Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

Absolutely delicious 😋!! My Hubby and I came in December 2023 all the way from Atlanta during a cruise and now I returned in May 2024 on another cruise with my Mom. The key lime pie is light and refreshing. I also enjoyed the key lime punch so authentic. What I appreciate the most is that it's not tart!! The most delicious choice in Key West...give them a try.

Some great key lime pie at this amazing bakery!! Couple of other places with similar names but this bakery is the real deal! Definitely check them out for the best key lime pie in Key West!!

Nice place to visit when you’re in Key West! Delicious Ice cream , also they sell delicious pie! 🥧 Service was great, atmosphere is nice!

Omg this pie is amazing! Sweet and tart. Paired with a latte... the gentleman working was so sweet and kind. The shop is cute and very Key West centric. I can't wait to come back!

This pie shop is a staple and tradition for my family. Despite us all living in different areas of the country, they offer exceptional customer service and delivery options to get their delicious pies almost anywhere. I recently ordered a pie for Father’s Day and unfortunately UPS ruined the chance of a timely delivery which ultimately led to the pie’s demise. Upon receiving tracking from UPS stating they were experiencing malfunctions, staff member Stephanie was quick to problem-solve for us. She was thorough, prompt, and was so kind. She offered routes to correct the issue despite it being no fault of theirs and made my parents so thrilled to receive their new pie. I cannot express how grateful I am for Stephanie and the Key Lime Pie Co. and how grateful they should be to have her on staff.

Delicious! 😋
The best key lime pie I've ever eaten!
Get the whipped cream. It's yummy!

Never knew we liked Key Lime pie until we tried it while here on vacation. We will be placing orders to be delivered from how good it was!

There are a lot of options in key west, but this place is the best. If you’re a key lime snob they make an extra tart one. They also were accommodating and wrote happy birthday on the pie for us.

This was the absolute best key lime pie I have ever eaten. My niece and her husband actually saw this company on The Profit and said the gentleman stated the same thing.
I guess you’ll have to visit Key West to get a taste of true key lime pie or order it online and have shipped.
I wish I had bought more!! I highly recommend visiting if in the area.

Enjoyed key lime pie after our key lime bike tour! Informed that it would be suitable for a peanut allergy and it was delicious !

Neat pie place. Easy walk from cruise terminal. Can watch pies being made and variety of pies tartness to select from. The frozen chocolate covered key lime pie is good as well.

Definitely the BEST Key Lime Pie in the Key West!!! We have tried Key Lime Pie from other locations during the same visit, but their Key Lime Pie and taffy definitely have that Key Lime punch, great consistency and taste as well. We the the mini version, soft serve. Great service, great ambiance. I would definitely love recommend and I know I will definitely crave it when I’m back home.

Saw this show on the show the Profit, so we had to give it a try. It lived up to the expectation! I had the chocolate dipped mango key lime pie- SO GOOD!!!! My husband classic key lime pie mini- DELICIOUS. The staff was super friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. Place was very clean. Give it a try!

It’s been on my bucket list to have key lime pie at the @keylimepieco in Key West ever since I saw if featured on The Profit. It inspired my whole family vacation to the keys. By far the best key lime pie I’ve ever had!

Hands-down, one of the best pie companies around you must try the strawberry Keylime pie and their ice cream bars for Keylime chocolate dipped bars absolutely fabulous.

I've had keylime pie 🥧 in almost every restaurant I've eaten this is by far the best I've ever had...went last night 🌙...15 min before closing...staff super friendly amd courteous...they asked if I was traveling far...I said yes! They gave me a bag with ice for my pie so it wouldn't melt...their little pies are to die for! I will be ordering online once this pie is all eaten up!

Great key lime pie …. Best Key Lime pie? Probably not but it’s good. Still looking for the best key lime pie. Homemade whipping cream amazing.

Searched out this place well in advance of leaving for Key West, Florida.. It was truly the best key lime pie I've ever had in my life. The extra tart pie was so packed with flavor. The staff super friendly. The restaurant was extremely clean. Highly recommend 🍰

This is hands down the best key lime pie in Key West. Not too tart and not too sweet. And they have the most delicious homemade whipped cream. We went every day we were in town and each day the staff was very friendly. I love this place.

Our first time ever trying a key lime pie. We LOVED this place. Splitting a mini pie between two was the perfect amount. Great vibe here too.