The Lobster Roll Amagansett

So delicious!!! Definitely will b back again. We had the calamari to start and the warm lobster roll, fish and chips, fried flounder sandwich, and chicken tenders as our mains ; paired with non other than beer from the local brewery - montauk brewery. Yum! 😋 Cute little atmosphere, does get busy so there was a minor wait (20m) to be seated. But once there, service was great, and the food was worth it.

This is a place right out of the movies (In fact a tv show the affair) but the food was spectacular. Simple yet full of natural flavor. I had a lobster roll - seafood bisque (was told this was their best) and an ear of the sweetest best corn ever. It was like I’d never tasted lobster or corn so delicious. Here’s one of the most important things after visiting this area- they seemed to want me and my business- unlike other places

The deconstructed lobster 🦞 roll was stellar, the cod had a really nice golden fry on the fish and chips but needs a little more salt. The fried flounder had amazing crunch and tasty. A must stop on the way to the state parks.

Best lobster roll we tried on our trip through NY, Mass, and Maine - so that’s saying something. Their hot lobster roll can’t be beat! Paired with Hearty Manhattan Chowder is *chef’s kiss*. Only thing we didn’t enjoy were the buffalo calamari. I think we just enjoy calamari prepared the southern, calabash way. Don’t miss a stop in here. They are also dog friendly!

Great little stop. Very friendly and helpful service. Good food. My wife and I each had a lobster roll, which were both delicious. I had the spicy passionfruit margarita, which was almost too spicy. Pleasant sitting area outside. Only downside is that the place (like most of the local food establishments) was somewhat spending. Still worth it.

We had the famous lobster roll with fries, and it’s as good as they say. Fresh, tasty and filling. I also ordered New England clam chowder, it was perfect. Not too salty, not too oily and large chunks of clam. Prices are what you expect for fresh seafood. The vibe is “beach shack” and there is plenty of parking. Wait time was 30min, but food was ready in less than 10.

This place opens at 11:45 and you need to get there at 11:30 if you don’t wait to wait on line! Be there early! Food was great, we got lobster bisque, hot lobster rolls and mozzarella sticks! Food was sooo good! Casual and good!

The place to be for Lobster rolls. Served in either the traditional or hot lobster, you can’t go wrong. The clam chowder and fish and chips were really good as well. Really nice setting and service as well. Highly recommend this place.

Wow! This place is incredible! Food, drinks, service & atmosphere, all worth a 5 star review! We shared a lobster roll & lobster bisque and our server was so kind - even offered us an extra bun since we were sharing! Highly recommend visiting this place!

The Lobster Rolls are a GENIUS! Eating outside is always awesome and I will never forget this moment I would eat here! I first tried it during the Pandemic in September of 2020, and I want to come back! If 5+ stars was an option, I would give it at least 10 stars.

Lobster roll is a must when having lunch here! The price is standard, but lobsters are always expensive! A burger cost $16 and a lobster roll @$30. It’s a great place and I totally recommend it!

Looking for that quintessential I am on vacation meal? Lobsters, sweet corn, clams? It just did not get any better than coming to the Lobster Roll, an icon welcoming your arrival to Montauk. Menu choices are everything seafood plus a few grilled types of meat for land lovers. Additionally, they have express orders for quartz of soups and takeout too. And they have many healthy salads and add on's too. For those concerned about health issues, they sanitize, wear masks, and appear exceptional in paying attention. They also have both indoor and covered outdoor seating. And if you opt for the Clams Casino, save the dish and pour the bacon flavors garlic butter over your sweet corn and lobster or baked potato. My superb waitress tipped me off. The taste was just out of this world! Enjoy!

It is a great place to eat, get a drink and spend some good time with family or friends.
Great lobster roll, great lobster bisqué.

The most delicious, buttery, mouth watering lobster rolls! In love. Still dreaming about those rolls. Loved that it was an old style diner, we thoroughly enjoyed sitting outside and enjoying our food.

Probably the best lobster roll in the hamptons area. We arrived right when they were about to close, but that didn’t impact the freshness of the food one bit. I got the cold lobster roll but a few of the people I was with got the hot lobster roll. Both were absolutely incredible and a must have when in the area. We did get bitten by mosquitoes a few times so be aware it’s a bit buggy. This is a dining but very low-key establishment. Nothing fancy just good food.

best lobster rolls this end. cool vibe. loved the drinks and not short on menu options. friendly staff even with the hectic pushy city snobs. the rolls bring the crowds and the vibe mellows us all. love love this place. its a yearly tradition. make it your own.

Drove about 3 hours to eat here and it did not disappoint. Delicious fresh seafood. Wait time was a bit but sitting at the bar cut it in half. Staff friendly and funny😀The warm lobster roll was the best come with big chunks of lobster meat! The original lobster roll was just as i expected, a lobster salad put on roll. Awesome. While wait they have a separate line to get a drink, cool. Waitress said there was an upstairs also. I am definitely going back! Beautiful town it was located in also

Servers are friendly and the menu is extensive. Highly recommend the hot lobster roll, though the traditional cold one is solid as well. Onion rings are very oily, so I'd suggest skipping them. Tip: this place is busiest when it first opens, so go for a later lunch or dinner. Nice outdoor space with flowers to help the space feel cozy.

Delicious food, we waited less than 20 minutes which was amazing on father's day. Loved the halibut, catch of the day, shrimp scampi was delicious. Fish n chips was crispy and delicious 😋

No trip to Montauk is complete without visiting this place! Lobster Roll is a staple whenever I visit and everything about the place makes the experience amazing. It goes without saying that you need to order the classic lobster roll (hot or cold, both are really good) and try it for yourself. The place is always pretty busy so try to get there earlier if you have a larger group. They also have lots of seating both indoors and outdoors depending on the weather and mood you are in. Their service is pretty quick and the food is really tasty and makes you know that you are really in a coastal town. Definitely check this place out if you are in town.