Western Ave Pizzeria

My husband and I stopped by for lunch and was greeted with a smile by whole staff! We had a steak and cheese grinder and fries! Cooked to perfection! The prices are great too! Very clean restaurant! Sorry we missed you today Russ maybe next time! I would recommend this spot to anyone who wants affordable, well cooked food and impeccable service! Thanks to all of you!
**Check out the new menu board**

Very friendly staff, excellent pizza and their steak and cheese subs are stuffed with meat. Excellent location, but easy to miss.

Love the Mexican calzone! The 10” is just enough to fill you up, but I’d recommend ordering the 16” so you have some to take home!
Also got a calzone for my mother, for she is truly the best.

Amazing!!! I’ve been coming here since I was 16. I’m 26 now and I still love going. I live a couple towns away now of course but they’re worth the drive. I always get the Buffalo chicken sub but their pizza is amazing!! Their western ave cream soda is off the hook also! 5 out of 5 starts because I can’t give more.

I recently discovered this place and I'm so glad I did!! The food is amazing! It's hard to find a place that makes good Italian subs and they do it the best I've ever had! Fast, efficient and the staff are very friendly every time I've gone here.

Great pizza and great folks
My daughter and I think they have one of the best raspberry lime Ricky sodas we have ever tasted, western Ave sodas

Hands down the best place around! Great friendly people! Love their food! Great prices

I love the people and food here! We eat here at least twice a month. My mother in law who lives out of state compares every white pizza she gets to Western Ave. So far none have compared fairly. The hardest part about eating here is making up my mind!

Love the food, especially the pizza, at Western Ave! We live in the next town over, which has a couple pizza places, but still make the trip here because the food is just a lot better! Staff has always been friendly as well. Their prices have gone up a bit, but where haven't prices gone up lately. Still going here for my pizza!

We haven’t gone here in years. Anyways we ordered steak and cheese subs and fries. Fries were great, crunchy and hot after a 15 min car ride. Now the steak and cheese I had... best I ever had. Roll was perfect as well as the steak. Didn’t get soggy after a 15 min car ride. If you never had the food their you must go, you won’t regret it. Chicken fingers are fresh and best around to. Thanks for the great food guys we will definitely be back.

Pizza is awesome! Have tried the pizza in Henniker and Hillsborough & surrounding local areas and none compare to here! For those saying they don’t answer phone they do everytime I call by the 3rd ring. Friendly people here too.

We needed 40 dinners for a team playing locally. Rusty and his crew were amazing. They handled not only the volume, but also the dietary restrictions without so much as a hiccup. They delivered the food right on time and it was just what the team needed after a great game. We will definitely be using Western Ave Pizzeria the next time we are in town!!!

Great little spot to grab a slice.

GREAT people that make GREAT food! Their pizza is delicious and I love their homemade honey mustard and ranch dressings. Chicken tenders are one of my favorites and I highly recommend their specialty pizzas. I’m getting hungry just typing this review- guess I’ll have to call in an order!

Best pizza, chicken fingers and the honey mustard is delicious! Well worth the drive to get their food! Their staff is friendly and always greet you with the utmost importance. By far this is the best pizza take out we have ever been to! We will certainly be coming back for more!

I am gluten free and they have the best gf pizza, I was very pleased and the price was perfect. 10/10 I am getting my gf pizzas here every time, the staff are lovely and can make a pie faster than you can say supercalifragilisticexpialidoshous!

Best place in Henniker to eat. Those sticky wings are the best around that includes Concord. Just wish the order taker's service was a little more polite. This place does have great customer service though.

Phoned ahead to order a pizza, not expecting much simply because Henniker is so small. Let’s just say we were delighted with the speed and quality of the pizza. This will undoubtedly become a habit we’ll have to be disciplined about. ;)

We've been coming here for over a year since we moved to Henniker. They have the best pizza and subs. Plus they deliver !!! It's our Friday night place 😊. And the owner is super nice so is the staff. Highly recommend.

This place has the most delicious pizza. I was only in town for a week but ate their pizza 4 times. I highly recommend this place. Very small area to eat inside. It's amazing food.