Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining

We ate here a few times during our stay at The Reach. Service was prompt, friendly and professional.

This is the home of one of the best Key Lime Pies in Key West. A big task, but after sampling a dozen different entrees into the category, this was one of the few that really stood out.

Perfect crust. High tower whipped cream covering creamy filling. The filling wasn’t as tart as I would like it, however the inclusion of cream cheese made it SO creamy and delicious, I actually ordered it twice and compared others to it.

Other dishes we had of note:
Hummingbird cake. Amazing, rich, very surprising.
French Toast
Eggs Benedict
Korean Beef Short Ribs

Shout out to Constantine- he always took good care of us and ensured everything was always perfect.

The food was incredible. My kiddo enjoyed the kids burger and fries. We got the sourdough with tomato butter as well as the whipped ricotta and tomato stack. Both were good, though the tomato stack could have used some salt and something a little crunchy for texture. For our mains, we got the mahi mahi and the NY Strip. Both were cooked to perfection. Only alterations we would make would be to make the potatoes on the steak more crispy and the season the squash on the fish plate. We ended the night with the key lime pie, and it was the best we have had in the Keyes.

We also got 2 mock-tails, a no-jito as well as a 42 something! I didn’t love the 42, but hubby was a fan. The no-jito was well made, but not exciting.

Four Marlins is nothing short of amazing! My group ordered fish & chips and the Conch & Crab fritters. They were absolutely delicious! We also got the key lime pie for dessert and it was to die for! Not to mention to our server, Ashley, was extremely helpful in recommending food options and was just an amazing server. She added to our dining experience completely! Everyone needs to try the Four Marlins!

They have the best key lime pie in Key West. We tried 5 highly rated pie spots in town, and Four Marlins was by far the best. The slices are substantial enough to be an entree, and justify the higher price you get here. We went back before we left town, and got extra slices for the road. We highly recommend this hidden spot.

Four Marlins is located inside "The Reach" hotel by Hilton on the Atlantic side of Key West close to the southernmost point that you can travel in the United States. You can experience indoor or outdoor dining, either choice is very pleasant with views of the ocean and or a beach. Our lunch order was the Four Marlins Burger and crab cakes, each came with their side salad, then Key lime pie which is a must since Key West is where the Key lime pie originated. Everything was prepared exactly to our liking. You can freely roam the grounds and explore the area.

First night of my 50th bday celebration. Everything was incredible. Kids enjoyed their burgers and my wife and I loved the grouper and mahi mahi. Lobster ceviche was fresh and flavorful. Service and atmosphere were 100% perfect. We will be back this week. Cannot recommend more strongly. Very accommodating of my wife’s Celiac condition. Thank you Danny and Zach. Memorable experience.

If you haven't been you must go! The food was excellent!! I suggested trying the key lime pie for dessert. The service was excellent. Our waiter was very helpful and attentive. I would recommend sitting outside. The! view is amazing

I wanted to share my recent dining experiences at Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining in Key West. It was a tale of two extremes, and I can't wait to tell you all about it.

Let's start with the positive. On my girlfriend's birthday, we decided to celebrate at Four Marlins, and it turned out to be an absolutely amazing evening. From the moment we arrived, everything was perfect - the staff, the service, the food, and the view of the sunset.

Ashley, the hostess, greeted us with a warm smile and ensured that we had a table with a breathtaking ocean view. It set the tone for a memorable night. Our server, Paul, went above and beyond to make our evening special. He was knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive throughout the entire meal.

Now, onto the food. I ordered the citrus grouper, and it was a taste sensation. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and each bite was a delight. My girlfriend opted for the lobster pasta, which she absolutely loved. The lobster was tender and flavorful, and the pasta was cooked to perfection.

As the evening progressed, we were treated to an incredible sunset. The view from Four Marlins was simply breathtaking, adding an extra touch of magic to our experience. And of course, we couldn't leave without trying their famous key lime pie, which lived up to its reputation as the best in Key West.

