giving it a 5💥 because these bakers are so amazing😍I asked them to make an L.O.L surprise doll cake for my daughters 4th birthday and they nailed ittt!!!!!Not only did the cake look good but it also tasted amazing!Everybody loved this cake and i am a happy customer😍! Thank you so much sweeties gourmet treats for the job well done🤗

BEST BAKERY EVER! Now I may be biased given I had worked there 2 years ago, but they make the best baked goods. Came in on Friday morning, service was excellent and the girl at the front counter told me a really cool fun fact. I bought 18 cupcakes and an apple pie to take to work for some departing coworkers. Was able to get gluten free cupcakes for my allergy coworkers. And all together was a great price! 11/10 would recommend.

Everyone at my job said these were the best cupcakes that had ever had and are super excited to check out Sweeties for more treats. Special shout out to DaShell for letting me know about gluten free cupcakes and the best ones to get! Super thankful to Tiffany for having a great business. Please support this black owned business.

Thank you so much for making the most delicious cupcakes! Your talent and amazing customer service helped make our daughter’s graduation party absolutely perfect!

Was a little confused by their website initially. I would just recommend going in or calling. The staff was super helpful with the questions I had, and it was super easy to place an order. I left with a bunch of cheesecakes that were probably some of the best I’ve ever had. Additionally it was way cheaper than I anticipated.

It’s really dangerous to my waistline and wallet with how good the sweets are, but I’d highly recommend supporting this small business.

I love the cupcakes and brownies and it was good to receive the information regarding the cupcakes needing to be kept in the refrigerator, because I did by one that was hard and cold, but now it all makes sense. If customers are told these type of things, it'll go a long way at keeping the bad reviews down and allow us to enjoy our purchase,, instead of us assuming the product is old and throwing it away, because the products really are awesome.

I wanted to order a special order of banana pudding.

Nyja helped me and was soooo professional and the pan was HUGE and the pudding was goooood!

I can't believe the price! #ThisPlaceRocks

Fantastic to work with - kind, patient & open to ideas while planning - final product was absolutely DELICIOUS - piñata sprinkle theme, a very happy birthday girl & boy - & guests!! Will be back and highly recommend!!

A gem for sweets. The buttercream on the Neopolitan cupcake was smooth, creamy & not too sweet. The cake was moist. Will be back again for more. Worth the trip.

Professional, attentive, and Oh so good! I ordered "Smash" cakes and cupcakes for my son's 1st Birthday Party. The team provided suggestions and flexibility and the treats were a BIG hit at the event.

Where can I start? Looove the rum cake cup cake & Strawberry lemonade cupcake, sweet potato pie! Omg... I found real sweet potato pie there! (Not pumpkin) lol can't wait to try the brown butter cupcake!! Great staff and owners!! Go there! And they do cakes for all occasions!!!

A great little bakery local to Fishers. They always have a nice selection of cookies and cupcakes when I stop in. Everything we've tried is delicious and from the pictures I've seen, they do a great job decorating cakes. Definitely stop in and try them.

awesome!! this was my first time here- i got the key lime pie, chocolate chip cookies, and cherry cheesecake which were all a hit! online ordering from the website was easy, staff was friendly, and the store looked super cute, will definitely be back

Sweeties knocked it out of the park. They created the most special and delicious cake for my sister in laws baby shower. Was exactly what I envisioned and they took the time to make sure it was. Highly recommend! So so yummy!!

My favorite cupcakes are sweet potato. I followed them from both broad ripples location to too far fisher. I wished they were closer to the west side. I would come more often.

This place is amazing! Better cheesecake than the Cheesecake Factory and the cupcakes are to die for! Not dry at all like some cup cakes tend to be and very flavorful!

I got three different kinds of cheesecake and each one was amazing. The strawberry was by far the favorite. Will be going back for more!

Love the turtle cheesecake, caramel cupcakes, strawberry lemonade cupcakes, & our daughter loves every cookie she’s ever had from here. All the employees are always super nice!