Morty's Oyster Stand

So glad we made the choice to pull in here for a lovely, relaxed, oystery and boozy lunch. It’s got the perfect Montauk beach vibe and generous and delicious frozen drinks. Try the calamari. And enjoy the design and custom made wall paper!

I read some of the reviews here where they gave 1 or 2 stars and I think that's an unfair rating. The restaurant decor is really nice and chic, the staff were personable and very friendly, the drinks were a bit pricey, food options were great and balanced. We mainly tried the seafood options and the quality, taste and presentation was very satisfying.

Wonderful setting, very good food, although a bit on the pricy side.

The oysters were the best I’ve had anywhere. Lobster roll was good not mind blowing, but eh e cocktails are prime. Also the chicken sando was very nice.

Id highly recommend this spot for a great drop in lunch during a chill beach day.

The food was fresh as can be and the flavors were delicious and uncommon. Steamers steamed in lemon and thyme were terrific. We had a tropical rum drink that made us feel like we were truly on vacation and the vibe Cyril left behind was palpable. We loved the place.

This place was such an amazing find. We were visiting for a wedding and had a free day to find some lunch and came here. We had the oysters, fish tacos and tried two drinks all of which were amazing. They had the absolute best service too. Very fast and the servers were so incredibly nice.

My husband and I visited Morty's this summer and were absolutely amazed at how delicious the food was! We are foodies so we have very high standards. Food was perfection, service was amazing and we even got to meet the owner! He sat next to us and he was so friendly, he even treated us to an amazing dessert. Also, the decor was beautiful too. Overall a perfect experience. :-)

Absolutely epic new roadside restaurant on Montauk Highway, everyone has been freaking out about how good the food is and now I know why. It's unreal, and the service was perfect. Bravo

This place was excellent on every level - ambiance, food, service - we had a wonderful time! I highly recommend the oysters, fish and chips, ceviche, and the key lime tarte. They even had a kids menu! Lovely experience

Delicious fresh seafood and very friendly service.

My fiancé and I loved this place! Really friendly staff, excellent fresh food, and A+ Drinks. Very cool, cozy ambiance as well. One of our favorite restaurants in the Hamptons

unbelievable seafood, the service was some of the best we’ve received. Would 100% recommend for anyone staying in the area. We will definitely be back. Try the BBC and the seafood platters!

I would recommend this establishment to any and everyone! world class seafood served by a top notch professional staff! Additionally, we were informed that the place has hired new high class management which is why the service and food were of such good quality!

I went to dinner here with my bachelorette party. Our servers Macarena and Annemaria were awesome. The food was and the service was great. Would definitely go back.

Found my cocktail of the summer here - the bbc. Real fruit, frozen, delicious. Also the food, people, ambiance, music all great. Local gem. Love it here.

Amazing food, service and scene in the old Cyril’s spot. Do yourself a favor and order the lobster roll, oysters, fried chicken, and arguably the best French fries out east. Oh and don’t forget a BBC!

Great place to stop for delicious seafood

Awesome staff, great ambiance, killer vibes. Can’t wait to go and chug back some oysters! And the bartenders were smokin hot ;)

great food with healthy choices and good frozen drinks.
great service. thanks Andreas for your hospitality.

Delicious apps, super well prepared, and absolutely wonderful, friendly servers! Menu and food are fantastic!

Absolutely amazing place, with great service & cocktails! Can't wait to go back!