Montauk Manor

We chose the Montauk Manor preferring a hotel over the typical motel experience in Montauk. The Montauk Manor sits up high with beautiful vistas, lush lawns, tennis courts and well appointed swimming pool. The beach is accessible via parking passes or a free shuttle minute away.
The rooms have kitchenette. This would be great to save some money. We would have preferred a king bed to the kitchen. The room had its own large balcony that had ample room for table of 4 & four lounge chairs. Newly opened restaurant served great breakfast. Dinner looked great too, but we dined out.

Rooms were great - clean, spacious and comfortable. Had everything we needed for a weekend stay, including a coffeemaker. View of the water from our terrace was beautiful. Short drive to Camp Hero (GREAT spot), Montauk Lighthouse and town. There is a shuttle that will take you into town which was a great perk that we were not able to make use of, but did like that the opportunity was available should we choose to use it. Would definitely stay again. Food at Monte's was great, as were the drinks!

The property is absolutely beautiful! Take in mind it is on the Historical list. Customer service was very pleasant. The employees were all very courteous and professional. Although it is not so much a “hotel” but privately owned units, it does have all the amenities of a hotel. The shuttle service to and from town is a definite plus!! Would definitely return again!!

We got married in Montauk this past weekend and used Montauk Manor for our hotel block and getting ready space for the girls. It was absolutely perfect!

Donna got us all set up and accommodated everything we needed, and continuously checked in with us to make sure we continued to have everything we needed.

It was the most beautiful place to have our guests stay, almost every single guest who stayed on our hotel block told me how amazing it was!

I have traveled to many countries and stayed in hotels. But I have never seen such a great hotel. It has a parking lot that I can call big, there is both normal parking and handicap parking. The exterior view of the hotel is quite wonderful, you will already see the rooms when you watch the videos. There is also a view of the Atlantic Ocean in front of you. There are seats against the view. The rooms are absolutely beautifully designed. I can say that there is everything you can think of. You'll feel like you're at home. Great service. There is a restaurant on the ground floor of the hotel. If one day you are on your way to Montauk, I can definitely recommend you to stay here. It's definitely a great place.

We loved every second of our stay! Great location, the one-bed was spacious and clean. We had fun playing tennis and watching the sunset. We will come back!!

My husband and I blocked off a set of rooms at the Montauk Manor for our wedding weekend and had an incredible experience. The hotel staff was so accommodating and went above and beyond to make sure that ourselves and our family and friends had an exceptional stay. Donna was available leading up to the weekend and during our whole stay, always making sure everyone was comfortable and happy. Fantastic location, beautiful rooms/views, and great food, we couldn’t recommend the Montauk Manor more!

We went to the Montauk Manor for a three day getaway. The accommodations were excellent. There are a few suggestions which would enhance and improve the experience at Montauk Manor. Offering coffee for guests, in the lobby, throughout the day, would be a nice touch. Additionally, since the Manor Is roughly a mile from the village, a gift boutique in the building would be a bonus to purchase a newspaper and other items and necessities.

The hotel and grounds are beautiful. They have a restaurant in the hotel, although we did not eat there they have that option. We had reservations for dinner at Harvest and the Montauk Manor shuttle bus drove us there and back which was great. Check in and check out was a breeze. We had a 1 bed room luxury suite and it was very nice

Initially the room I booked was considerably smaller than I’d anticipated. With very little ado management was happily able to upgrade my reservation to a more accommodating room. Service as always was excellent, as was dinner at Monte’s, the in-hotel restaurant.

Been coming to Montauk Manor for many years and pleased every time. Great location and love having a small kitchen for coffee and snacks. 2 bathrooms is ideal for us. Already booked labor day weekend

Room 416 was a little outdated. With questionable furniture choices. Of the four equally priced rooms in our reservation, it was by far the least desirable.

That being said the staff and facilities are amazing…. We utilized the shuttle which was very convenient and had a delicious dinner at Montey’s.

My partner and I went to the Montauk Manor off-season at the end of April. While some people warned me that there wouldn’t be much to do, because of the Manor, that could not be less of the case! We found ourselves in a beautifully maintained location and building in which a lovely restaurant, wonderful outdoor scenery, and many incredible amenities made our stay efficient fun and extremely well worth the money and time! There were plenty of restaurants, beachfronts, and fun pubs and breweries to find ourselves busy and beyond content! A few things to shout out are the incredible shuttle service that, with your stay, is completely complementary and will get you around Montauk and even to the lighthouse in extremely fast time. For my partner and I who don’t own a car and live in the city, this is incredible. Also, the Montauk Manor restaurant, Monte’s, was unbelievable and I’d have to say they had probably the best ravioli that I’ve ever tried in my entire life! We look forward to our next stay at the Manor, hopefully this summer!

Everything about this property is fabulous. The accommodations, the staff, the restaurant; Montauk Manor never fails to make our annual trip absolutely amazing. Diana at the front desk went above and beyond this year to make our stay wonderful. She is part of the reason why we will continue to stay at the Manor when we vacation there. Cant wait to come back.

We've stayed at the Manor many times over many years. We've also been in many different types of rooms, which vary widely from small one bedroom to large. I always enjoy the beautiful lobby. It's a wonderful place to stay

We go a few times every year to visit Montauk and enjoy a stay at Montauk Manor. A lovely addition to the Manor's offerings is Monte's Restaurant serving fine food
wine and cocktails in the cozy dining room and lobby bar.
Accomodations are varied and pleasing. The pool is inviting and there is outdoor seating to enjoy the stunning sunsets.
You will get a good reception from the great staff in all areas and enjoy the charm of this historic destination.

J.C. Bladt

We've stayed in Montauk hotels\motels many times before- always dreaming of staying at the Montauk Manor 'Castle'. Dream came true and did not disappoint! Beautiful water views on the grounds with sightings of deer, elegant lobby, and loft room was amazingly impressive! Every amenity provided with 2 Queen beds, full couch bed, even a twin cot...2 full baths, full kitchen complete with microwave, dishwasher,.. Just every convenience!
We felt more "at home", not in a standard hotel room.

I have been coming to Montauk since I was a kid and have stayed at multiple locations but non as nice and accommodating as Montauk Manor! For the past 3 years I have come back with my family and we found our home away from home here at Montauk Manor! Patty and Janice are excellent they are extremely friendly, helpful and accommodating! We look forward to returning again this summer! Thank you again Patty and Janice!

We love this unique spot in Montauk. High on a hill overlooking Fort Pond Bay, Montauk Manor is full of old world character and comfort. The rooms are spacious and the facilities great, and the addition of Montes At The Manor as the onsite restaurant is excellent. The Manor's shuttle takes guests to and from Montauk if they wish, which is a super helpful added bonus. We've stayed here many times now and will definitely be coming back.

The Montauk Manor is lovely and the grounds are wonderful. We had a delightful stay, so nice to have a kitchenette and coffee maker in the room!