Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties

Randomly stopped to grab pizza while staying in Marquette and glad we did. Really great food and staff inside this small pizza shop were very friendly and seemed to love the job. Pizza sauce was great flavor and cheese they used on our pepperoni and cheese pizza was amazing. Had the pizza sticks as well and the garlic bread. Happy with all of it!! Keep up the great work.

5 stars isn't enough for how amazing their food is. The Double Steak and cheese on garlic bread with honey Dijon is to die for. I also recommend their Chicken and Bacon with ranch or honey dijon. I have yet to try their pizza, that's next on my list. They also have free delivery.

My girlfriend and I usually order Domino’s, but we wanted to try something new and had heard great things about Lake Superior Pizza, so we decided to try it out. We were not disappointed! Our pizza was right on time (we picked it up) and everything from the cheese to the toppings tasted nice and fresh. It was also very reasonably priced, as our order came out to around $21 for a large pizza and pizza sticks. I would highly recommend ordering from this awesome local business, and I think LSP has one of the best pizzas in Marquette. We will be ordering again in the future!

Small pizza shop. Ordered a deep dish pizza and 15 minutes later they called me to say that their deep dish machine was down so I got a traditional pizza. When I arrived to pick up the owner informed me that he had made my pizza a 16 inch because of the hassle with the deep dish being down. Once you got past the crust the pizza was endless toppings!

5/5
This TINY pizza place is a gem. There are a few chain restaurants around the area but you always have to find local places to try. This place did not disappoint. The pizza was outstanding and I must say the ranch was very good also! Definitely worth a try if you are in the area and looking for some good pizza

This small (and I mean SMALL) pizza place is amazing! The pizza was tasty and we enjoyed it very much - the garlic bread was pretty OK, nothing crazy - just plain garlic bread. Still good!

This place is a hidden gem, overflowing with gooey pizza cheese. 10/10 would eat again.
We ordered the pig out-and while I would've liked to order a smaller size I'm glad we didn't. My husband and I ate all but two slices... so good!
You could tell by the look of the cheese that this was high quality, and it stayed true bite after bite.
After dinner, my husband commented that we need to go there again (and we're only in town for 2 more days).
Only sad thing is they don't have a place inside to sit down and eat. Even some picnic tables outside would be ☆service☆.

Excellent pizza. We had the chicken Alfredo pizza and a cheese and sausage pizza and they were both great. Service was pleasant and delivery was quick.

I’m giving this a fine five star review it was rather exquisite and made my taste buds tingle. I ordered what the outstandingly pleasant staff suggested which was the chicken fajita. For this being a pizza place they should be known for their fajitas instead. I’ve never chowed down on such a work of art so fast. I will be ordering more from the enticing menu as the days come.
~fed

Great place. Skip the chains. Eat at Lake Superior Pizza!

This food literally melted in my mouth! THE CHEESE PULL ON THE PIZZA ROLLS is crazy!! You have to get the ranch with them too I heard all their dressings are house made and you can tell! The pizza dough also tasted so homemade it reminded me of my grandmas house. I highly recommend this place hands down the best pizza I’ve had other than my grandmas

Tiny places have the best food - this is a rule. This place is no exception. They've been serving up tasty foods since I was in high school, I've eaten their pizza rolls for over 20 years. The salads in bread bowls are local delicious legends. There are tons of ingredients, not just lettuce. 🤌👌

I had a pizza delivered to my mechanics shop, they loved it. 🙂

LSP! I don't know if that is what the kids are calling it these days, but I wanted a bit of nostalgia during my recent trip to the UP.

The food is still just as good as I remember, although I didn't venture too far into the menu. Simply got two 6" pizza rolls, one cheese only and one with added pepperoni.

The dough remains cooked to perfection, slightly soft on the inside - so you won't need reconstructive surgery after eating these. The ratio of crust to toppings is fair, so you don't feel like you're eating a log of bread.

The stated time to make our order (35 minutes) was right on the money, as when we pulled up they were packaging our order.

I do hope they beef up their website a bit. They have a photo of a printed menu on their site, but I think the time has come where a multi-page PDF print of the menu from whatever program they use to design their menu would be much better for potential customers.

Well done as always, LSP!

I started eating LSP in the 70's, and still do today.
'Nuff said. Get your pizza here.

I’ve been living in Marquette for over a year and this is the first time I’ve ordered food from here. Amazing staff answered my questions about the pizza rolls and man it was delicious. 10/10. Amazing small business 🩷

My wife and I have never been crazy about any pizza options in Marquette. We decided to try Lake Superior pizza and were beyond impressed! We ordered a pizza and a sub and both were made with fresh ingredients. We got it delivered and it was still hot when it got to our house. We will definitely be ordering again!

Always yummy. Free delivery and wonderful staff

Oh my goodness, I just had the 12 inch pizza roll with ham, pepperoni, and sausage. It was unbelievably good. Definitely worth the price. I have been going to LSP for over 40 years, but this was the first pizza roll I had and it definitely won't be the last...🤓🤓

I grew up coming here. You could get a pizza roll and soda for 2.50!

The food is decent now. You can tell it has changed owners. The staff was super friendly and kind. Free delivery if anyone wants it delivered!