HMC

The Montauk Beach House

Hotel in Gardiners Island

Updated: July 21, 2024 11:56 AM

The Montauk Beach House is located in Gardiners Island (Island in Suffolk County, New York), United States. It's address is 55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954.

55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954

23M4+JR Montauk, New York

(631) 668-2112

thembh.com

Questions & Answers


Where is The Montauk Beach House?

The Montauk Beach House is located at: 55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954.

What is the phone number of The Montauk Beach House?

You can try to calling this number: (631) 668-2112

What are the coordinates of The Montauk Beach House?

Coordinates: 41.0340634, -71.9429775

The Montauk Beach House Reviews

Ashley Renee
2024-06-28 14:16:54 GMT

We had an amazing stay at the montauk beach house. Both my kids 7 & 3 had a great time, pool was warm and very family friendly. We love how private this resort is. Food is incredible, we had the lamb burger everyday we were there. Highly recommend and will be back 🤍

James Johnston
2024-06-25 21:18:11 GMT

Great stay at The Montauk Beach House. The pool area and service was amazing! A++ Speical shoutout to Emma who always made sure we had full pitchers of water with ice and very attentive if wanted anything to drink or eat. Always checking in just enough to make sure we were good.

Highly suggest the lunch by the pool. We ordered burgers by the pool which were delicious and even better not having to leave the pool area as we maximized our time in the beautiful weather.

Also the location of the hotel is amazing walking distance to everything in town for breakfast, dinner and very short walk to the beach!!

Andra Dinielli
2024-06-03 12:54:58 GMT

Awesome spot in Montauk! Great location, right in town and walking distance from everything. Rooms are updated and clean. The pool area and bar are huge and really nice to hangout out. And the staff are wonderful. Highly recommend! We will be back.

Kathleen Nagurka
2024-06-30 20:54:03 GMT

Everything is amazing at The Montauk Beach House. Rooms are clean and spacious, pool area is so luxurious and everyone from checking in, service at the pool and room was above and beyond. Loved it here and I can not wait until next year! Oh, and walking distance to beach and town. Perfection!!

Jasmin Vazquez
2024-05-29 18:56:02 GMT

Bathroom showers are quite tiny otherwise everything about my stay was wonderful. Clean rooms, attentive and courteous staff, great bar/pool and food. Even though I didn’t get to use the pool bc of weather it looked clean and modern.

Liana H
2024-05-25 18:32:42 GMT

It was our first time staying at Montauk Beach Hotel. The whole stay was amazing, check in and check out process was very quick and smooth. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Amenities were clean and well maintained. We had great time and will definitely be back soon!

Charles Peralo
2024-06-13 17:26:19 GMT

Really loved the hotel and everything about it.

Staff was extremely friendly.
Rooms were nice, minus a hard to figure out shower.
The location was probably the best put together spot in Montauk.

Joe Liotta
2024-07-08 17:46:57 GMT

Was a great experience. The location was centrally located right in the town, the room had some boutique looks to it. Very much enjoyed the stay.

Shayna Lehrer
2024-06-08 15:20:00 GMT

This place is beautiful. The people are accommodating and friendly. The atmosphere is outstanding. The location couldn’t be any better. This is my absolute favorite place to stay and I have been to many places. Can’t wait to come back!

Rob Moore
2024-06-21 18:45:42 GMT

Very nice hotel, king sized bed, outdoor pool with lounge chairs all around the pool, bar and food near the pool, 2 min walk to the beach, we really enjoyed our stay, we will definitely be back.

Ashley Panniello
2024-06-02 12:10:05 GMT

What a cute spot! Stayed on business for the night and it was perfect. Loved the vibe, friendly staff and a 2 min walk to the beach to catch the sunrise. I’ll be back. Thanks MBH!

Cherilyn K
2024-06-22 17:19:54 GMT

Beautiful oasis for relaxation, the Montauk Beach House has lovely rooms, a pool and garden with a vibe and is a brief walk from the beach, coffee shops and restaurants. I hope to come again soon!

Marissa Innella
2024-06-11 00:42:53 GMT

Beautiful pool and bar area! Quick walk to the beach. Right in the center of town! Will definitely book this hotel again!

Carol Fisher
2024-05-24 21:53:31 GMT

We just spent 2 nights at the MBH
We had a blast the staff was
Incredible the pool area beautiful
And the lounge area very chill we will def be back

Samuel Plimpton
2024-06-10 22:27:02 GMT

Enjoyable stay, responsive customer service. Great location. Not for families, very young and more of a scene to be seen.

Deanna Cannella
2024-05-29 16:05:06 GMT

What a great time we have had and will definitely be back!! We have been coming to mtk for years and this is the perfect gem. Thank you!

Bea “Bibi” Myerson
2024-06-01 15:49:49 GMT

Our room was spotless ….the property is beautiful & so well maintained.
Walk to town/restaurants

Marianne Branda
2024-05-24 19:47:51 GMT

Always a nice stay, cannot beat location and service this season greatly improved

Leyla Marchetto
2023-10-01 18:51:18 GMT

MBH is my favorite spot to spend a few hours in the sun with great bites, beverages and service. The place is always clean and they have great music as well as retail and you can even get left hand coffee 💕 The hotel also sponsors art and music events so there’s usually something culturally interesting going on!

Gloria Pope
2022-10-06 16:18:48 GMT

I stayed at the Montauk beach house and September when the weather started turning. The rooms were comfortable and cozy. The restaurants offer us delicious food! Very diverse menu.
The beach is a half a block!! This is a true winner! But most importantly the staff here is so sweet and helpful.
Prices are very reasonable, especially since everything in this area is very expensive. I will definitely be back! Gloria

Write a review of The Montauk Beach House


The Montauk Beach House Directions
About Gardiners Island
Island in Suffolk County, New York

Gardiner's Island is a small island in the Town of East Hampton, New York, in Eastern Suffolk County. It is located in Gardiner's Bay between the two peninsulas at the east end of Long Island. source

Top Rated Addresses in Gardiners Island