Capt'n Con's Fish House

I had the clam strips with fries and coleslaw. Added a side of mashed potatoes and gravy. Everything was cooked perfectly and very tasty. Had the peanut butter pie for dessert, which was rich without being overbearing! Everything was delicious and homemade to perfection!

This is old Florida restaurant at the end of Pine Island. Our waitress was great and the atmosphere felt like we went back in time but with AC. We ate peel and eat shrimp, maybe the best we ever had, a hamburger and a fried flounder sandwich that stole the show.

Terrific experience, outdoor dining at Captain Con’s Fish House today. Our server, Karen, couldn’t have been more welcoming allowing us to sit down outside before the restaurant opened. When opened- She gave exceptional service. She was quick, kind, and our food was delicious, exactly what we wanted. We love this place. Great ambiance. Love the vibes.

Great little local gem tucked away on Pine Island. Eat at the bar and enjoy the banter with Daniel, who has excellent menu suggestions and is very friendly.

Serving portions are generous. Food was outstanding. Definitely get the grouper, the chowder and the chocolate coconut cream pie. Great value. Easy drive from Cape Coral. Not a tourist trap either, which is nice.

At first, we thought it looked mediocre, but we had grouper, shrimp wings, and onion rings. It was GREAT! We not only had great food, but we sat at the bar, and the bartenders were super friendly and great conversationalists! Karaoke sjnger was outstanding. We had a great night!

Went on Sunday for the seafood boil 10/10 so well cooked and seasoned and filling at a great price. Our server Denise was awesome and took great care of us! Before you leave make sure to get a slice of one of their delicious pies!

The meatloaf and fried mushrooms were great service was nice big helpings. I talked to a guy next to me at the bar and asked him what was good he said everything. I also visited the gift shop the jewelry is beautiful and fair priced hand made so I did get a few pair for the kids. TY

The food was amazing Mary Ann was really kind and she gave us excellent service I want to come back❤

Old school quaint, no frills place and food with an accompaniment of Florida charm from the people serving. Wonderful location, this isn't Michelin dining, but who wants Michelin in Florida??
It was quiet when we arrived, we were met with a smile, and everything came out in short order. The captains plate was massive. I could not eat it all. It was all fried, but it states that on the menu, it was all good, accompanied by a nice cocktail sauce (they also have tartar at each table) My wife had roast beef with gravy which she loved. And we took home rhubarb pie to have another day. These guys were hit hard by Ian, not as hard as many, but hard enough and they are still managing through damage, and kudos to them it doesn't show one bit. We will be back. I want to try the mussels.

Really really good food. Really good service. Famously delicious pies. A perfect view. What more could you want? It's a Pine Island landmark. Enjoy the old school vibe in this super casual place. We were here 20+years ago and are so happy it survived the pandemic.

A great destination place to soak up local color. Indoor and outdoors seating. The place sits on the farthest point on Pine Island. You can view the bay all around you.

Great food
3 or 4th time here
Never came out for the sunset before.It was absolutely wonderful

Our server Carrie was great. I will be back for Saturday night

Probably the best fish sandwich (Fried Grouper Sandwich) I have ever had. Waitress was fun, witty, charming, full of one liners. Sat outside and enjoyed the day...just wonderful. Will be back! Glad I found this place.

Took a drive out to Pine Island from Fort Myers, we stopped at Capt'n Cons. Had the best grouper sandwich I've ever had! Also don't skip on the pie! I will definitely make the drive again to eat here

What a lovely place for lunch and dinner :) so great to have a place on the 4th of July 🇺🇸for dinner :) we had two burgers and the grouper basket - fantastic service and the peanut butter pie 🥧
Best parking spot in Florida ☀

Yes they are open post Hurricane Ian!! I had the country fried steak lunch special $10.45. Boyfriend got the blackened grouper. DELICIOUS. Also the seafood chowder was hot and buttery. Cold beer and fantastic pies. One of Bokeelias best restaurants.

Stopped in today as part of a Sunday Drive.
Adorable and quaint with friendly service . Had the seafood chowder, great flavor with plenty of seafood. Had to try the famous Peanut Butter pie and it did not disappoint. Probably the best I ever had.

This place serves 14 different homemade pies. I'm almost tempted not to review it because it seems like the best kept secret on the island. Lots of locals and motorcycle riders. It's not an upscale place but that probably helps keep away the jerks. My blackened grouper basket was on par with any other great seafood restaurant.

This is a great place with friendly servers and a fantastic view of the water. It wasn't busy outside where we were sitting in the shade, watching the pelicans. No liquor here. But we each had a huge beer, very reasonably priced. The entire place was decorated for Christmas. Including a Christmas tree in the ladies. As I was leaving I noticed a small bar in the back that looked like it was filled with regulars. Something to check out next time along with the seafood.

Went back with my friend from Georgia & we both had the combo basket. The shrimp & clams were really good. The deviled crab was your standard fare, nothing special. The beer was cold! The views were great!