Dive Bar Pizza

I’ve been coming here since they first opened in 2019 and it never disappoints ❤‍🔥 Amazing pizza (👀 spicy clam pie), fresh salads 💅🏽 and tasty heroes 🥖, all featuring their house made mozz 🧀.

It’s a lively atmosphere with friendly staff and are always hosting local musicians 🎸 Great place for groups and to hang outside 🌞

I had been told this was the best pizza in the area. They were not kidding! We had the grandma pie. Half pepperoni and half meatballs. AMAZING. Excellent sauce, excellent meats.

I still dream about the seasonal veggie pizza I had here 1.5 years ago. One of the best pizzas I've had in my life (and I am a pizza fiend). I would make the trip up to Montauk just to get this pizza and drive directly home. This is the BEST pizza!

Such an amazing stop at dark evening, dar road, clear sky night. Happy people by the lousy bar, disco sound, dimmed light with different colors. That pizza window, with two lovely young people, relaxing, talking, laughing, ...... feel like stepping into an Utopia.

Easy drive to montauk
imagine it very busy during sports event or holiday and weekend
Service was amazing. Tony was great and staff was friendly, positive.

Very clean outside and indoor seating with tv screens

Menu Best pizza
Taste was delicious garlic knots and pie grandma hands down was the best
Got some beers
Highly Recommend for best pizza in town !

Best bar … I feel bad I only find this post the night we were leaving .. I can’t wait to come back and have more fun !!
The bartender on a Monday night was just the person we have meet in montauk , very friendly and professional , unfortunately I forgot his name !!!
Next time we have to stop by and try the pizza !

Awesome ramp to skate but I believe the town prevents you from skating it now. The pizza was good and the vibe was cool, just sad not able to skate the ramp anymore. Hopefully it gets sorted out and we can get a good session in soon!

Best Pizza for a reason. Homemade crust, sauce and cheese. Totally worth the stop.
We were there mid-day, so not crowded. The bartender Kyle was cool and shared the local history. Made to feel at home

Side of the road pizza bar that is worthy of a stop when in town.
The cheese and pepperoni slices were amazing … wasn’t a big fan of the grandma slice - dough was a little too soggy for me.

Outstanding pizza and great staff. Must stop if you are out in Montauk. I think this might be the best pizza on the East End.

Truth in advertising! The name says it all. This place is a Pizza Dive Bar in the very best way. The pies are super tasty, great crust. The people are super friendly and welcoming. Great place to relax, get fed, and have a good time.

This place lives up to it's name! The pizza was seriously the best I've ever had and the place was definitely a dive bar.

Delicious! Everything was fresh, hot and tasty!

Name says it all. It's a great indoor/outdoor low key dive bar vibe Hang. The Pizza is pretty good too.

We camped at Hither Hills and came here like 3 times lol. My husband and I called it "pizza and activities center." First off, the pizza is great, and actually better than most pizza joints on long island. They have ping pong, corn hole, pool...activities! Outdoor picnic area. Indoor seating and live music! We loved it. Will definitely go back next time we are out that way.

Anyone who says this place is mediocre or not fancy is completely missing the point. This place is completely out of place in the elegance of the Hamptons, which is great. The place is old, basic, walls covered in sharpie graffiti, but that all adds to the focus on the pizza, which is some of the best I’ve ever had. The staff are friendly, the prices are reasonable, the drinks are cheap, and the pizza is FIRE. We had the grandma pizza and a white pizza, both large and tasty.

Go here. It’s awesome.

This place is just the best! Amazing pizza! I never really opt for a white slice but this is hands down the best white slice I have ever had in my life, speaking from a chef! And the cheese steak. Damn. Love the staff love the poetry on the walls. Never ever disappoints ❤

It’s really nice to have a spot like this in the area that can honestly be a little stuffy. They have a laid back vibe, live music and great pizza. Their sauce was amazing, the garlic knots were great, and had a variety of pizza toppings.

Probably the best Pizza our entire family has enjoyed together. Everyone, from my 4yr old & 8yr old boys , to my wife and I absolutely loved it !
Fresh high quality ingredients. Crisp crust.
Great Pizza !

Cool small town divey atmosphere and really solid pizza. This place has great reviews and met expectations. Well done, highly recommend!