Toll Station Pizza and Grill

Over the past four years we have tried every pizza place in McCall, none of them quite right. This year we finally tried Toll Station Pizza, we should have tried it years ago! We’ve eaten there 3 times this trip. The atmosphere is basic, but very clean and fresh. Not overly cluttered with “atmosphere”. The staff has all been so friendly and kind.
We’ve tried every specialty pizza on the menu, some classic and some more unique. But all made well. The Wisconsin cheese curds are incredible and the classic burger is also great! Toll Station Pizza is by far a new favorite place to dine!

Absolutely delicious food here. The chicken wings, the loaded fries, the Fettuccine Alfredo, were all Delicious. With a large group, we had I incredible service. My new favorite place in McCall.

A favorite for pizza in McCall.

It is especially enjoyable to eat out on the patio in the summer.

Chicken popper pizza is the BEST! Original and gf cauliflower crusts are great!

The chicken Alfredo is great too!

Staff is friendly, helpful and hardworking.

We'll keep coming back!

Great food and atmosphere! The best part however, is Shari. She is always such a pleasure! Thanks for making our visit each time we come to mccall!

I can not yes 1 bad thing about this restaurant. I have eaten here when there is a long wait, short staffed or just us on a Saturday night. The staff is friendly and accommodating and the food is delicious ~

Wonderful little spot in the heart of downtown McCall: very kind and attentive staff, excellent, generous helpings of food, and a very clean and cozy atmosphere. There are both outdoor and indoor options for sitting - I highly recommend coming in the evening, the sunset is exceptional. This is an exquisite experience at a very reasonable price.

Update 2024: Went again and this time had hungarian mushroom soup and gluten free tortellini. One of the best soups I have ever had and the tortellini was excellent as well. Kids loved their full sized burgers. Only complaint was some loud music being played, sounded like there was a bar attached to it. Wife had the finger steaks and enjoyed them. Not very expensive either and service is excellent.

Gluten free and cauliflower crust and they do not skimp on the toppings. Good service, came quick too.

Excellent food! Service is always great and friendly! Finger steaks taste delicious! Salads are large and filling.

It was a great day here. I had lunch with a friend. The food and service was great.

The service was great and very friendly. Had the prime rib sandwich, fettuccine alfredo, margarita pizza, pepperoni pizza, and the kids cheese pizza all were great.

I'm updating my review from a 3 star to a solid 5 star across the board. I live locally and haven't been to toll station in 4 plus years. Last time sadly was pretty bad to the point we didn't want to go back. But tonight we decided to try it out. We had a large party and wanted some where that'd fit all of us. The pizza was amazing! The hiker was a hit and the chicken ceasar was also great. The staff was wonderful and attentive and the little game room is always a hit with the kids. Only bummer is they no longer have the salad bar. But the pizza definitely made up for it.

Had a quick bite to eat at Toll Station Pizza and Grill on Monday for lunch. Greeted and seated promptly. Served some of the best onion soups I have ever tasted! The lasagna was superb as well.

We've enjoyed Toll Station as a favorite since our honeymoon in 2003! This time, we brought our young kids who just loved it!

The bean bag toss to the claw machines, my kids were happy!

We didn't get pizza and instead tried other items. My wife loved her lasagna and I really enjoyed my hamburger (which I'm pretty sure was grass-fed:) and on a gf bun (don't care about gluten, but I do care about insoluble fiber;) Practically healthy!

Toll Station remains a definite must for us every time we're in McCall!

The pizza here is really delicious. What was best for us was the ability to sit on the patio with our dog. We tried the local beers on the menu but they also have wine and study drinks too. We ordered a medium chicken alfredo pizza and thought we'd have left overs but it was so good we ate the whole thing! The crust is thin and I highly recommend this place when you're in McCall, Idaho. (They also have salads and burgers too). 🍕

The best food I've had in a long time, for an incredible price. I highly recommend this little gem to everyone.

Great views great service and equally as good food! I had the bacon cheddar cheeseburger which was really good.

Burgers and beer battered fries are Amazing!!
Service was fast, friendly, and attentive.
Nice, clean establishment.
Patio is an excellent place to enjoy the nice weather and a pitcher of Lemon Ginger Heffiweizen! Yum!🤗🍻
Going back to try the pizza for sure!
Decent prices too!
No pics, too hungry and thirsty!

Fast, friendly service. Lovely dog-friendly patio. Pizza was really good; crust crispy and chewy, not too thick or thin, generous toppings and flavorful sauce.

This is an institution, amazing pizza, great craft beer selection great service and a casual atmosphere. One of few McCall staples open all week, especially in the summer. The beautiful patio can be warm but the vibe is laid back so it's worth it.

We came in just after 8, understanding they were open until 9. Not real busy, sat on the patio with our 2 kids. Pizza was delicious, patio was nice and shaded - just felt like the server really didn't want us there.