Collectors' Choice Antiques

I don't know why people have to come onto somebody's business page and complain about prices. Don't make someone's business look bad because the big bad prices offend you. It's not the owners that set the prices! The antique market is different in all areas and states. The New Oxford area has been known for great antiques and the market is strong. I personally love going there as a buyer and a dealer. More times than not if you just ask for a better price your going to get it. Andrea and her employees are always happy to help. Great place to shop and highly recommend a visit if you're in the area.

Have visited this wonderful and unique antique store for over 25 years! Always friendly, helpful, and extremely knowledgeable staff—simply the BEST. It’s a fun experience to look at so many antiques in one place that range from Americana primitives to elegant decorative objectives. This mall represents excellent selection and diverse range of pricing for Pennsylvania antiques that are always authentic! Wishing Collector’s Choice many more years of continued success!

An extremely valuable collection of vendors and their wares. This shop is curated wonderfully and has a diverse offering of products. The proprietors are kind and friendly. Some very rare pieces. Most are priced within expected market ranges. Lots to choose from. Everything is in great shape. Check out my photos on Google Maps. Make sure to stop in when in town. You will not be disappointed.

This was the first time since I moved West from New England That I felt that I was in a real antique store. You know, stuff that is at least 100 years old, the legal definition of an antique. Of course not everything was that old but I did not see any of the junk that characterizes most CA antique stores. This got me pining for the 1853 house I had in NH. I did not bring anything home but only for lack of space. In particular there was a beautiful tall hand made dresser (check the dovetails to see if it is hand made) for $2,200 that I would have bought in a jiffy if I had a place to put it.

A great selection of antiques, lots of large pieces too, not just smalls, including lots of 18th and 19th century furniture, which I collect, and a lot of dealers don't have anymore. I would reccomend!

Real antiques at fair prices. Lots of happy help. Easy parking.

Had a nice time searching their showcases. Nice place - friendly staff! Too bad I couldn't find anything - but it's not their fault. I'm just too fussy on price.

Well worth the stop when hunting antiques near Gettysburg.

Nice place. Beautiful antiques

Great inventory and very nice staff.

Best antique gallery in Pennsylvania

Loved it

A variety of items. Lots of furniture and home decor.

Not impressed, high end antiques. If your looking for a bargain don't stop here