Mellow Mushroom New Albany

Bradley was our server the last two times we've been there. I always order the Marley, which isn't on their menu any longer, and they're always accommodating! The pretzel bites are great! This pizza is top shelf! The vibe and service has always been amazing!

I'm a big fan of mellow mushroom. The chicken parm sandwich is great, and they have a great mushroom pizza as seen in the picture.

Probably the BEST pizza I’ve ever had!!!! Very fun decor, clean, friendly staff, we liked being able to see the pizza being hand tossed. We went on a Saturday evening and there was a balloon artist for the kids making the absolute best balloon animals I’ve ever seen!!!! Definitely have to give her props!!!!

I was surprised at the quality of pizza that came out. I genuinely enjoyed the sauce, crust and other ingredients. Good place for families with an upbeat atmosphere. Johnny was an attentive bartender and very informative.

The food here is amazing, and it's my favorite of the Mellow Mushroom locales in central Ohio for that reason. The staff is super friendly, accommodating, and attentive. The veganized holy shiitake is my regular order here. The others have liked the Thai Dye pizza and the buffalo chicken version.

That being said, they always mess up one of our orders, and we often end up waiting a good 30+ minutes extra for one of our dishes. The servers and managers have always taken care of us when there has been a mixup in the kitchen, and they discount our order, so we keep coming back here despite the drive, but if you have plans afterwards, keep possible delays in mind.

Love this establishment. Great for a family lunch or an evening of craft flights & music. The service is outstanding. Everyone on staff seems to really care if you're happy.
Wow, the food....this is what P&P wish they were. Amazing crust for all the pizza options. Chewy, firm, crunchy & golden. Huge topping assortment with lots of variety in all toppings. The prices are surprisingly low/affordable for the quality. *The owner was a regular in a retail shop I used to manage. He's an awesome dude. Always friendly and respectful. :) *

It was our first time at this location and it exceeded our expectations! We simply had the lunch special - a slice of pizza and a yummy salad but there are five stars on everything above for a reason! We're looking forward to going back!

Stunning. Atmosphere and character are through the roof, and then the food is up for the game too!!

Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, and good food. Double baked garlic parmesan wings may be some of my favorite! Pizza was great too, fresh ingredients. Will be back again.
Update: brownie is really good too
Update 2: tried the double oven baked hot wings today, very good

Very nice atmosphere and good menu. Food items are generous in size and done as it should be done.

Wow! We’re locals but this was our first time trying MM. Definitely won’t be our last. Let me start by saying our server, Daniel, was fantastic! Very personable & attentive. The Cloud 9 wings & Kosmic Karma pizza were AMAZING. Five stars. We’ll be back!

We love sitting at the bar! We've always had the best, friendliest, and fastest service at the bar. The pizza is delicious and the beer selection is the best! One of our favs we just keep coming back to.

This was our first visit here, and let me tell you... I'm pretty sure that we've found a new favorite place to eat!! The second we walked in the door the we were totally digging the atmosphere, I mean you can never go wrong with C3PO, R2D2 & Yoda greeting you at the front entrance foyer!

Once we were inside the restaurant we were immediately greeted by Sydney and seated at a table. Sydney was also our server, and quickly took our drink order. He ordered Coca-Cola and I got plain Tea. When she came back with our drinks she immediately took our lunch order. We decided to try the Magic Mushroom Soup to start off with, which came out quickly and did not disappoint!! It was so creamy and it was like a mushroom flavor explosion in your mouth! We both agreed that regular mushroom soup would never ever be the same. Lol.

For lunch he ordered the Sausagefest Calzone with a side of Spicy Ranch. I ordered The Elevated Cobb Salad without tomatoes (allergic) and the Balsamic Vinegarette dressing. Once our lunches came out we were even more thrilled with this place. The portions were huge, and the flavor on both of our lunches was frikin amazing!! He could only eat about 1/2 of his Calzone and I probably only got through about 1/4 of my salad. So we asked for to go boxes, and Sydney immediately asked us if we wanted to also take our drinks and if we'd like a bag to carry everything.

Sydney's service was phenomenal! She was always pleasant, and had a smile on her face and truly looked like she enjoyed her job! In fact, every employee we encountered was also smiling and pleasant. 🤯 That in itself was very refreshing!!

The portions and quality of food was outstanding! The restrooms were clean,, and smelled good. The entire ambiance of the restaurant was very chill and inviting. We LOVED the use of all the reclaimed Wood! Plus, all COVID Health guidelines were being followed by all the staff we seen at the restaurant, and all the tables were set up socially distanced.

We will most definitely be returning, with our kids next time lol, so that they can enjoy it with us!!

Ordered to go from here for the first time. Friendly staff welcomed me inside the restaurant and had my food ready upon my arrival. Pickup time was accurate. They showed me my food to make sure that I was pleased with my order. The food looked great!

Delicious Pizza and good service. Can watch the kitchen make the pizzas from the majority of the tables. Family friendly. The portions are big - the calzones can easily feed two people, or allow for a second meal with the leftovers.

Very cozy atmosphere with a rustic look, and a nice looking bar. Sat at the bar, service was very prompt and friendly. The bruschetta was amazing and a nicer plating/presentation than would be expected at a pizza place. The House Special pizza is loaded with toppings, and a small was definitely enough for two people. There are plenty of pizza places in New Albany, but it is the care with which their food is prepared that sets the Mushroom apart from the rest. I will definitely be back to try their other items.

Food was great, amazing beer selection, there was even a really nice lady that made balloon animals for our kids. We'll definitely be back.

I love good pizza, and MM always has thr best crust around. Chewy, yeasty, and moist. Their topping selection is extensive, and their specialty creations are very inventive. I love their cookies for desert "a la mode." Theor salads are great, with the Caesar being my favorite. Try jt with extra dressing and Anchovies!

I love the atmosphere in every MM. They are all unique, quirky, and cozy. Service was sadly very slow and unattentive this vist. Still, there were no mistakes or problems.

MM is by far the best pizza chain in the country. I've been to 6 of them in different states and never had a bad meal.

Its been years since I had five guys and I forgot just how good these burgers are! Since I'm doing the keto diet I had their lettuce wrap with the veggies that fit my macros and it was still amazing.

Great service, atmosphere, and taste. When I needed a good business lunch without the interruption of things going poorly. Great execution.