Pudgies Pizza

We had let minute plans to host a lunch for 60 people. I called at 1015, 45 before they opened and they answered! The gal who answered was so friendly, helpful and thankful for the call. The food was delivered promptly at 1245 as planned and was amazing!!! Thank you for for helping us out at the last minute. I love great food but the service was the icing on the cake. Very thankful and appreciative.

Very busy pizza shop. But I can see why. Its the first time I have ever been to Pudgies. The Stromboli was packed full and delicious. Bread sticks were good. Wings were perfectly spicy and sauced. Blue cheese dressing was awesome. The canolis were honestly the best I've had. It was not overly sweet. Im not a big canoli fan usually, but Pudgies did a phenomenal job. Staff was friendly and personable. We ate outside at the tables they setup. With social distancing applied.. Which was excellent because you got to see the cute town of Horseheads, NY. Historical Hanover square is well kept very quaint very cute. Thank you Pudgies.

Still as good as when I was a kid. Good pizza, lots of toppings. Great sauce. Friendly service. Got delivery- was supposed to take 45 mins- only took 20. It's pretty much everything the Watkins Pudgies isnt! And I got GF crust, really good. Pricey though.

I loved it! My husband and I stopped by to get the fish and it didn't disappoint!! Beautifully battered and fried Haddock with the works. Mac and cheese, coleslaw and of course I had to get a cannolli a Great meal!!!!

Every time we are in Horseheads we get Pudgies! Its great and different than what we get in Syracuse! Very consistent and tasty!

Their fish fry and coleslaw is extremely good. Their sheet pizza is a party staple for the area. Good food!

Brings me back to my childhood. Every time we would visit my family in NY my Grammy would have a big sheet pizza waiting. Stopped by again years later and still amazing

It's been around for a long time for a reason... They make good pizza. We all have different tastes, and I like most all pizzas, but Pudgies is as good as any of them and better than a lot of otheres, IMHO. I recommend take out, it's okay for eating in, but it has zero atmosphere.

Great pizza. Dunno why they’re not a bigger chain but would eat again.

Great pizza and pasta. Also, the garlic knots were the best.

Best pizza and subs I have ever had!!! Still the best!!!

Got two sheets for the Super Bowl and service was great! Food was delicious as always.

These guys are awesome! I had ordered online for the first time and didn't realize ordering a cheese and then selecting garlic as a topping meant there would be no sauce and my lil guy is a stickler for sauce and cheese. They remade a pizza for us right away free of charger to fix it and save the birthday boy's party. Would give them 6 stars for their service ❤ They definitely gained a loyal customer!

Had dinner here tonight & it was AMAZING! Ordered a medium meal deal and the cold Italian sub came EXACTLY as I ordered it with fries. It was SLAMMIN'! The subroll was SOOOOO SUPER SOFT & fresh!

Ordered my friend a 2-slice deal with 🐔-wing pizza and an order of wings.

I drive all the way from Pine City for a reason. Understand? THEY DO NOT DISAPPOINT!

I also picked-up the rest of a special order of PUDGIE'S HORSEHEADS HOODIES to ship to family in Japan!

THANK YOU for designing them, Kristen, they are so freaking awesome!!!!

If I was on death row, a Party Pack from Pudgies Horseheads would be my last meal. Keep raising the prices, I will keep paying. God bless.

Best Pizza in the upstate! We get this every time we travel up north, it's fantastic! We usually get the Party Pack: Sheet Pizza + 2 dozen wings, will feed the whole family + leftovers. Prices have increased over the years, but the quality has not declined at all, tastes the same as when I was a kid. Highly Recommend!

I have family in the area that I visit at least once a year. Every time I come, I make a point to visit Pudgies. Highly recommended!

While visiting some family in Horseheads from out of state, my Uncle Crow picked up pizza and wings from Pudgies Horseheads and it was all so delicious! The sauce on the wings is unlike anything we’ve been able to find anywhere else…mouthwatering with the best balance of flavors, and they were cooked perfectly. The sauce on the pizza was wonderful and the crust was soft with a hint of crisp on the edges which my kids loved and ate every last bite of. Such a great option for a family meal!!

I'm here back home for the day and had to have some of my favorite pizza! Definitely delicious and fresh as ever! Service amazing as well! Best pudgies around! Thank you to Laurie especially!

This place is always hopping they have the most amazing fish dinner on Friday nights. I prefer this one over the one in Watkins Glen. The staff at the Horseheads pudgies are so friendly and outstanding they do an awesome job.