Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

My husband and I go there about once a month. We order off the $10 daily special menu. Our order is always right, hot and fresh. The people there are friendly and always has a smile on their face. Would recommend this Salvatore's to anyone.

My most recent visit, on a Sunday evening was just to pick up a pizza order I called in. But it was ready on time when I arrived. Have frequented the Avon location many times. Most often just to pick up an order, but have eaten-in many times over the years. Staff has always been attentive and pleasant. Orders were complete and ready when I arrived. And they have the BEST pizza! I recommend them often to people who ask where the best pizza is in the area. They of course have many other food options, but I have not tried anything else. They are my go to for pizza! 🍕

First time taster of Salvatore Pizza. Called in an order for pickup. Medium thin crust pepperoni bacon kalmata olives and banana peppers. Ready on time. Good sized pizza. Hot and crispy. $26.95 total. Gave her 30.00 and told her to keep the change. Her face lit up!! Will definitely be a Salvatore Girl.

FINALLY a sub shop that knows how to do a Vegetarian Sub! They doubled the veggies and also warmed it for me (my request). VERY nice staff and QUICK service on a VERY busy day. Oh and a bonus? NAPKINS in our bag! Been a long time since a sub/pizza place put napkins in our bag. Thanks!

Fantastic service. To make a long, complex story very short - someone lied to the delivery driver and took our pizza. Salvatore's was on top of it, figured out what happened and remade and re-sent out food with absolutely no fuss. We will definitely be ordering again,

First of all, the new owners are wonderful and amazing with their customer service skills. I ordered a pizza and it is the best I have had in several years. The crust was perfectly baked and the toppings were not lacking in amounts. I couldn't resist the M&M cookie. No complaints there either. I definitely recommend this location!! P.S. The dining area was very clean also.

Food made exactly as ordered, fresh and friendly service

The best pizza my family and I had, we have been to other Salvatore locations in the past but this place beats them all with their great customer service and fast work! We definitely will come back again.

Holly Pizza!! AMAZING!! Salvatores in Avon... must try the Holly pie! Absolutely delicious! Artichokes, roasted red peppers, banana peppers, garlic & oil base- no sauce. Gooey mozzarella cheese cooked to perfection. I called the Manager to give a Holly shout out! I'm definitely ordering this again!!
Judy in Avon, NY

Friendly, pleasant staff. Ordered a whole pizza and fries. First pizza was too overcooked. They made another one that only took 10-15 minutes and offered a free dessert to make up for the wait. Pizza was absolutely delicious. And they had football on. Can't get better than that. Can't wait to visit again. I cant believe all the negative reviews I'm seeing.

Food delivered right on time!! Food arrived HOT and everything was DELICIOUS!! Elderly man that I care for was so HAPPY and IMPRESSED with all the food!! Definitely MADE his WHOLE DAY!! Thanks guys. You guys are doing awesome. Keep up the good work.

We order from this location at least once a week. They have great turkey subs!! Everything is ALWAYS consistently good and they have never messed up an order. The owner and all the staff is very friendly. He always makes sure things are good quality. Everything is always delicious here!

Staff was a great help in getting me the best combination of pizzas. They were ready when promised. Great food, great job! Thank you

Not my brother's pizza is AMAZING!!

My favorite pizza, I love the old fashion pepperoni and the delicious pizza sauce. Always been a consistent product in my experience.

The food is great, the employees treat you like family, and the value is unheard of! Met a great manager who made my ordering dinner for the family quick and easy, shout out to Steven! I had my food in ten minutes and the restaurant is 20 mins away at the LEAST. Thank you Salvatores!

We recently were in the area and our friend who lives in Avon recommended we try their food. I went for the Haddock fish fry and she went with the alfredo pasta dinner. Both were delicious. Our recent outing we went for the Alfredo pizza and man were we surprised with how great it was, so tasty. Definitely trying more pizzas soon and looking forward to the fried foods!

We placed an order for pick up on Super Bowl Sunday. Everything was fantastic! Thin crust meathead pizza, sweet country wings and mozzarella sticks. A little bit of a drive for us, but well worth it. Salvatore's will be our pizza place from now on!

Much improved under new ownership. We have tried several different menu items on different occasions and have had a great experience each time. It’s easy & convenient.. Keep up the good work!

Delicious food and ready on time.