Sugar Daddy's Toy Store

Every toy you can imagine in this perfect tucked away magical toy store in Westhampton Beach!!!

Highlight of our day trip to the beach was stumbling on to this very cool store ! Both my 9 and 6 year old found toys that they were so happy with . This store owner must know what kids love - all the classics that can’t easily be found at really great prices ! Thank you for ending our family outing day with extra smiles !!! If you are in the area stop by with the kids both young and old - something for toy lovers of all ages .

Amazing place, we come here quite often and so far we haven’t had a bad experience! Wonderful!

This place is amazing! They have everything.

This is everything a good toy store should be!! Literally a dream come true for a young kid.. The collection of toys and games, everything from classics to collectibles, are clearly curated by a true toy connoisseur.. There was a great selection of toys for my children to choose from, and as I scanned the shelves I was basically transported back to my childhood.. The quality of most of the products here is impressive.. There are some simple and cheap options as well as some very expensive collector’s items and models.. Every time we stop in we leave with something cool, but I’d be happy just to stop in and browse the eye candy!! If you’re in downtown Westhampton Beach with a little time to kill, visit Sugar Daddy’s for a blast from the past!!

They had lots of items to kids toys to high end collectibles. The only issue was the staff wasn’t friendly, to greet when going into the store. It’s really far from home so I may not go unless in the area. It’s definitely worth it to check it and support a local business. I got some Star Wars figures I’ve never seen in any other stores any where on Long Island.

My son and I traveled far to check this store out on saturday april 3 . We weren’t greeted, even though two workers a older male and young girl, walked by us twice. I walk with a cane and I heard the owner / older gentleman say to the girl in the joining store. “Oh yeah!” go in and look” then laugh. SHAME ON BOTH OF YOU! I wouldn’t spend a dime in your store. Nasty and no service whats so ever. I guess you have a problem with people who are handicapped !