Fisherman's Cafe

My only disappointment is that I didn't go here sooner. Was looking for delicious conch salad on the island and gave Fisherman's Cafe a chance. The conch salad was perfect...so fresh and delicious. And the vibes are awesome. The old school island feel with thoughtfully prepared and fresh food. Make this a stop after your snorkel boat trip or in between drinks and Schooner.

Great customer service. Great food. Even tho their menu was very small and the store was very small. But the food was amazing. The fish we got was very fresh and the shrimp wrap was great too. Be sure to get their sauces too.

If you're seeking a satisfying street food experience, look no further than this hidden gem near the old port in key west. The lobster bites and fish tacos are absolute must-tries. The fry was flawless - crispy, golden, and not the slightest bit greasy. Very recommended!

This is the best little hole in the wall in Key West. We were only on island for 4 days and ended up eating here twice because it was so good. The menu is small and simple. All the food is spectacular. Our whole family are huge foodies and we were all thrilled with everything we got from here. They even have options for the non seafood eaters, a club and a burger, (much appreciated) and I can attest that both are delicious. You walk up to the window, place your order, and it is made fresh while you wait. There is extremely limited seating, so you may have to take it to go, but don't let that deter you. It is more than worth it to have go sit somewhere else and eat it.

What a great location to have this shack! The food and service was great, a lot better than the high priced restaurants around. The staff really take pride in their food and customers. We grabbed breakfast sandwiches prior to going out in the water and trust me, you get enough for your buck!

Stopped by for conch salad and it was awesome. Its very authentic, packed with flavor but not overdone. The gentleman working at the counter was so pleasant. Will absolutely be back

What can I say…this is a must when visiting Key West. We love tacos and tried many different establishments while we were there, and I can honestly say Fisherman’s Cafe is the best! Too bad they didn’t have lobster that day, so we ordered the pulled pork and fish tacos which were unbelievable. Pulled pork was seasoned well and not salty (which I find too often) and if getting the fish, get it blackened. The food took a bit of time, but it’s expected since it was made fresh. Plantains we’re made just how I like em - soft and sweet. Portions are sizeable so you definitely get your money’s worth. Can’t recommend this place enough…don’t second guess and just go!

We had lobster tacos, catch of the day tacos (yellow tail snapper), and an island bowl. They were all very good. The breakfast looks good too. I’d like to try the guava sesame toast and coffee next time. **Edit** I came back for breakfast and had the sesame guava toast and a cafe con leche. So good

This was such a great choice!! I had the shrimp tacos and my family tried the fish tacos, turkey sandwhich and shrimp wrap. They were all so so good! The value for the pricing is great and everything was truly delicious. The staff was also super nice 💛
Note: limited seating avilable and is outside seating bit has fans.

We heard the music and strolled in on a Sunday night. Had the best time here. Great drinks and service the band was awesome and it’s a super laid vibe. Definitely make this spot part of your night

This place is fantastic! Ordered the Caribbean turkey sandwich and fried plantains. The food was ready in less than ten minutes. The plantains were served piping hot, crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and perfectly sweetened. The turkey sandwich was perfect too. It had crisp lettuce and juicy, ripe tomatoes. The counter server came out to check that I was happy with my meal.

Second time I have eaten here and I love it! Food taste is great! Prices are good on some items but a little high on others. Portion size is decent as well. Would go back and eat there again.

We loved the blackened shrimp wraps and the blacked mahi tacos!! Fries were amazing. Small outside seating with view of lovely square, much better than sitting in a restaurant. Highly recommend.

So glad this place reopened! Always a favorite stop for lunch. My wife absolutely loves their fish tacos. Nice little place to grab some great food.

One of the best hidden gems on the island. Black bean burger is phenomenal, and their yuca fries are some of the crunchiest, most delicious things I have ever tasted. The woman in front (so sorry I don't know her name!) is always so pleasant and friendly. Don't fret at prices at first glance - the portions are HUGE. I have yet to finish something I've ordered, despite a large appetite. Lemonade is fresh and has no added sugar - I love it that way. Have yet to try the coffee but have heard very good things. Excited to come back next year.

So good. I had the blackened shrimp wrap and it was seriously delicious. We also had the sweet potato fries with cinnamon and vanilla and they were really good. They were very friendly and helpful and service was great. If we go back to Key West we will definitely go back here!

The coconut lobster tacos were the bomb!! After a few days in Key West, this was one of the best things we ate. And we ate lots of great food in Key West. Extremely flavorful!!

Great food good customer service. We shared fish grilled sandwich w maduros and lobster taco w sweet potatoe fries. Wld def go back

Ps surprised to see so many roosters I felt i was in DR 🇩🇴 i love it

We came here two days in a row. First for the breakfast sandwich, which was excellent, made on a Cuban roll, paired with cafe con leche and freshly squeezed orange juice. Then the following day we came for the blackened shrimp wrap, made with locally caught shrimp, with bacon and avocado. So tasty with a little heat. Generous amounts of sweet and delicious shrimp too. Don’t let the humble exterior fool you. Inside this little shack they’re executing culinary magic. Friendly quick service made for a extra enjoyable experience. 5 Stars.

The fish sandwich was great and the portion was big enough for 2 people to share and if your thinking about getting the mac and cheese then you definitely wouldn't be able to eat it by yourself that thing was huge.