West Side Mutual

Clay was very friendly and shared stories about local popular places in the area. He was not rushed and able to share pertinent information. He photo copied a picture of my Dad's house for me from decades ago. He came out to my house promptly and detailed the difference between two possible policies! I am extremely happy to have him serve as my insurance agent!

Really appreciate their knowledge, attentiveness, and helping me understand the coverage. Clay has been a great help over the years and we've had many different types of coverage through them.

Disappointed with the customer service. We moved forward with a home insurance policy with West Side Mutual. They then cancelled our policy on us after we had already closed on the home. Additionally, the tone from their representative in their cancellation email was incredibly rude.

Took about 3 months to decline virtually all losses on my house after the derecho. They were however quick to follow up with a letter notifying me that my insurance is going to be cancelled and non renewable as of December because of "claim activity". Stay far away from these guys. They are definitely crooks. Hire out rude independent adjusters that try to get them to pay little to no money for claims.