Bagel Boys Cafe

If you're reading this, you have a ton of choices that are probably all wonderful. I used to take places like bagel boys for granted until I moved to Delaware. I knew I couldn't find bagels here, but I expected to get a decent bacon, egg and cheese sandwich, boy was I wrong. I was lucky enough to be in town for Christmas and got myself the bacon, egg and cheese I've been dreaming about. I can't wait to come back!.

My family and I regularly buy our bagels there.

Bagel are very good, especially compared with the local options. Bagel dough is excellent, flavor and size are very good.
Good deal on a dozen = You get 15 bagels for a price of 12.
Definitely recommended, even for a quick dine-in snack (place is nice for a bagel store).

Only issue to report was a recent 3.99% price hike for credit/ debit card users.
See attached letter with header "Good News"posted at the bagel store. I don't see a reason credit/ debit card users should be penalized for shopping there. So much for good news....

Great food 😋 👌 timely. Prices are alittle high and some mistakes on order taking. Outside that, this is a great place.

Helpful staff. Great product. A little pricey but all in all worth it. Big bagles good flavor.Thank you.

Great bagels and staff. Please make an egg everything bagel 🥹

Authentic New York style bagels. For the last 5+ years when I've visited Suffern/Airmont for an annual event I've always stopped in to grab a bagel. Bagels are my go to breakfast and I can't get anything like these back home in New England. I always go for the bagels but they also have a full breakfast menu of sandwiches and breakfast staples.

I stayed at the hotel down the road for a mini vacation, but their dining was closed so I had to make the trek over to Bagel Boys and I'm so glad I did. The bagels were fresh and delicious, and the coffee was incredible. The staff worked fast and took care of all customers during the busy morning with a high level of efficiency. I didn't get to try anything from the bakery or the deli which are in the same space, but the bakery treats in particular certainly looked incredible. If you're in the area, it's definitely worth a visit.

Large seating area, tea and coffee, and a large breakfast and lunch menu. Also has acai superfood bowls which are a great option for those who want a healthier alternative. Plenty of snacks available also.

The huevos rancheros are bomb! The toasted bagels with butter are really good too!

Great food, hand crafted! I had something like a #3 turkey and cheese wrap and it was delicious. This store can get very busy so be sure not to miss it!

Love this Bagel Boys. Much better than the others and always serve me quickly. They have a great eggplant wrap and cheese danishes. Their bagels are so much better than anything I can get upstate. We go there every time we come down to visit my in-laws. I highly recommend this gem.

Excellent bagels. toppings on both sides of the bagel.

Now this is a deli! Breakfast, lunch, snack/nosh, whatever you want. This might be one of the largest menus/selections you will come across at a deli. You can have ANYTHING you want made for you on the spot, or, check out one of the many pre-made sandwiches ready to be heated up and eaten. I frequent this place when I am in the area and have yet to have a bad experience. Its always clean, staff is on the ball, and they also have a very appetizing bakery section for cookies and cakes, and pastries. Decent prices. Great beverage options. You can't go wrong here.

✓ - Quality deli sandwiches/breakfasts with a variety of menu options
✓ - A clean establishment with an more than adequate area to sit and eat
✓ - Staff is friendly and attentive

🥇 Anon Eater X approved!

Great bagels for reasonable prices highly recommend

My favorite deli for bagels. The bagels are perfect! Big, nice outer "crunch", soft and chewy inside. Home of the 15 bagel "bakers dozen". Lots of fresh, whipped cream cheese. Excellent fresh squeezed orange juice.

They also have an amazing deli. Wonderful pre-boxed salads and pre-made sandwiches for those in a hurry.

The staff is prompt and the line moves quickly. Highly recommend.

Fresh food, friendly employees, efficient service

I am in love with this place!! Their everything bagels are the absolute best and the staff is so so friendly! I could not believe how big the place was and how many options there were. Even the guy restocking the juices was so nice to me and recommended I try a new tea. Great recommendation, the tea was awesome. Thanks everyone!! I’ll be popping in any time I’m in the area :)

It's not cheap, but it's worth every penny. Always fresh and of the highest quality. Never had a bad meal

Stopped by the spot this morning and I ordered breakfast for the wife and I. The everything bagels were phenomenal. (No bottoms just tops). My wife loved them. The homefries were well seasoned and amazing. Eggs and bacon were on spot.

The bagels are good for sandwiches. Breadier than an authentic bagel. No chewy snap. I got a half dozen. First i tried the poppy seed. Nice but not savory. Later, i had the cinnamon raisin. Same thought. The dough needs salt. The store made scallion cream cheese is really good. The place was pretty packed but was out of there in ten minutes. A SEC was also ordered and really good. Regular people working a busy bagel shop. Smiles are voluntary and i don't expect them. Especially if I'm not smiling like a jerk either. The attitude was fine for me. I came for take-out. Would have stayed but i had a CSI Marathon to participate in