We were so impressed by our dinner experience that we couldn't resist going back the next morning for brunch. And let me tell you, Four Marlins doesn't disappoint when it comes to brunch either. The menu offered a wide variety of delicious options, from savory to sweet.

During brunch, we were once again greeted with the same warm hospitality. The staff remembered us from the previous night, making us feel like valued guests. The food was equally exceptional. I tried their signature eggs benedict, which was divine, and my girlfriend enjoyed fluffy Belgian waffles with fresh berries and whipped cream.

The brunch cocktails, including mimosas and Bloody Marys, were the perfect complement to our meal. The service remained impeccable, and Four Marlins continued to deliver an outstanding dining experience.

Overall, Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining was a tale of two experiences. Our dinner celebration was absolutely amazing, with impeccable staff, service, food, and a stunning sunset. And the following morning, their brunch impressed us just as much, with a delectable menu and the same level of hospitality.

I highly recommend visiting Four Marlins for both dinner and brunch. It's an experience you won't forget, and I'm sure you'll enjoy it as much as we did.

A great breakfast at Four Marlins. Excellent service by Tim. Latte was really good. Loved the Avacado toast and we also had the regular bacon and eggs which was great as well. Nice view and good start to the day.

We are local to Key West, but had our first dining experience at Four Marlins last night - my husband and I celebrated our anniversary there, which was very special because we were married at the Casa Marina (sister property). The entire experience and meal was amazing! Our server, Daniel, was very professional, took time to explain the menu and specials and gave great recommendations . He also let us take our time, we never get rushed. We will definitely dine here again - it was lovey for a special occasion and the ambience was perfect!

I came here for my honeymoon, and did the tide to table. I also ate here for breakfast and dinner as I was a guest in the reach hotel.
Our first night, we flew in late because of airline issues and they were minutes from closing. The staff stayed open, and let us eat without rushing us.
Every waiter we dealt with throughout the weekend was great. And tide to table was an EXPERIENCE.

Such a great experience. Our server, Ashley, was amazing! The Key Lime Pie was unreal. Would definitely recommend Four Marlins.

After checking in to the Reach Curio Collection we decided to stay there for dinner. The Four Marlins was a superb experience. I recommend booking in advance so you can get a table outside overlooking the beach. It was a bit pricey however the food was perfectly executed and service by Fabiola was awesome. We shared the conch and crab fritters for appetizer and they were delicious. For dinner we had the NY strip which was extremely flavorful, the red snapper entree special that was delicious and the grouper entree that was amazing. We followed it all by the key lime pie and a fantastic croissant bread pudding with raisins, caramel and vanilla gelato. All was awesome and would def go back

Hostess is kind rude tho🤦Excellent food and friendly staff.... Definitely not your typical hotel restaurant. Breakfast is plentiful and delicious.... Dinner is also great upper scale quality. Typical prices for the key West area... As a diamond member, you get a $18 allotment per guest 💸💸

Breakfast was great! Nestled inside a hotel, Our server Tim was one the best! This eatery had a small but truly excellent food. Bloody-Marys and cappuccino martinis were awesome.

Danny was out waiter he was very observant to the needs of the table while also not being overbearing loved his energy also had a good atmosphere. The food has great flavor and so was the presentation.

We ate there Friday night and the food was absolutely Fantastic. The. Waiter and the atmosphere was as good maybe excellent. Also the best key line pie in Key West. Would definitely? Go? Back there next time down.

Eating out on the covered deck at the Four Marlins is a 5-star experience. The view looking out over the Atlantic, the service, innovative and flavorful food, freshness of the local fish, etc. have made this my favorite restaurant by far in Key West.

Best fish and chips I’ve ever had! Also the key lime pie was to die for! Amazing views and decent service. Cocktails were pretty overpriced ($18 for about 4 ounces of drink) and not that good. Would definitely come back for dinner and dessert but would skip the cocktails here

Food and drinks were incredible. This place is a little on the pricey side but worth it. I enjoyed the calamari, fresh fish tacos, and key lime pie.