Reel Deal Seafood

We stopped in here 3 times while on vacation. Super friendly and helpful staff, and my wife is very funny about seafood markets being clean, odors, etc. We travel a lot and hit coastal areas along the east coast frequently. She loved how clean it was and didn’t smell, other than the fresh seafood smell… and it was definitely fresh with a lot of locally sourced fish.

Prices were very reasonable for the quality of product offered. Get in here, try this place, and support small businesses that deliver great service and value. .

I have been staying near by for the past few months and found this place right away . The owner explained how to prepare all the seafood I got. and all were excellent . Pictures tell the story !

Surprisingly, stopping in to pick up shrimp for a low country boil was the highlight of our morning. The smell of the smoker filled the parking lot! The service was outstanding and the place is immaculate! I can't wait to try the shrimp (local and brought in this morning)! We will definitely be back on our next trip!!! Thank you!!! 🦐🦐🦐

An excellent source of locally caught fish. We purchased yellowtail snapper, and another fish that we had never eaten before. It was a great recommendation! You are not going to find these fish at a local fish camp. Enjoy Florida fish!

Great selection of local fresh fish. Helpful staff, that gave us an extra oyster when we purchased six (Basically a "bakers dozen") that were amazing. Really fresh piece of mahi-mahi that we grilled with a mango/avocado salsa that was delicious. Will go back (in fact we are going back tomorrow).

Did go back the next day (early April) and the snapper was great. Went back again today - August 30, 2024 (we are only in St. Augustine a few weeks a year) and just as good. Will be back this weekend and any time we need seafood while we are in St. Augustine.

Very helpful staff and Super Fresh, quality seafood. Also expertly cleaned and filleted!

Lovely variety of choice of fresh fish lobster and other seafood also shrimp dip and salmon dip available too

Have shopped several times. Seafood selection is always good. Service is excellent. The smoked salmon is awesome.

This is a little gem of FRESH caught select seafood. Nothing farm raised. The salmon is great at $18 a lb. Way better than the Island market at $28 a lb. Their Key west pinks shrimps are wonderful. Owner is in the process of creating a small kitchen for take out along with a wine and beer patio....Bravo to the small business owner Mitch!

Awesome place. Seafood was fresh and they have local fisherman that bring whatever they catch.

Absolutely the best place to get the freshest seafood around! Mitchell and company know their fish!

Went into Reel Deal for the first time yesterday. Everything looked clean, organized and very fresh. The owner assisted us with our selections and recommended cooking methods. We ended up sucessfully grilling a delicious shrimp and fish dinner. Will definitely shop there again!

Nice variety of fresh seafood, very helpful owner who explained how to prepare everything. Crab dip, smoked salmon, and crab cakes were delicious! Nice to get fresh fish vs grocery store or restaurant fish.

The seafood was fresh and delicious. Staff very knowledgeable and helpful. Would highly recommend.

Amazing, top quality, mostly locally caught yumminess! Although the salmon isn't locally, its undoubtedly some of the best in house smoked salmon ever. We aren't locals, but, if we were, this would be a regular stop.

For starters, the food and selection is awesome! In addition, the staff was very knowledgeable and helpful in explaining different ways to prepare the differand varieties of seafood. Definitely recommend to anybody looking for a good seafood meal!

Love this place. Fresh local shrimp. Smoked Salmon is delicious .

We bought fresh caught grouper and went home to fry it up! It was delicious!! So nice to have a fish market closer to us! We will be back!

Great selection of fresh local seafood and wonderful staff.

The fresh flounder was unbelievable. I used it to make flounder with stuffed crab meat, and I don’t know which was sweeter the flounder or the crab meat. It was wonderful.