Little Italy

I had my baby sprinkle here. All the ladies loved it! Everyone was talking about how amazing the Alfredo pasta was and I couldn't agree more it is probably on of the best pastas I've ever had. Booking the place was so easy. Prices are so reasonable, the staff was friendly, the atmosphere was amazing there is nothing I would change about our special day it was everything we wanted plus more cannot wait to host more events here.

This is my favorite restaurant since relocating to Indiana. You feel like you’re in another country. The noise from music playing, people talking, smell of everyone’s selections (ie- chicken Marsala was the special) and the atmosphere make for a fun & enticing experience.

Jonathan is an AMAZING staff member. He is honest, quick, and anticipates your needs before you even knew you had them.
I’m leaving this review because the staff here hands down puts their heart and soul into the service they provide. Even the hostess helps to clear tables and check in on you during the busiest times!

Thank you for being an exceptional option for me and the community to dine in!

Great food at a great price! I will be going back again! All handmade pasta! I recommend the Risotto Rice Balls, Bruschetta, Brussel Sprouts with Cauliflower, and the Shrimp, appetizer! Everything we had was amazing!

Being Italian and going to eat at an Italian restaurant is a risky proposition for me. I always find myself comparing to moms home cooked food! So when I was asked to go here, I was apprehensive and a bit reserved. Well, I can tell you without a doubt this place is out of this world good! The atmosphere and food were absolutely spectacular. The only thing that could be improved for me was the sauce, but that is a personal preference from years of my own sauce. However, everything thing else was just superb! They have two sizes for most of the meals, the little or the big Italy. Thank god I ordered the little.... the portions were so large that I could not finish the small ones! Finally, our server Emily was the absolute best food was delivered hot and my drink never went dry! This place was just a pleasure to eat at and well deserved 5 stars!

My wife and I were there tonight.best italian food in indiana.the food is made fresh every day . The food is fantastic this my wife's and my go to places.the atmosphere is great with nice music playing in back ground.so relaxing to have dinner here. The service is the best here.thank you Emily H. For a wonderful night,we will be back soon.

Gorgeous atmosphere!! We sat near the front door but did not feel exposed or disrupted there. Ordered our "test" foods--calamari, chicken parmesan, and tiramisu. All was good, my meal (vodka pasta w peas) was good--not as amazing the next day as it should be but this is certainly a great spot to cozy up in.

My company "Balloon Lady Krisi & Co." set up a balloon display for a baby shower in the Rose Room. It is a beautiful space and the food smells divine. I will have to visit for dinner myself sometime soon.

This place is a gem! We've tried other Italian restaurants in NWI but none of them just compares to Little Italy. We always get the little Italy salad and their corn for appetizer (not pictured since we devoured it right away!) and most recently tried their lemon chicken. It was tender and juicy and so flavorful! Sat at the bar this time since we didn't want to wait for a table. 2 lovely ladies were at the bar and were so attentive to our needs while making drinks for everyone as well. Such great customer service. ❤

Went for the first time Saturday and I was very impressed.

The Good: Service was great. I was concerned the Little Italy portions (you can choose Little Italy or Big Italy) would be too small but that was certainly not the case. Very nice size portion. Had the pork shoulder and it was delicious. Many of the dinner options fall in the $15 - $20 range which is great value for money. The cocktails were good, reasonably priced, and it was nice not to get drinks that were 3/4 ice. To top it off we were brought complementary salad and ziti. This was a nice surprise and a nice break from places that wont even bring you a glass of water unless you ask. I hope they do not change any of this because this is what will definitely bring us back: value. Highly recommended.
The Bad: Nothing

I'm not going to give a bad review for draft beer being not as cold as should be. My pork shoulder was great, but not the same portion I usually get. Food is always excellent and usually the service.

We were there last night with another couple, the food was amazing, but our server Doug was probably the best server I’ve ever had anywhere. We couldn’t have had a better experience, Doug made that happen. Thank you!!

My sister had her wedding shower and my aunt's 75th birthday party was held here recently. Both experiences were phenomenal! Food is excellent and the service is even better. All servers were attentive and so very sweet. If I could give this place 10 stars , I would.

The level of service, food and environment are all amazing! The portions are very generous as we always leave full and with leftovers for later. The owners are the sweetest couple. This is our absolute favorite restaurant in the Region! We always recommend Little Italy to friends looking for a restaurant to try.

Great cocktails and amazing food! Everything i tried was delicious. I will be making this a regular date night spot so I can try everything from here. The grilled brussel sprouts and cauliflower in lemon were so good I am still thinking about them the next day. Meatballs with fresh bread, so good! The drink I had, lavender lemonade, was also a must have! Great little find👍🏽👍🏽

My waiter was amazing! Very attentive to our needs and he was very polite. The food was delicious however I do recommend bringing the garlic bread back it was the only thing missing to go with the spaghetti and Alfredo! The plain baked bread was a no no for us! Other than that 5 Stars for sure. Ps the house sangria is one of the best I’ve ever had!

We had a wonderful meal for my husband's birthday. Emily made it very special. Thank you all.

Our server, Emily, may be young but she was also an incredible sweetheart through the whole thing. We had a great conversation and she made some great food suggestions. Convinced us to take home some tiramisu. We had a lovely time and plan to go there again. Probably many times.

Went to celebrate a bday and everything was great from the bread to the salads then our meals there is so much food almost should have shared but so worth it !

This is the best Italian food I’ve ever had. The bruschetta was really good. The lasagna was excellent!!! Sauce is phenomenal. The chicken fettuccine was great also . For drinks we had the appletinis and they were so good. Our server Jonathon was very knowledgeable about the food and gave us great service. We will definitely be back

My husband and I visited for the first. The prices are great for the amount of food on you plate. Food was made to order and very good.
Exceptional service!! Thanks Ben!
We will return