The Pizza Shop

A nice local Pizza shop. Pizza was very good, especially after hiking 4 hours in the area. Had the buffalo chicken, it was great. My brother had the fetta and spinach, he enjoyed his as well. Will be coming here again, the next time we are out hiking.

We usually do pick up but eating there is cute too! Love the artwork on the walls and it's fun to be able.to see them make your pie! Great selection and different flavor choices 👌

Always, always a great pie. Best in the region! Just had dessert. Unbelievable! Save room. No better pizza anywhere. Period. Get there! Everyone loved it.

My husband and I love stopping here for New York style pizza by the slice when we’re visiting family. I always enjoy the BBQ chicken pizza. The crust has a nice crunch and the flavors are great!

Very good pizza. New york thin crust. Bone in chicken wings were crispy and flavorful. And we actually received the extra blue cheese we requested. We order 3 pizzas and a Ceasar salad, meatball platter, 2 kinds of bone in wings. Only thing for us. Chicken Ceasar salad was a little dry with the Ceasar dressing. Perfect foldable slices!

Love this place ❤. We go as much as we can, because it's not close to our house. Pizza is like the pizza we had in Long Island. The crust is crispy and delicious. I prefer the white pizza 🍕 😋. Go there if you're looking for great pizza !!!

Was in the area on only way to my vacation home and me and my stopped here. It was the best mini pit stop ever cause their pizza and Tiramisu is soooooo GOOD. Highly recommend. We wanted to stop again cause we loved it so much but we're going to wait till next time. Maybe they will have cheesesteaks our next visit.

Best pizza this side of Albany being from downstate it was painfully clear that pizza up north is a lot different than what I was used to. That was until I found this gem. Love love love it!!!!

This pizza was delicious! The garlic knots were amazing (like buy a few orders). My chicken wings were a bit of a disappointment for me but I like them super crispy and they were a little soggy for my taste. The prices are great for the generous slices you get. I see why it is voted best in the region.

I always order pizza and I like its distinctive Italian taste, in addition to the delivery staff being very nice.

Omg!! Had to redo my review!! The local favorite with the pickles omg amazing!!! Its my new favorite pizza EVER!! Since my last review i got wings again asked for extra sauce an the wings were perfect!! The garlic knots are to die for!!!

the best pizza i have ever had. Giovanni is a master of his craft. nyc pizza can learn from this guy! amazing food and an amazing price... a true hidden jem!

Perfect pizza place for family on a budget. It's absolutely delicious! Cheesy bread was awesome too! Drinks are a buck. Can't beat it! They are all so polite and helpful! Why spend tons of money for pizza when this place is truly Italian pizza! THANK YOU " The pizza shop" we will see you again next year when we return to Lake George!😀

We asked a few locals where the best pizza in the area was and they said "it's not just the best pizza in the area, it's the best pizza in the world." So, we brought the whole family here to give it a try. The locals did not steer us wrong.

While I'm not ready to say it's the best pizza in the world I can definitely say it was great pizza. Our family has done Friday night pizza every Friday for the past 9 years and we've been traveling full time for the past year so we've had plenty of pizza and I will say this ranks highly.

We bought 3 pizzas - cheese, pepperoni, and a supreme. They were great and all the kids ate more than usual so I know they loved it. The Pizza Shop was also surprisingly affordable!

We will definitely be visiting this place again when we are in town.

Fiancée and I were visiting Warrensburg from Rochester for a wedding. Decided to have Pizza Shop for dinner one night. Lady on the phone was nice, courteous and helpful. We had a small pizza and garlic knots delivered to our hotel. Delivery was fast and driver was friendly. Food was amazing! Pizza crust was thin and very crispy. Sauce was delicious and toppings were plentiful. Garlic knots were tasty and well-seasoned. If we ever find ourselves out in Warrensburg again, we definitely will be stopping by.

Pizza was excellent, fresh and perfect for a cold winter day. The homemade red sauce that goes with the mini garlic knots is a must. Staff was extremely nice too.

I had a nice turkey club wrap, the ingredients tasted fresh and the wrap was full of flavor.

We have found our new pizza place!! The pizza is QUALITY & the service was super fast and friendly. Prices are just right too! We walked in tonight and ordered a large pie to go- they had it ready in no time. The atmosphere is clean and the artwork is impressive. Can’t wait to try other menu items.

We stopped here on the way home from six flags. We were hungry for some good, quick pizza (with three exhausted kids) and that’s just what we found. The staff were nice and friendly and the pizza came out much quicker than expected and it was delicious! Also reasonably priced. We will definitely eat here again.

Love this place! Delicious pizza! 😋