Wise Guys Pizza

I had issues with Wise Guys back in the day with the old owner. But things have gotten so much better. Tonight the guy who took my order, made my pie, and checked me out was so chill and polite and really cared about making sure I got my money's worth. The results were great, I almost ate the whole large myself in one sitting (don't tell my doctor).

I grew up in Como! My family and I love Wise Guys and have been eat their pizza for years!!! Best Pizza!! Highly recommended!

Double cooked bbq wing are the best!!! And that Chicago style supreme was prolly one if the best I've ever had!!!

Best home-town style and flavor I’ve had in a long while. Huge quantity, and also checks the ‘leftover pizza next morning is great’ box. A bit spendy, but the taste is commensurate with price

Wiseguys pizza is a friend favorite in my group! We love the xl pizzas and we have been eating them since we’re teenagers! Great pizza! Friendly staff and you can have a pint at McNallys while you wait on your pizza!

I tried wise guys for the first time a couple weeks ago and I’ve ordered pick up 3 times since then. The pizza has been perfection every time but tonight the wings weren’t cooked all the way through. No biggie, just popped them in the oven for a little bit and they were super good.

Stuffed crust 4 topping is perfection and the staff is lovely. Fantastic stop for Chicago deep dish in COMO

I've had a few bad experiences lately and thought they may have changed their recipes up. However, I visited last week, and the food was great again. I always ordered the cheese bread, and that was excellent. I also tried the wings and am impressed!

Ownership changed last month and they are making a difference! I've been ordering from Wise Guys for 10+ years. In the past year or so, it was definitely having trouble, particularly with slow deliveries. This time however, we ordered our favorite custom pizza and it was the best we've had from them. I hope this continues.

FYI our pizza is: Medium pizza with Garlic, Bacon, Pepper Jack Cheese, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, and Green Peppers.

Was so shocked to see so many bad reviews, I love this pizza! We have had the hand- tossed, the chicago style, and the deep dish. FYI if you're from chicago area looking for "deep dish" then you want the chicago style pizza (stuffed). The deep dish is really good but it is more like a pan pizza. I've never had an issue with the staff and we've been there a few different times. If my partner liked deep dish pizza as much as I did, we'd be eating here every week.

We are from out of town, visiting family in the hospital. Was really craving some good pizza. They say hole-in-the-wall restaurants usually have the best food. That's exactly what this place is. At least as an out-of-towner, it felt like a secret place. It's in the back room of a bar, and they literally have a counter and a window that you can see a giant kitchen through.

The food.... Oh my God. I got a 10" order of cheese sticks and a 14" deep dish supreme. The smell that hit me when they put my food on the counter was like nothing I've smelled before. My mouth instantly watered.

I didn't get to start eating my food for about an hour after I got it. It was somehow still hot, and let me tell you, that was the absolute best pizza I've ever had the pleasure of eating. Every bite was perfect. The crust was incredible. The cheese sticks were basically a giant pile of melted mozzarella with garlic and a little bread. I say that in a good way. They were amazing. We stuck the pizza in our hotel fridge and had some cold for breakfast today. I don't know how their pizza improved in the refrigerator overnight, but somehow it did.

If you get a chance to visit this place, do it. I'm sure all the locals are like "yeah, Wiseguys, everyone knows that place" but I'm going to call it a secret restaurant anyway. 10/10, will absolutely miss this pizza when I go home.

I love the Chicago style and stuffed one! Probably it’s better than domino’s and Shakespeare’s in como!

Best Pizza hands down in Columbia. Prices are great with the coupon they offer and beat the clock is awesome. One issue I had happen two times when I ordered for pickup was, when I got there, someone had taken my pizza for delivery and I had to wait for two more to be made. Staff there are nice. Sometimes when picking up also, you can wait several minutes after ringing Bell for someone to come help you. Aside from those two things, it is by far, my favorite pizza in Columbia and the ranch is awesome as well. I order pizza from here twice a week for the past 18 months roughly. I will continue to eat the pizza here and be loyal as long as they continue with quality ingredients like they have. I suggest you try the pizza if looking for good pizza. Also ask for ranch to dip the pizza in if you like ranch. Love Wise Guys 🍕

My favorite pizza place in town. The pizza is cheesy, saucy, and the original crust has a great texture. Deep dish is great but not quite chicago authentic. Where this place really shines is the wings. The hot wings Wise guys serves are phenomenal. The absolute best in town hands down.

Overall Pizza 4/5 and the wings 6/5
so an avg of 5/5

This pizza is legit. Drove from STL and had to try local. The cheese is phenomenal. Sauce is delicious. Sausage spicy but great. Definitely give it a shot, it's worth it!

I'm a pizza person. I've ate pizza in many different states and all over Missouri. This is BY FAR my FAVORITE pizza place. The pizza is phenomenal. The deep dish is my favorite. And they are VERY generous with their toppings. We just ate pizza in Wyoming an it doesn't even compare to wise guys. This place is a little hole in the wall, if you go to the business. The building is old and out dated but the pizza is amazing. Looks can be deceiving. Don't let the old building scare you away. Highly recommend. You won't be disappointed. We eat here a couple times a month.

This place has great food! They weren't delivering because of the nasty weather, but we ordered anyway for pick up. Yes, like other reviews say, the location is in a bar and not the greatest. Delivery would be a better option. BUT ...that says nothing for the food. The pizza and cheese sticks were the bomb. Strangely enough, they even have REALLY good ranch! Ready in less than 20 minutes. Staff was quick and friendly and the food is priced really cheap.

Delivery was a bit long so it wasn't too hot when I got it but the pizza is delicious ❤

I love love their food. Its a small hole in wall place. They offer outside seating. Its a little confusing bc its connected to a bar. But the pizza is worth it and their salads are da bomb!!!

I'm a columbia native and with shakespears, pizza tree, gumbys, tonys, I take this statement seriously. Wise Guys is the best pizza in town. They never dissapoint. McNally's is my favorite bar in town and they have great wings and great fries. Try the fries with the ranch dressing, it never dissapoints. The pizza is always top notch. Deep dish is a bit of a stretch, but it's delicious without the gimmick.