Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

So much history in this restaurant. It's beautiful and laid back. Very clean, great, friendly employees. They made us feel at home. Very cool renovations.

Exactly what my wife and me were looking to enjoy! We had classic--when in Key West--cocktails. Pina Colada frozen and Key Lime Tini...Duffy's is known for Steak and Lobster, and that is exactly what the evening called for! My wife enjoyed the Seafood Medley! Would definitely be back and recommend to others. The service was excellent too!

Amazing food and drinks! Service was great too. It was large portions, my sister and I shared a meal and both of us were full! Definitely recommend this place!!

We really enjoyed the chicken and crab cakes. Salads were prepared nicely with more than just lettuce and a cucumber like most places. Nice warm loaf of bread was served with the meal as well.

Omg omg omg don't sleep on this spot, seafood was SO fresh, staff very friendly and helpful, mixed drinks were fantastic. We were too excited for the desserts to remember a picture but the chocolate thunder cake and the key lime pie (of course) were amazing
Totally recommend

Great surf and turf dinner! Attentive server, comfortable atmosphere. Good price for a great meal too!

The staff here makes it a dining experience. So friendly with top notch food. I will definitely return.

We had a great time with great food at Duffy’s. I order the Surf and Turf Filet Mignon and Lobster and my wife had the catch of the day which was sword fish which was awesome! We also had the Conch Fritters and Alligator Bites which my son truly enjoyed! We will definitely come back!

Our waitress was very attentive, food and drinks were fantastic!! Definitely, you must have the chocotini!! Lobster and steak was very good!!

Great steak and fish restaurant with pleasant vibes and attentive staff. Ordered mixed fish platter and beef tenderloin. Meal sizes were right, not too much. So there is space left for their delicious key lime pie too :)

I stopped in for late lunch and tried the Buffalo wings, strawberry lemonade, and cheesecake for dessert. The wings were great, just the way I like them. The waitress was friendly and service was good.

We’ve been visiting Key West on and off for 13 years. Often, we’d pass by Duffy’s but never ate there. Big mistake. We finally stopped in, tried it, and have gone there at least four times ( we tend to do a very late lunch). It is old school quality. Perfectly, and I mean perfectly prepared food with friendly, efficient service in an inviting atmosphere. Our server, Brenda, is a lovely welcoming presence who added to our meal, making the experience both satisfying (in a food sense) and memory making. If you love to relax over a plate of good food without the hyperactive activity of a tourist town, Duffy’s is a breath of fresh air. (& in a town where it seems everywhere touts the “ best key lime pie”….theirs is REALLY good)

Very very good!!!! Our waitress Naomi was fantastic and the food was delicious. I highly recommend it for a nice meal and an easy dinning experience . Very full right now

The first impression was the beautiful building, then we walked inside to find an inviting warm atmosphere with a view of the large windows and awesome decor. We ordered the seafood and they didn’t disappoint! The drinks were awesome as well! This was our favorite stop!

I just want to say I LOVE their key lime pie!!! Like all other tourists I tried key lime pie EVERY place I went to while visiting Key West and out of all the places I went to, Duffy's had THE BEST key lime pie. We enjoyed it so much we went there a second time just to get two pieces to go.

Pleasant waitress, relaxed environment. I had the local fish 'maison' (house) and it came with a very good baguette and salad. Generous portion and was very good.

Had an amazing time here. Customer service was great. Everything I tried on the menu was seasoned well. The bread was soft and warm. The stuffed mushrooms were tasty. The shrimp cocktail were cooked perfectly. The filet mignon was delicious. The yellow tail snapper was fantastic. The yellow rice was seasoned nicely. The baked potato was small to say the least but it was okay. The New England Clam chowder was perfect, fresh clams and seasoned very well. AND THEN THERE WAS THE CHEESECAKE! OMG! Show stopper! Case closed. The end!

Great local place. Server was friendly. Salad was very fresh and the house dressing was very good. The hollandaise sauce on the stuffed shrimp was delicious. Definitely recommend

We were looking for a surf and turf in old town, and we weren’t disappointed. We had prime rib, strip and they were both cooked to perfection. The wait staff were incredibly nice, too.

The bisque soup is also incredible. Definitely give this a try !

Ate here twice on my last visit to Key West. Best seafood and mouth watering steak. If you are looking for good seafood congratulations your journey is over. Ask for Donna. Service is impeccable.