Amagansett Hardware

Shopped as an out of town guest (tourist). Very friendly service and local information. Even though fairly busy. Took the time with our questions and needs. Enjoyed our experience. Felt confident in our purchases and information given.

The store is amazing in how many products it Carrie’s and how helpful the staff are at solving specific problems. Very convenient and great hours.

As a longtime resident in Napeague, i rely on the friendly and informative employees who run this store. I value there advice because they help me solve everything from plumbing to pest issues.

Really friendly and helpful. Talked to the guy inside for ten minutes. Got exactly what I needed.

Herbert is a cool dude.

Picked up parts for a toilet. They had what I needed.

While visiting the Hamptons they charged me for a propane fill up, despite not having a propane tank with me. They refused to credit me the charge

Least helpful hardware store ever. Without fail, a disappointment.

I was looking at sweatshirts when the shop clerk accused me of stealing a candy bar (referring to my wallet that was very clearly sticking out of my pocket.) He then attempted bumblingly to explain himself without ever actually apologizing to me about accusing me of something I did not do. Then the man at the cash register could not have cared any less that I was waiting to buy something, he just chatted away to someone until finally deciding to ask me if I was ready to check out (after clearly having been ready and stood in front of him for 5 minutes)

NOTE: They close at 5pm, not 6pm. REVIEW: They are very rude. Plus won't take returns, even if you walk out and walk immediately back in to return. Also $12 card minimum.

Incredibly rude, unhelpful and overpriced.

high prices, rude atention, no costumers in store, thats why